Beyoncé, Scarlett Johansson or Jessica Alba? - Andrew Trinh

is there a 4th choice? - Yolanda

God dammit! Andrew, they're all hot. You damn bastard. - Matt Ruiz

@Yolanda++++ - Shevonne

Scarlett - ★Kristy

None of these ladies, Yolanda/Shevonne? - Andrew Trinh

Johansson...aside from the physical, I think should would be the better conversationalist. - JA Castillo

What Yolanda and Shevonne said. Obviously. - Derrick

Derrick, that's cheating. Let's say everyone had to pick ONE of these ladies, who would you choose (not necessarily based on physical appearance)? - Andrew Trinh from IM

I guess I would choose Scarlett. I wouldn't choose Jessica Alba because she is ashamed of her latin roots. Beyonce still annoys me with how she handled the whole Destiny's Child thing. Scarlett hasn't done anything to irritate me, so if we are not basing it on looks and I have to choose one, then Scarlett. - Shevonne

Scarlett - Scoble, Alex Scoble

It all depends on the criteria. I don't know what any of them are like IRL, so it's hard to say. - Tinfoil 2.0

I suspect that Beyoncé & Jessica Alba are both quite high maintenance, so they lose points for that. - Tinfoil 2.0

If there's no other choice - Scarlett - Spidra Webster

Beyonce appetizer, Scarlett! main course, Jessica dessert - Adrian

Scarlett! - AJ Kohn

Well, if I have to choose, I'd like to hang out with Scarlett. She might have some interesting stories to tell. - Yolanda

+1 Mark - Robert Miller

Scarlett - Arawak

Smart choice, Mark haha. - Andrew Trinh

Umm. Scarlett because she puts me to sleep in every film she's in and I have chronic insomnia? - Pixie

Scarlet handsdown. - vijay

Definitely Scarlett for me - Wang Yip

Beyonce is just dos muchos, Jessica Alba? Meh. And I'm still hating on Scarlett for A) Lost in Translation, and B) Marrying Ryan Reynolds. - Derrick

yonce, then alba, then scarlett - chrisofspades

Scarlett Johansson seems to be the clear winner so far because she seems to have more brains and personality than the other two (or she puts you to sleep if you're a chronic insomniac…interpret that as you will). One point goes to Mark Essel's lady. - Andrew Trinh

Jessica by a close margin. - Josh Haley

+1 for Scarlett - ronin

ALL OF THE ABOVE. I CAN HAZ. PLZ? - AJ Batac (/-_-)

Scarlet. Absolutely. - Joey Gibson

Alba...yummmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm. - Beau Liening

Scarlett... - Zee.

Beyonce! - MutfakTeyze

yes, Scarlett.. period. - Gtp19

i think i have a prob. since i only see scarlette... :))) - Atif UNALDI

my wife blows these ladies out of the water. sorry, no bikini-clad pics. just take my word for it... :) - Scott Magdalein

Drop Alba for Ayumi Hamasaki and you've got my ultimate 4some! As much as I like the others, for me it has to be Scarlett as she genuinely seems to have a personality. Oh and my mum's blonde with big tits so according to the Oedipus complex I really had no choice in the matter! - Toby Graham

@haggis - oh yeah, LOL. I ain't lyin', huh! - Scott Magdalein

Your wife blows WHUT? - Andrew Trinh

@trinh - ahem... ;) - Scott Magdalein

scarlett :D - آریــوبرزن

Milla Jovovich? Morena Baccarin? Jewel Staite? - Ordinarybug Heather

Jessica Alba, duh - Outsanity

scarlett, cuz everyone knows Beyonce' is a bitch and I have already seen Jessica naked. - Lokei Atikus™®

what's the question? I pick D, all of the above - Bryan R. Adams

I'm pretty sure Jessica Alba is the only right answer. Ever. - Heather Whoapants

Scarlett Johansson...tho that Tom Waits cover album makes it iffy. - Joe Silence

I'd go with Scarlett, but dang that photo of her is awful. - Tristan Seligmann

i dunno, i think the only bad part is the expression on her face. it's like she's waiting for you to discover the poop she smeared on your chin while you were napping. - Joe Silence

Scarlett Johansson hands down :) - Ac0n (former Franc)

ooo, Scarlett - Imabug

Scarlett. - Parth Awasthi

Ok crikey!! Nurse! - Kevin J Hatton

Can't believe Alba doesn't get everyone's vote. Well +1 Jessica Alba. - TobiasVerhoog.com

Alba is good looking and photographs well, but Scarlett looks like she means business... when it comes down to business. Just a guess. - Adrian

Beyonce. Have you seen her thighs? #oohgirl - Zulema ❧ spicy cocoa tart from iPhone

Scarlett - Alex Scrivener

Scarlett だろJK - YungSang from FriendFooV2

Beyoncé. She'd make me laugh, and then she'd teach me the "Single Ladies" dance, which would make her laugh. We'd have fun. - Ayşe E.

...yes - Cardeen winedrunk

Even though I can't stand her music, Beyonce. The other two, while pretty, could use a sandwich or a bowl of grits....just sayin. - Rahsheen the Dream

None of the above, it would've been Scarlett hands down till she stole my boyfriend Ryan Reynolds. Bitch. - sofarsoShawn <Pop-Rocks>

Yup, Rah. - Ayşe E.

Scarlett - Brandon

Scarlett! - Shawn Farner

Mmmm Jessia Albaaa - Will Higgins™

Jess! - David Cook

Rah, this is the first time I heard someone say that Scarlett could use a sandwich. - Bryan R. Adams

I'll have Scarlett and Jessica, you can keep Beyonce. - Mellissa

Just Beyoncé :)) - Mahdi Ebrahimi

Salma. Oh, not a choice. Damn. - Ben Hanten

Scarlett - Vezquex

Alba - Mohamed J

Scarlett and Jessica. - zooz

Scarlett first. And fourth, and seventh, ... - Andrew C (✓)

Based on these photos Scarlett - Erfun

Jessica Alba no doubt - Rodfather

Scarlett no doubt - Durukan Duru

Beyonce. I only like ethnic women, and I especially love ethnic women with curves. - Mark Davidson from BuddyFeed

I've always been a huge fan of Jessica Alba('s body), but I'm gunna have to go with Scarlett Johansson. - Matthew Horton

jessica... - Erfan342

Scarlett - Serkan Ünsal

Jessica Alba. - Peter Kruit

If this had been posed circa Dark Angel, well, no contest. But Scarlett has since dethroned Ms. Alba. Oh, though even circa Dark Angel, if you replaced Beyonce with Original Cindy, I'd have problems choosing. - Michael W. May

I'll let them do the fighting. Whoever wins can have me. - Ruud van Wijngaarden

Scarlett any day of the week. - Nathan Chase

Beyonce - مهکامه

J. Alba. - Ümit Orhan

Alba - eljayblue