In the wake of FriendFeed+Facebook, I get the feeling it might be better to move the "conversation" to a service like Disqus rather than something like Google Reader. The model could be start your own Tumblr/Wordpress blog + Disqus, then sub to everyone you know via Disqus
you like tumblr vs posterous...I started using tumblr the idea...they have tons of themes being developed everyday! I like posterous aggregation way better though!
- AlexKaris
Tumblr, Posterous, Wordpress... it fundamentally doesn't matter. My broader point is to take control of your own sharing platform, but then tack on distributed commenting/conversation vs just moving from one aggregator to another.
- Ken Sheppardson
Not a good model - too much overhead to maintain for the people who would otherwise want to be part of the conversation. (Like me.)
- Jason Miller
Yeah, I can see how that might be the case, Jason. Hm.
- Ken Sheppardson
I'm a huge fan of google reader. Not a fan of discussions on there though. I do, however, like Disqus.
- Beau Liening
from iPhone
What Jason said. Good idea but the model breaks down for people who don't feel like creating a Disqus account.
- Laura Norvig
Is it a bad idea to just stay with what you have until it actually has changes you don't like?
- Matt Hilton
I have a feeling that Google Wave will play a big part soon.
- Mark Layton
A smart client could also use the Backtype API to show blog posts your friends reply on, even if the blog doesn't use Disqus. Come to think of it, it would be nice if Backtype would also aggregate "likes" of posts. For example, FriendFeed "likes" and Posterous/Tumblr "favorites".
- Meryn Stol
a wavelet provides access control. It provides a branch where participants can be different from another branch.
- Ahsan Ali aka. Slick
a wave, itself, can also have participants: which implies they can see/control all the wavelets
- Ahsan Ali aka. Slick
I've written a bot that creates a post on FF for every blip... but it's not feasible. The alternative is to create a comment for every blip .. and thereby lose all formatting/photos.
- Ahsan Ali aka. Slick
Hmm, I should flesh out the FF side of it. An FF Post can have participants. A Comment has an author.
- Ahsan Ali aka. Slick
From the Wave docs: "Waves are hosted live conversations between multiple participants". Excellent definition.
- Ahsan Ali aka. Slick
Now if only I could get a login for Wave!
- Rick Cogley
Rick, you will if you have applied for it ! Surprisingly, many people haven't.
- Ahsan Ali aka. Slick
from IM
I'll need to update this mind-map further. Will post an updated one later.
- Ahsan Ali aka. Slick
I've applied, but it looks like I'm waiting for the September invitations.
- JR Holmes
from iPod
I think anyone working in tech - not just programmers - can get access to the sandbox. You just have to pitch them a good reason :)
- Ahsan Ali aka. Slick
You forgot that on Friendfeed, a post also has addressees. Addressing specific people on FriendFeed also allows for access control, since the post/thread/conversation will be private. If you post something to a private group (and not your home feed), the whole group will have access (and not the public).
- Meryn Stol
It's a pity FF doesn't allow me to edit/reattach inline images ;)
- Ahsan Ali aka. Slick
Sounds too complicated to start a new technology off with. They need to start more simple.
- Jesse Stay
Jesse, the map is from a technical perspective .. visually, you'd just see a threaded conversation with (optionally) private sections. It is interesting, however, how much FF has achieved with a relatively simple model. Maybe their success is _because_ it was simple ?
- Ahsan Ali aka. Slick
Yeah, the friendfeed side of this mindmap is very simplified right now. I really think Google Wave will run into some mainstream challenges for what I've read so far (don't have wave account yet). However, aren't you really just displaying the threaded feature of a Wavelet? That would just be the ability to comment to a comment in FriendFeed.
- manielse (Mark Nielsen)
manielse, yes. The major difference between the two is threading.. except in Wave, a comment is equal to a post itself (with photos, rich text, etc, multiple participants). Hence the recursive nature of the tree. A comment (blip) can have a reply, which can have a reply in turn.. and so on)
- Ahsan Ali aka. Slick
But these are features that some of the FF users have wanted, to reply back to a comment and also with a richer content such as a diagram that explains the topic better.
- manielse (Mark Nielsen)
Ahsan, I know how it looks visually - I'm on the dev sandbox. I still say it's too complicated for an initial launch. They need to start simple, the Google way.
- Jesse Stay
Google Wave is all about potential. In a sense, it's like handing someone a copy of Visual Studio or Eclipse and saying, 'Okay, now go build what you want!' The majority of people will say, 'Uh... what?'
- Akiva Moskovitz
Akiva, agreed. That's why they haven't released it to the public yet.
- Jesse Stay
Interesting comment, Joelle. I wonder if Microsoft will branch off from the Wave server protocol at some point, like they did with XML, and do their own thing. :) Interesting times, ahead.
- Ahsan Ali aka. Slick
Ahsan -- what a great post! Pure gold. (And I happen to think that Google Wave is the wave (oops) of the future. But I need to get hands on with it for a few days to be sure.
- Sean McBride
Glad you liked it, Sean. Be sure to view the updated version (see the link I've edited into the original post).
- Ahsan Ali aka. Slick
I didnt have a precise enough project to make it into the closed access, apart from having written time and time again that what we should have and want was an open standard, distributed system matching nearly word for word the wave press release... (although the reality will probably be different). AM more interested in what can be done on a node basis than writing bots.
- Joelle Nebbe (iphigenie)
A key question in my mind: will Google Wave feel more cluttered than Friendfeed? The beauty of Friendfeed is the simplicity of the look and feel. Will more power features reduce the impression of simplicity and clarity?
- Sean McBride
You really can't compare FriendFeed and GoogleWave, they're both completely different things. Google Wave is a set of technologies that I feel will contribute heavily to the next generation of social networking tools, however it will not replace them. http://jaredquinn.info/article...
- Jared Quinn
To answer Sean's question, the interface itself looks pretty, but inside the wave it can be difficult to manage: I don't like some of the keyboard shortcuts; the threading in a live chat becomes confusing. While the windowing is slick, you feel like you need more space (at least on my monitor). They need to work on the UI (see Jesse's points above).
- Ahsan Ali aka. Slick
It's nearly certain that people and companies will come up with different client "front end" apps which are slicker to use, focused on using wave for a specific purpose - live chat/discussion, document management, information sharing, location enabled services, archive access, tech support, games...
- Joelle Nebbe (iphigenie)
"the threading in a live chat becomes confusing" (I wondered about that from the first moment I saw a Google Wave demo -- it looked busy and noisy...)
- Sean McBride
We strip the threading out then, sean..... non threaded real time conversations work perfectly well here on FF.
- Roberto Bonini
Roberto -- I need to actually use Google Wave in threadless mode to compare it to Friendfeed. Can't wait....
- Sean McBride
"Today, there are only seven living species of sea turtles worldwide and members of five or six of these species manage to visit Vallarta annually. Six of the seven species have hard shells and only one has a soft shell; it’s the leatherback turtle, the largest of them all and a periodic visitor to Vallarta. The leatherbacks grow for 30 years, from hatchlings weighing about an ounce, to maturity weighing up to 1,300 pounds and measuring up to 7 feet long and 5 feet wide; they can live to be more than 80 years old."
- M F
from Bookmarklet
This guy subscribes to a different definition of 'intelligence' than me. I know he did it to build up to the punchline about them returning every year, but still...
- Eivind
Well yes I bet these turtles are not very familiar with algebra or PHP and they might not have a moral code or watch Big Brother, but they seem to be doing well what they are supposed to do which is still an achievement although I don't know if I would define it "intelligence". I am not always sure that being endowed with intelligence is always a blessing though but that's another issue altogether.
- M F
They are getting the real time religion. I'm here with Khris Loux and Chris Saad. Hanging out at the Oola restaurant/bar on Folson. Hi Mike!
- Robert Scoble
But I wonder, do most blogs get enough activity that real-time would be interesting? They already offer mini-chat, which is a neat idea.
- invariant - farewell FF
Don: sit on that man. thats your retirement money
- Sweyn Venderbush
Yo JS-Kit dudes. Does that stand for "javascript kittens"?
- RobinDotNet
It's true, real-time matters much less on a blog... If a blog post only gets 10 comments over the period of a week, do you care if they are real-time? Hah
- Colin
My CMS provider uses JS-Kit and it works fairly well, but getting real time comments is defiantly the way to go. Make the move to real time JS!
- Rodman
Well, the kitten sold me, even though I understand Chinese as well as I understand Greek.
- RobinDotNet
Looks interesting; I'll pass on to my PM for perusal.
- RobinDotNet
Since you said "really cool", the upcoming features probably don't include the boring one I asked for.
- Bruce Lewis
Bruce: what boring features did you ask for?
- Robert Scoble
I want a comment system that can be used with unlisted/noindex URLs, such that comments made on those URLs don't end up in people's public profiles. If some other comment system besides Disqus implements it first, then there will be two comment system options on OurDoings in no time.
- Bruce Lewis
Awesome, love the features of their comment system. ONLY one thing missing that I saw. When I put in my email address - I was SURE it was going to go grab my gravatar. I did notice it gets avatars from twitter, facebook, etc...but in leiu of that, gravatar :)
- Justin Hopkins
from twhirl
hi JS-Kit! I haven't use your service. But I surely want to know what cool thing you geeks are cooking :D
- Toni @ NavinoT
Well hi there - I am living proof the real time web is exactly 44 minutes behind schedule. :)
- Jack Humphrey
h' bday Chris ! (well if you were in Aus I guess; so keep drinking till after midnight and read this then!)
- David HC Soul
I think I put everyone to sleep over there with my boring details. Hey, Scobleizer did ask. And he could have given us hints about upcoming cool features.
- Bruce Lewis
hello, and hi to the real time real web! ..does JS-Kit plan run Google Friend Connect?
- Petr Buben
@Petr JS-Kit already has Google Friend Connect implemented as a login option
- Chris Saad
@David heya mate - thanks for the bday love!
- Chris Saad
@Chris. I see. thank you .... well, are you also running this bar ? or, do you plan to ... anyways, very nice site, and widgets! will have to give it a shot :]
- Petr Buben