"If you combine Project Natal with Emotiv's neuroheadset you could create an amazing interface - full body motion plus thought control - really post-human type interaction. The only thing missing would be sensory feedback."
- Daniel Mietchen
from Bookmarklet
Daniel says on the last slide, "The issue is whether or not to do science in the open, especially if you are a young researcher." This issue really hit home with me tonight, as today I finally assembled all the OKs from collaborators and program managers to carry out our DNA unzipping / chromatin mapping experiments as open science. Such a relief to get everyone on board, and very exciting...especially if we actually manage to get funded :)
- Steve Koch
The presentation also raised an interesting issue for me, the first time I've seen attribution stacking really occur in practice. Some of the slides that Daniel re-used have images which I grabbed from flickr. Daniel has left my attribution to the original image in place but also attributed the slides to me (and Bjoern and others). The risk is you end up with slides covered in...
more...
- Cameron Neylon
@Cameron: Good question. I think that's overdoing it. Credit the original and you're fine. Personally, I rarely use the slides as they are and constantly tweak them here or there such that eventually, they may have originated from some place but look fairly different even though the content may be still very similar. If so much own contributions have gone in there, isn't demanding attribution like being more catholic than the pope?
- Björn Brembs
I noticed these attribution stacks too and thought about removing them. However, the talk was targeted at a rather uninitiated audience, and so I left them in and pointed out on one slide that I am, in the spirit of the whole talk, reusing slides from someone who has reused them from someone else, even though they do not necessarily know each other personally. In the long run, I would...
more...
- Daniel Mietchen
"The results of the study show that wealthier countries, though they have predominantly better science and enforcement capabilities, face the negative repercussions of excessive subsidies and larger fishing capacity, which have resulted largely from increased modernization of national fleets. The only attribute in which poorer and wealthier countries overlapped significantly was their limited ability to convert scientific recommendations into policy. "
- Daniel Mietchen
from Bookmarklet
"is it possible to measure the contribution, even relative, of a scientist in any particular field without bias by relying on metrics? The answer is no."
- Daniel Mietchen
from Bookmarklet
right he is, though it might be useful to remind him of the possibility of post-publication peer review.
- Daniel Mietchen
"SCOAP3, the Sponsoring Consortium for Open Access in Particle Physics Publishing, proposes an innovative economic model to achieve Open Access to peer-reviewed literature in high-energy physics (HEP). The model seeks to, (using current funding levels as a starting point), redirect subscription expenditures to ensure open access and work to contain costs - and in doing so, achieve more value than is possible within a subscription-based system."
- Daniel Mietchen
from Bookmarklet
The Caribbean Librarian: Knowledge Exchange comparative report on Costs and Benefits of Open Access - http://thecaribbeanlibrarian.b...
"In June 2009 a study was completed that had been commissioned by Knowledge Exchange and written by Professor John Houghton, Victoria University, Australia. This report on the study was titled: "Open Access – What are the economic benefits?: A comparison of the United Kingdom, Netherlands and Denmark." In the three national studies the costs and benefits of scholarly communication were compared based on three different publication models. The modelling revealed that: the greatest advantage would be offered by the Open Access model, which means that the research institution or the party financing the research pays for publication and the article is then freely accessible. Adopting this model could lead to annual savings of around EUR 70 million in Denmark, EUR 133 million in The Netherlands and EUR 480 in the UK. The report concludes that the advantages would not just be in the long term; in the transitional phase too, more open access to research results would have positive effects. In this case the benefits would also outweigh the costs."
- Daniel Mietchen
from Bookmarklet
[[Induction/Definition]] moved to [[Induction (philosophy)/Definition]]: disambiguation
- Daniel Mietchen
Scientific findings in a digital world: What is the genuine article? at the British Library on 22nd July (18.00 - 20.30) - http://network.nature.com/groups...
"Looking Good on Paper The gold standard of the peer-reviewed scientific paper has barely changed in form since its inception over 300 years ago. However, with more and more scientists communicating research findings in digital format in many different ways does the notion of the scientific ‘article’ itself remain relevant? Is the traditional research paper still the optimal format for the dissemination of the outputs of scientific research? If not, what are the alternatives? Video Killed the Methods Section More and more scientific findings are ‘born digital’. The traditional format of research article is being transformed into a multi-media digital object with linked content, video, audio, datasets and reader annotation. This raises new possibilities and challenges. How should these newer types of content be peer reviewed? Are researchers really able to make the most of them? Does a link to a dataset or image always provide sufficient context to enable informed re-use or validation?...
more...
- Daniel Mietchen
from Bookmarklet
Anybody planning on going there? They do not foresee live streaming but would allow microblogging.
- Daniel Mietchen
I'm not sure that I can go - its a long (and expensive) detour on the way home...
- Cameron Neylon
from twhirl
Can't help you with the "long" part but I'm working on the "expensive" one.
- Daniel Mietchen
Sounds like a great discussion! Sadly it is too far away for me. Does anyone know what the format is? It says that John Wilbanks will introduce the topic but doesn't say how the discussion will proceed from there.
- Lisa Green
Up to five people who commit to microblogging from the event will have free entry. Please sign up here or let me know via email.
- Daniel Mietchen
D'oh! I already registered :) Looking forward to it!
- Fiona Bradley
Looking like I might be able to make it after all. Woot!
- Cameron Neylon
from twhirl
Nice to see that you plan to go there, Fiona and Cameron!
- Daniel Mietchen
"It is the objective of the conference to further the exchange of ideas among established as well as upcoming young researchers, politicians, business people, and decision-makers. Eminent speakers such as Sir Timothy Berners-Lee, Homi K. Bhabha, Paul Collier and Nancy Birdsall have already confirmed their participation. The Volkswagen Foundation offers up to 100 grants for highly motivated young researchers from all over the world and invites them to attend the conference, take part in the plenary sessions, topical workshops, and panel discussions."
- Daniel Mietchen
from Bookmarklet
Limitations: (1) 140 chars is too limited to accomodate a typical URI, (2) needs to be coupled to author ID, (3) only one rating dimension as of now.
- Daniel Mietchen
if we could aggregate a whole bunch of different comments from different sources and translate them automatically to fit? Or provide a link to the comment rather than the full text of the comment?
- Cameron Neylon
from twhirl
Ok, now I've looked properly. Would probably need to build a slightly more intelligent service but if you could parse links then there are two very nice things here. One is linking id, and review via URLs but the other is that this actually matches the PubSub-Syndicate mechanism that Jon Udell talk a lot about much better than commenting on websites (...now where is that half written blog post...?)
- Cameron Neylon
the comment text from people usually contains even more helpful information than rating metrics
- Mike Chelen
DOIs can still be very long - plus you'd probably want to give them in the http form so that makes them even longer. Mike, agree the text can be more useful but if it is held somewhere else then the tweet only needs to reference it via a shortened link was what I was thinking
- Cameron Neylon
The DOI problem could be solved if the @hreview service were to expand the shortened URL per default.
- Daniel Mietchen
Also, we need a URI scheme for anything on the web, from blog entries to wiki edits to @hreview ratings.
- Daniel Mietchen
Cameron:probably the posts could contain shortened DOI URLs that were expanded in the underlying hReview
- Mike Chelen
Daniel: can the hCard support be used to integrate with other author ID systems?
- Mike Chelen
CC-BY-ND certainly makes sense for the pure values (text or numbers) of the ratings, but isn't it too restrictive for reuse, e.g. aggregation?
- Daniel Mietchen
Daniel: there are clauses to specifically allow collections, but it's never been clear to me exactly how ND applies to subsets or programmatic reuse.
- Mike Chelen
Nor to me, Mike, but the opencritics are open to criticism (I had to bring that) and suggestions, and have lawyers to sort such things out properly. More to come on that by tomorrow - just had them on the phone.
- Daniel Mietchen
hmm, 140 characters won't work. We need an article social activity aggregation service, could then be mirrored onto twitter or where ever. Like stramosphere, but just for articles. Euan should write it.
- Ian Mulvany
Should note that CrossRef is thinking of creating alternative shortened DOIs that could address some of these problems. Working name is "toydoi". Advantage of CrossRef is we could avoid spam-plague faced by traditional URL shorteners. Would be good to hear from interested parties to understand use cases.
- Geoffrey Bilder
Ian, I think that "article social activity aggregation service" is a good description for what Mendeley are up to - still a bit rough a toy, but improving very fast.
- Daniel Mietchen
Geoffrey, good to read that. However, the length of DOI is just one problem, and more pressing from my point is to develop a DOI-like URI scheme for anything cited in a scientific context (and for anyone citing, too), e.g. via automatic deposit at places like Webcitation or Portico (and using some sort of author ID). And before going public with that working name, they might wish to invite comments from speakers of Vietnamese.
- Daniel Mietchen
So we've also been thinking a little bit about how to assign identifiers to new forms of scholarly communication- thinks like blogs, wikis, data sets, etc. Some background can be found here: http://tinyurl.com/m68jlq
- Geoffrey Bilder
Yes, that's useful background. Do you have an update on the current situation?
- Daniel Mietchen
hReview supports multiple rating dimensions if the site could use it
- Mike Chelen
A possible way to go global (>7 countries) with some Open Science projects (be this blog 3 descendants or a reform of the peer review system)? Source: European Science Foundation. Largest drawback: They foresee 15 months for the review process, not really the time frame for _supporting_ innovation. Deadline for proposals: Oct 22, 2009. - http://www.esf.org/activit...
"An ESF Research Networking Programme is a networking activity bringing together nationally funded research activities for four to five years, to address a major scientific issue or a science-driven topic of research infrastructure, at the European level with the aim of advancing the frontiers of science."
- Daniel Mietchen
from Bookmarklet
Good grief, 15 months of review. This sounds like a possible way for a big open science consortium to be funded - if one can strip away the typical EU verbiage. I could represent Australia (where we have our own funding), but we'd just then need "Canada, China, Israel, Japan, Korea, Russia, USA and others".
- Matthew Todd
in 15 months we could be past the singularity already :)
- Jean-Claude Bradley
I'm all for it! Let's do some brainstorming!
- Björn Brembs
Additional development of interdisciplinary research methods would be useful, particularly if there is a focus on the learning and sharing aspects.
- Mike Chelen
made a few comments and quickly skimmed the call. No harm in working something up though - we could use some of the old network proposal we wrote a year or ago...http://docs.google.com/View...
- Cameron Neylon
Bah, I meant to say - it would be a good thing to start putting together some of these - if nothing else we can re-use the text until some of them get funded. Wasn't meaning to be negative.
- Cameron Neylon
Cameron: advocacy for data repository, semantic publication, and community commenting could be influential and interesting
- Mike Chelen
It might be interesting to see if writing this in public would get the attraction of funders with shorter review periods.
- Daniel Mietchen
"Everyone's a winner, right? Wrong, says Vincent Kiernan, associate dean at Georgetown University, journalist, and journalism scholar. Embargoes have become an addiction for journalists, he said, a set of "velvet handcuffs" that simply eats up time and resources that could be better spent digging up scoops. Not only does it turn journalists into propagandists for scientists and academic journals, it also reduces science to an artificial series of 'eureka' moments. Indeed, there's no evidence that stories written under embargo are any better than those which are not, he added. And in a time when media companies are struggling, the ones that will survive are those which provide unique content - not those who follow the pack and write the same stories about science that everyone else is writing."
- Daniel Mietchen
from Bookmarklet
"Ultimately, getting rid of the embargo system would improve the quality of science journalism, he concluded, because it would force editors to employ reporters who actually knew what they were talking about, rather than simply being able to read and regurgitate a weekly press release at leisure."
- Daniel Mietchen
"But Horton has a plan. To test the hypothesis that embargoed journal papers get more, and better-quality, coverage in the popular press, he suggested that all the papers published by The Lancet over, say, a month or two, could be divided into two randomized groups. One set would be press released under embargo; the other merely published by the journal at the usual time." - Nice idea. What about getting blogs involved?
- Daniel Mietchen
"Ultimately, getting rid of the embargo system would improve the quality of science journalism, he concluded...etc.". I'd add to that that removing access barriers to the literature for journalists would improve it even more, because then journalists would be able to read all the other literature and really know what they are talking about!
- Björn Brembs
I'm in total agreement with Kiernan. PNAS is the worst: their embargo is usually a week. Thus, distorted sensationalist press coverage stands for that long before scientists can read the paper. Ridiculous! I'm curious to see the outcome of The Lancet experiment...
- The Neurocritic
Dissertation: "Bibliometrische Verfahren und Methoden als Beitrag zur Trendbeobachtung und -erkennung in den Naturwissenschaften" - Dirk Tunger, 2009 - http://juwel.fz-juelich.de:8080/dspace...
"Die kontinuierliche Beobachtung von Trends und die korrekte Einschaetzung von Entwicklungen in der Wissenschaft bilden wichtige Grundpfeiler für ein erfolgreiches Zukunftsmanagement. Bibliometrie als eine Methode der Trenderkennung steht hierbei im Mittelpunkt der Dissertation. Bibliometriker versuchen durch die statistische Auswertung von wissenschaftlichen Veroeffentlichungen Trends in Wissenschaft und Forschung zu erkennen, ihren Verlauf zu beobachten und Aussagen ueber ihre moegliche Entwicklung zu treffen." - past citation trends in the time frame of years, that is.
- Daniel Mietchen
from Bookmarklet