"It's been a week since Joss Whedon's Dollhouse closed up its rent-a-slave operation, and we're still grieving, for the stories that will never be told now. Dollhouse kept exceeding its limitations — but never reached its potential. Spoilers rising... There are really two kinds of television shows: the ones canceled too soon, and the ones that drag on past their best-by date. Very, very few TV shows end at the right time. Even though Dollhouse got enough advance warning that it was able to cobble together a definite conclusion, we still feel as though it belongs in the same category as Firefly, Terminator: SCC and many other shows. Dollhouse started out as the most conceptually ambitious thing Joss Whedon's ever done — but forcing that concept into the box of a weekly TV show was a process akin to chainsaw bonsai. Whedon was clear, from before the show launched, that this was fundamentally a show about a woman who had been robbed of her identity and dehumanized. The overall arc of...
more...
- RAPatton
from Bookmarklet
"And that's why I'm most convinced that Dollhouse should have had a few more years to run its course. Not just because the shift from "eww icky fantasy fulfillment" to "the whole human race is at stake" could have been a smoother arc. Or because the awareness that Rossum was the real monster, and that the L.A. Dollhouse was going to have to posse up and fight, could have dawned more...
more...
- RAPatton
"Color me unmoved by the alleged tragedy of Joss Whedon. What happened to Firefly was arguably tragic. But by the time Dollhouse came out, it was clear that the place for idiosyncratic, ambitious television was cable where a show could be viable with a smaller, but more devoted audience. We’ve had Battlestar: Galactica we’ve had The Wire we’ve had Mad Men it doesn’t take a genius to see how this goes. But you get paid more money to develop a show for a network, and Whedon wanted more money so he gave us Dollhouse, a show with a ton of promise but also dozens of artistic compromises. Getting “killed before its time” was inevitable. Whedon’s fans want to see him make the kind of show he can only make on cable. And I’m sure one cable network or another would be happy to develop a show with a creator who comes with a fervent built-in fanbase. But he doesn’t seem to want to do it. I think it’s a shame, but it’s his own fault."
- Steven Perez
from Bookmarklet
Shared primarily because, whether he realizes it or not, Yglesias and the commenters who agree with him make the tacit verification that network television, progressively as the years go by, is not a place for smart television shows. Progressively, network television has to follow a formula, or the audience "doesn't get it". Guess Pop was right all along: TV really does make you stupid.
- Steven Perez
wow... I always have wondered why Wedon didn't go to cable... but I never figured this angle. Not sure if I buy it
- MoTO Bott
Yglesias gets that part wrong, Barry, if the stories are to be believed. This was Eliza Dushku's show; she asked him to help her develop it. And the rest is history.
- Steven Perez
IMO network TV has still produced pretty smart shows in the last couple of years or so. They do tend to die way early, though. And Barry, network TV definitely does pay better. The creator of "Action" said they had the opportunity to make it on one of the premium cable channels but he wanted the money Fox was offering.
- Andrew C (✓)
I also like comment #4, the one about how BTVS S6 and S7 sucked so much they tarnished the entire series.
- Andrew C (✓)
Also, as fun as Dollhouse is once the writers get the fear of cancellation struck into them, the premise has always, always been crummy.
- Andrew C (✓)
I disagree. The premise - the questions of identity and sexuality - were excellent premises for a science fiction show. As I often tell people who think the show is rotten, you need to locate and watch the original pilot to really appreciate how egregiously Fox screwed over all involved.
- Steven Perez
By 'premise', I meant the idea of a Dollhouse at all. The underlying concepts of identity and sexuality are compelling, yes. But episode to episode, the Dolls generally did tasks that high-end hookers or mercenaries could just as easily have performed, without all the trouble of having to have Dolls.
- Andrew C (✓)
To Steven's earlier point, network TV is, by and large, a wasteland these days. Mindless reality shows, low-brow formula comedies and cop/lawyer/doctor soap operas. As for Dollhouse, it was clearly the sort of show that would get canceled by any broadcast network with the possible exception of ABC.
- The original Kevin
IMO network TV has produced a number of gems in the last few years, though some have been short-lived. Pushing Daisies, Arrested Development, Veronica Mars, ... OK, OK, just for currently alive shows, and setting the bar down to 'good' from 'great': Chuck, Better Off Ted (technically not cancelled yet), Community, Parks & Rec, 30 Rock, House, ... I guess that's not a very long list compared to the number of active network shows.
- Andrew C (✓)
"Dollhouse, Joss Whedon's weirdest show, started out being about people who can be anybody. But last night, every one of the show's characters was so clearly defined, so much themselves, that their personalities are imprinted on our brains forever. Spoilers... The penultimate Dollhouse episode was the cheesy action thriller, with tons of twists and turns that make no sense and characters jumping out of danger into more danger. But the final episode, "Epitaph Two: Return," was pretty much the opposite — it was a solid character-based drama with almost no plot twists to speak of, after the initial set-up. There was exactly one big McGuffin in the episode — Topher's somewhat miraculous scheme to restore everyone's minds to the default factory settings — and it was introduced pretty early. I've watched this episode twice already, and I sort of liked it the first time — but it plays way better the second time around, when you're less caught up in "what happens next."
- RAPatton
"The big where he turns to Adelle and says, confidingly, "Your job is wayyyy harder," managed to be a uniquely Whedonian mix of funny and tragic. And Topher got to have one final scene with Summer Glau, sort of. And you know, Summer Glau got to give us the final takeaway Dollhouse message: "We literally become what we do, not what we've done, or what we will do. We're best defined by our actions in the moment.""
- RAPatton
"It's hard not to feel like the story of Dollhouse isn't really over, though — like, the original problem still remains. The tech is out there, and it'll be used again, as long as anybody understands it. Despite all the ways you can erase people's minds, it's really hard to get rid of an idea. And what kind of repressive world would you need to have, to ensure that nobody ever uses...
more...
- RAPatton
No power in the Verse can stop it. er...
- Michael W. May
"Dollhouse, Joss Whedon's weirdest show, started out being about people who can be anybody. But last night, every one of the show's characters was so clearly defined, so much themselves, that their personalities are imprinted on our brains forever. Spoilers..."
- Steven Perez
from Bookmarklet
"I can't freakin wait for tonight. I've had an unhealthily obsessive relationship with Dollhouse for ages, even before the show namechecked io9. The other day, I saw a headline about the Dollhouse series finale having an airdate in March, and nearly had a heart attack — before I realized it was referring to the U.K. airdate. With no more new episodes coming, here are the things we'll miss getting to experience for the first time .... Dollhouse's finale airs tonight at 8 PM, one hour earlier than normal. "
- RAPatton
"The Topher-isms. It's hard to believe anyone ever hated Topher — he's become such a fascinating, tortured, unforgettable character, as he's groped towards a sense of ethics and a comprehension of the terrible things he's been a party to. And even more than that, he's had all the best lines. Witness: "Something fell on me." "I bet it was something great!" " Relax, Mountain Man. I've...
more...
- RAPatton
"The many sides of Adelle the ice lady. Dollhouse is full of characters who seem very one-note at first, but slowly open up to reveal weird kinks and contradictions. And Adelle might actully be the greatest of these. At first, she's just the smooth, British iron lady, who's troubled by neither fear nor compunction. But one of the great pleasures of watching the show unfold every week...
more...
- RAPatton
I always enjoy a Whedon show. Even when it's not *fantastic* it's generally better than 98% of shows out there. I keep coming back for his characters. I truly believe that when he's given full creative reign, the show is better. Still haven't watched the finale...
- Lis
Found myself frustrated by the missing episode. I hate that I have to either rent the first season DVD or get it on iTunes. Is it available for free online anywhere? I personally think they could have ended the season on the next to last episode. I tried to watch the finale without watching Epitaph One and it just left me feeling like I had missed something huge. I made it 5 minutes before I turned it off.
- Jen (SquirrelGirl)
The USB drives were funny, as well as how I assumed everyone would be evil, like Victor and Alpha, but they were super nice. And I like the happy ending. No reason to continue it. I would rather a nice director's cut Blu-ray release.
- Vezquex
And it is over now. Wow ... so sad. it was only really just beginning.
- Amani
"Joss Whedon's mind-warping Dollhouse ends tonight, and then we'll enter the "endless rewatching and overanalyzing" phase of our relationship with this show. Here are 10 things we'll miss most about Dollhouse, plus some clips from tonight's finale."
- Steven Perez
from Bookmarklet
"The last episode of troubled drama Dollhouse is definitely the end of the story, according to creator Joss Whedon. He's confirmed that there's no chance of continuing it in other media, and explained why (Not necessarily what you think). Talking to Comic Book Resources, Whedon seemed resigned to the show's cancellation, as well as the role he played in taking it to that point: The only regrets I have about it are the things I didn't do right. 26 hours of television is a lot of time to tell story, and everybody involved was great. I just look back and go, 'I wish I had figured some things out a little earlier.' But that's all the time I have for regret. It is what it is."
- RAPatton
from Bookmarklet
"He also finally answered rumors about the possibility of a Dollhouse comic: I don't think it's a comic. It's a TV show...apparently not a Fox show, but it is a TV show. There are themes in it and ideas that could work in a comic, but for me to spend the amount of time it would take keeping the comic true to what's already out there when I'm already doing that with 'Buffy' would be a...
more...
- RAPatton
It's leela from the 5the element!
- RAPatton
from iPhone
I've had a spinaltap to extract spinal fluid; yes it does hurt
- RAPatton
from iPhone
I still don't understand the angle that the founder of Rossum is doing. I just don't get it.
- James Ferguson
RAP, I thought for sure that the Rossum founder would have been revealed to be Joss last week.
- James Ferguson
James, I think 1) he is insane 2) cause end of world, so someone doesn't do it so he controls it 3) make vaccine to protect his "family" 4) he's insane
- RAPatton
from iPhone
But why stay in that body when his partner appears to be jumping from body to body?
- James Ferguson
Saw the greystreak; the whole multimind is very rogueish and the streak is the icing on the cake
- RAPatton
from iPhone
TVGUIDE.com says Epitaph Two is airing NEXT week. So maybe Epitaph One will actually air next week. Why they don't make that clear is a mystery to me.
- tehKenny
I liked tonight, but I think the previous 8 eps, which were all awesome, were better
- RAPatton
I thought Two was just ppd due to the Haiti telethon? Any real chance of One being aired?
- cdogzilla | downgraded
James, I think he is in a lot of bodies, not just the one
- RAPatton
Yeah, I'm guessing multiple bodies, too. And I hope you're right about there being something on next week--I'll need my fix!
- Kirsten
from fftogo
I think next week they are airing the telethon, cdogzilla
- The Amber
I kept getting distracted by Enver Gjokaj because he is *so good* at impersonating Topher (well, anyone, actually. The guy is an actor extraordinaire.)! :)
- Cheryl Jones
Cheryl, I thought so too. (He was so convincing that I kept wondering if they dubbed Topher's voice!)
- Mark J
SEMI-SPOILER-ISH I think they knew by the time they did epithet one; I don't know if it was sooner, but it might have been. His motivations, well I think that was shoe horned by epithet one. I think Caroline's DNA was always part of the plan, but forced end of the world not so much
- RAPatton
"A fan gets Jossed when the elaborate Epileptic Trees or Fanfic that they've lovingly built upon canonical elements is abruptly disproved by further canon or by the Word Of God. Named after Joss Whedon; Buffy The Vampire Slayer was notorious for this, as fans would come up with detailed and elaborate theories or plots during summer hiatuses, most of which got completely thrown out within three episodes of the new season."
- tehKenny
from Bookmarklet
The closer Dollhouse gets to its unjust cancellation, the nearer the end of civilization gets. And once again, the apocalypse just makes everyone, and everything, better. But what was up with that last plot twist?
- The Amber
from Bookmarklet
It's as if they hadn't ever watched Buffy or seen Serenity.
- Kevin Fox
"Topher, especially, has gone from Satan Jr. to one of the richest characters on television. Topher's relationships with almost every character on the show got little moments of revelation and dismay. There's his reunion with Claire, who starts out cleaning Topher's busted lip with something akin to tenderness, and winds up shooting the woman Topher is falling for. Then the scene where Topher, already drowning, has to explain to Echo that yes, he deleted Paul's love for her. Like I mentioned, Topher and Adelle are now miles from the snarky banter and inappropriate flirtation of their earlier relationship. And Topher's scenes with Bennett were so funny and twisted, with the two amoral geniuses bonding over their love of pure mad science, that I got more invested in their relationship, after that short time, than I'll ever be in Skate or Huddy."
- RAPatton
"I guess we'll find out next week. But the **** revelation, on top of everything else, ensures that whenever you rewatch one of those season-one episodes — yes, even the boring "backup singer" one — you'll have a lot more to think about than just, "Isn't Echo's latest shiny outfit shiny?" I can't say it often enough — this is one of those shows that will become legendary once the whole...
more...
- RAPatton
Does it make any difference at all? This show is dead. The characters aren't going anywhere, correct?
- iTad
@Tad: the storyline will wrap up by the end of this season, so we'll have a complete plot arc. Which is more than you get out of a lot of shows that go on for 3+ seasons.
- Louis Simoneau
I had very mixed feelings about it at first... Not liking some of the actors much and finding some of the plot lines a bit absurd. I stuck with it though, and it really got interesting. I'm glad I hung in there.
- Jen (SquirrelGirl)
from iPhone
The final 10 episodes of the show have been great (assuming the next 2 keep it up)
- RAPatton
"The description and promo pics for the final episode, "Epitaph Two: Return," are out. ECHO RACES TO STOP AN APOCALYPSE ON THE SERIES FINALE OF "DOLLHOUSE" FRIDAY, JANUARY 22, ON FOX Picking up from the events depicted in "Epitaph 1," the "lost" episode of DOLLHOUSE, and set in the year 2020, Echo and her surviving Dollhouse crew attempt to restore order to a devastating future world before mankind is eliminated. The cast includes Amy Acker, Miracle Laurie, Reed Diamond, Alan Tudyk, the little girl Adair Tischler (as "Caroline,") Zack Ward (as "Zone")... and of course, Felicia Day. And Brandon Tischler plays T, who has a "special relationship" with Sierra. And here are those pics. "
- RAPatton
Echo's arch has taking the classic Greek heroes myth path
- RAPatton
from iPhone
The last 6 hours of Dollhouse has been very high quality; excited to see what the final three episodes bring
- RAPatton
from iPhone
Yup. Clearly they're seriously condensing the season. they didn't plan to double-up episodes for the last three weeks and last Friday's should have run in January. 3 more episodes! Ack! I hope they don't kill of Anya!
- Kevin Fox
"Last night, Dollhouse served up a blend of the Borg, The Matrix and The Cell... and then revealed how they all fit together, in a wholly original story. And then we finally learned the secret origins of Rossum. Spoilers ahead."
- Steven Perez
from Bookmarklet
You know what, this show doesn't suck that much. eliza dushku is still terrible tho, she's killing it. but otherwise it's not bad at all.
- Richard Lawler
I have been suffering through her not quite acting for a hot minute, she did well this round.
- The Amber