Tim O'Reilly › Comments

"This bit was taken a bit out of context. My point was that if novels matter to customers, they will survive. They don't need special protection. I was reacting to a conversation that I had on Charlie Rose that struck me as very entitled. I had made a comparison to classical music, making the point that what we consider "classical music" was once popular. And that when we got this mindset that classical music needed special funding and protection, it became increasingly disconnected from what people really wanted to hear. I love fiction and consider it a great art form. But if it really matters, it will survive. And meanwhile, it will continue to evolve." - Tim O'Reilly

Hi,Good Day!!! My name is Miss Armela, I pray that this letter meets you well,though we never meet or seen each other before, but I believe that nature has a way of bringing people together for specific purposes.(miss.armela @yahoo.com) If you need a friend Email me back - Mac Mercy

"Aaron didn't actually release the JSTOR downloads. He did some research on the downloaded corpus. If someone did the same for Safari, I might well have been intrigued and asked for a copy of the research. It's true that if Aaron had actually released all the bulk-downloaded data, in despite of the copyright owner's wishes, he would have been doing something I wouldn't approve of. If you look at my history on the subject, I am all about finding the right balance between open and closed. E.g. when bookshare.org asked for copies of my company's books for scanning, I said, "Why don't we just send you the files?" Now almost all publishers do that." - Tim O'Reilly

very good book to much enrich and for one front information managmet system whit ITIL 4.0 - gabriel eduardo moya

"What a great framework you've laid out for exploration, Edd! I can't wait for future installments in this series. In the meantime, what O'Reilly books would you recommend to get a head start in each of these areas?" - Tim O'Reilly

"I totally agree with your thinking here, Joe." - Tim O'Reilly

"Yes, fantastic observation." - Tim O'Reilly

"What a great observation! Local businesses used to do this the human way, without technology." - Tim O'Reilly

"Just because Napster was shut down didn't mean that the future of music wasn't online.... Whether Uber succeeds or not, we can look forward to hailing cabs on our phones with a system much like it." - Tim O'Reilly

"That's an important and thought-provoking point, Alasdair. A world without cash simplifies user experience, but creates many new issues, both the credit-divide issue you highlight here, but also privacy." - Tim O'Reilly

"I didn't know Corwin well; I wish I had. The stories told here are a testament to how he lives on in the lives of others. I am reminded of Auden's poem on the death of W.B. Yeats: "Now he is scattered among a hundred cities And wholly given over to unfamiliar affections, To find his happiness in another kind of wood And be punished under a foreign code of conscience. The words of a dead man Are modified in the guts of the living." I also think of Wallace Stevens, as if reflecting on Corwin's intense physicality: "The greatest poverty is not to live In a physical world, to feel that one's desire Is too difficult to tell from despair. Perhaps, After death, the non-physical people, in paradise, Itself non-physical, may, by chance, observe The green corn gleaming and experience The minor of what we feel. The adventurer In humanity has not conceived of a race Completely physical in a physical world." and, Stevens again, reflecting on death and continuance: "How red the rose that is the..." - Tim O'Reilly

"I hear you, Normm. Of course, Xerox themselves later sued Apple, so their earlier spirit of "hey, if you can do something with this, that's great" evaporated in the face of later events. But in any event, the main point of the article stands: copying doesn't inhibit innovation. It may enhance it, as companies need to run faster to stay ahead of those who copy them. You could argue that it inhibits the profits of those who innovate - but it's hard to make that argument today in the face of Apple's enormous success, and their determined attempts to lock-in customers to their entire product suite. So copying by Samsung (to the extent it's happening) is definitely pro-consumer and pro-competitive. And frankly, the idea that Apple can somehow protect the whole idea of the tablet or smartphone is fairly extreme. The iPhone and Android phones are sufficiently different that I find myself having trouble going back and forth between the two. Most of the deepest similarities are in third-party..." - Tim O'Reilly

тупизм - Radion2000

apples creates waves on the markets - Estel Efimova

"I agree with your basic point here, but your historical analogy for Apple stretches the facts pretty far. There are decades between Apple's near-death experience after Windows rather than the Mac dominated the windows and mouse paradigm, and their resurgence with Mac OS X, then the iPhone. But it's very true that Apple didn't lose out to Microsoft because of copying.  In fact, the original Mac interface was itself inspired by the Xerox Alto and other work at PARC.  That's the real disingenuous part of Apple's argument.  They copied from Xerox, and the Microsoft copied from them.  But in each case, it was execution (and business model) that made the difference." - Tim O'Reilly

"Evan - the fact that people build proprietary cloud services on top of open source is not news. I highlighted that fact a decade ago in my talks on "The Open Source Paradigm Shift." It's not only not news, it's the way things work. Open platforms always create new value that is captured by people who close the system down in some ways. But we're all better off from the dance. Roger's post is not open source "triumphalism" but a statement about how open source and proprietary, revolutionary and enterprise, have learned to coexist. There is plenty of room still for new open source innovation. The notion that if everything isn't open source, we've somehow failed is a bankrupt notion. My own thinking about open source has always been shaped more by the generosity of the Berkeley/MIT/Apache/Internet approach - here's our work, build on it however you will - than on the hyper-controlling approach of the GPL. There's no question in my mind which of those approaches has created more value for..." - Tim O'Reilly

"I think you misconstrued my post. I wasn't arguing that technology kills jobs (although I do think that it kills some jobs, at the same time as it creates others), but that the relentless drive to squeeze labor costs out of business misses a major point: that those same businesses depend on consumers having the income to purchase their products. There's a kind of long-term madness in the pursuit of short-term advantage that is starting to bite Western economies in a big way. And much as I admire and support the craftsman, the entrepreneur, and the move up the skills ladder, I think you have to recognize that we are moving away from a culture where there were lots of well-paying jobs that were essentially repetitive (and hence easily automatable), and that to replace those jobs with something more creative will require a major retooling of the economy." - Tim O'Reilly

my name is Vera i saw your profile and became interested in you,i have something very important to share with you write to me in my email address (vera43@yahoo com)not on the site i need your help pl - Vera Apollo

"So interesting.  I did a version of my "Towards a Global Brain" last night, which ends with the slide "We've got one world. We've got to get it right."  In the Q&A, one of the questions brought back to mind Jay Winik's book, The Great Upheaval, which is a tale of three revolutions: The American, the French, and one at about the same time in Russia, which was brutally put down by Catherine the Great. They represent a nice spread on the possibilities.  If we truly make it new, as the American Revolution did, we have a bright future.  If we let the Revolution devolve into rivalries that grow ever more acrimonious, we get the French. And then there's always the possibility of the Old Guard intervening forcefully to keep the new from happening." - Tim O'Reilly

"Marshall - Sorry to appear to have confirmed your story. A while back, I saw some of the same research you refer to here, and when I saw Steve Case's tweet about a product being announced at SXSW, I thought "cool, they made it into a product." I hadn't clicked through to your story, and didn't realize it was just speculation." - Tim O'Reilly

"Marshall - Sorry to appear to have confirmed your story. A while back, I saw some of the same research you refer to here, and when I saw Steve Case's tweet about a product being announced at SXSW, I thought "cool, they made it into a product." I hadn't clicked through to your story, and didn't realize it was just speculation." - Tim O'Reilly

"One-click is one of Amazon's biggest advantages, since once you have an account there, it reduces shopping friction. The biggest opportunity for products like Paypal and Google Checkout is to recreate that frictionless experience across any retailer who doesn't have the breadth of Amazon. Major merchants fighting Amazon shouldn't be requiring customers to create accounts; they should piggyback on existing payment players with network effects. Osama Bedier, who was the CTO at Paypal, and is now running payment technology for Google, remarked to me the other day that the only reason for taking a payment mechanism (from cash to credit cards) is because it increases sales. Once you realize that, you understand that using new payment mechanisms to reduce the friction of buying, and to increase the ease by which people can buy without registering (again), is absolutely critical." - Tim O'Reilly

EXACTLY! That is what I have been trying to tell all those GBF's who think that Amazon is going to pick up Google Check out. Will they? I'm not 'in the know' so only my future will tell. My thoughts? WHY WOULD THEY? - Heidi Jacobson

"Can reports be interfaces? Sure, but are they? Consider as a thought experiment the difference between a paper map, or even first generation online maps, and what you experience now with mapping on your phone. The map is now an interface to data and services - what's nearby, how to get from one place to another, how long it will take by car, by public transit, by bicycle, or on foot, which of your friends are in the neighborhood, and much more. That's a data visualization as an interface. Statistical visualizations can also be interfaces. Check out the cool demo of Microsoft's Pivot interface. http://www.microsoft.com/press... This is the same kind of approach that Bloom is taking to visualization as interface. But stick with the map example, and think on how a shift of framing can help you turn an output-only visualization into a set of new affordances." - Tim O'Reilly

"One-click is one of Amazon's biggest advantages, since once you have an account there, it reduces shopping friction. The biggest opportunity for products like Paypal and Google Checkout is to recreate that frictionless experience across any retailer who doesn't have the breadth of Amazon. Major merchants fighting Amazon shouldn't be requiring customers to create accounts; they should piggyback on existing payment players with network effects. Osama Bedier, who was the CTO at Paypal, and is now running payment technology for Google, remarked to me the other day that the only reason for taking a payment mechanism (from cash to credit cards) is because it increases sales. Once you realize that, you understand that using new payment mechanisms to reduce the friction of buying, and to increase the ease by which people can buy without registering (again), is absolutely critical." - Tim O'Reilly

"Can reports be interfaces? Sure, but are they? Consider as a thought experiment the difference between a paper map, or even first generation online maps, and what you experience now with mapping on your phone. The map is now an interface to data and services - what's nearby, how to get from one place to another, how long it will take by car, by public transit, by bicycle, or on foot, which of your friends are in the neighborhood, and much more. That's a data visualization as an interface. Statistical visualizations can also be interfaces. Check out the cool demo of Microsoft's Pivot interface. http://www.microsoft.com/press... This is the same kind of approach that Bloom is taking to visualization as interface. But stick with the map example, and think on how a shift of framing can help you turn an output-only visualization into a set of new affordances." - Tim O'Reilly

"I love the fresh thinking Romer displays. It is so easy to go down the same rutted roads to the same bleak destinations. It's great when someone comes up with a new idea. I hope someone has the guts to try this. Or try it again, since the historical precedents are compelling." - Tim O'Reilly

"I love the fresh thinking Romer displays. It is so easy to go down the same rutted roads to the same bleak destinations. It's great when someone comes up with a new idea. I hope someone has the guts to try this. Or try it again, since the historical precedents are compelling." - Tim O'Reilly

"I love the fresh thinking Romer displays. It is so easy to go down the same rutted roads to the same bleak destinations. It's great when someone comes up with a new idea. I hope someone has the guts to try this. Or try it again, since the historical precedents are compelling." - Tim O'Reilly

"See my comment here, riffing off Katrin Eismann's question about this: http://www.facebook.com/profile......" - Tim O'Reilly

"See my comment here, riffing off Katrin Eismann's question about this: http://www.facebook.com/profil..." - Tim O'Reilly

"See my comment here, riffing off Katrin Eismann's question about this: http://www.facebook.com/profile......" - Tim O'Reilly

"I agree with you, Andrew. I've always disliked the moralistic approach to copyright. I dislike the direction of our copyright laws, which give near-perpetual protection even to works that are abandoned by their owners, and that's a real problem. And our patent system is worse, granting rights for "inventions" that are obvious, or have never even actually been made. But in general, I prefer arguments that make the practical case for sharing rather than some kind of moral case. That's what I wrote about in my essay Piracy is Progressive Taxation http://openp2p.com/pub....... and in the piece about free software that I wrote for Nature entitled Information Wants to Be Valuable http://www.nature.com/nature......" - Tim O'Reilly

Tim, both links in your comment are dead. - earlyadopter

"I agree with you, Andrew. I've always disliked the moralistic approach to copyright. I dislike the direction of our copyright laws, which give near-perpetual protection even to works that are abandoned by their owners, and that's a real problem. And our patent system is worse, granting rights for "inventions" that are obvious, or have never even actually been made. But in general, I prefer arguments that make the practical case for sharing rather than some kind of moral case. That's what I wrote about in my essay Piracy is Progressive Taxation http://openp2p.com/pub....... and in the piece about free software that I wrote for Nature entitled Information Wants to Be Valuable http://www.nature.com/nature......" - Tim O'Reilly

"I agree with you, Andrew. I've always disliked the moralistic approach to copyright. I dislike the direction of our copyright laws, which give near-perpetual protection even to works that are abandoned by their owners, and that's a real problem. And our patent system is worse, granting rights for "inventions" that are obvious, or have never even actually been made. But in general, I prefer arguments that make the practical case for sharing rather than some kind of moral case. That's what I wrote about in my essay Piracy is Progressive Taxation http://openp2p.com/pub/a/p2p/2... and in the piece about free software that I wrote for Nature entitled Information Wants to Be Valuable http://www.nature.com/nature/d..." - Tim O'Reilly

"Chaim, Allen - I'm sure that we can arrange an "out of shopping cart" sale - just send an email to tim at oreilly and we'll find a way to make it happen for you." - Tim O'Reilly