"That's very moving and maybe you aren't as orthodox as you think. As you may know, the renegade Rabbi Kook you mentioned was essentially the founder of the Gush Emmunim movement. Their political ideology being that Jews living in the promised land was a prerequisite for the coming of the Moshiach. Orthodoxy by contrast believe that the physical land of Israel is irrelevant to Moshiach. That the redemption is "purely supernatural" and emanating from God anywhere in the galut. In their view, a God of miracles would have no need to place Jews in the promised land because such a prerequisite would mean God was not all-powerful. Jews living in the historical land of Judea was not seen as the fulfillment of prophesy. Gush Emmunim was a nationalistic movement that found its strength from youthful idealism, not calcified orthodoxy defending established power structures. The Gush appealed to progressive religious American Jews, with the partisan reactionary politics of Judea & Shomron today..."
- Rachel Cogent
"You state that in your 7th paragraph Israel was born out of Holocaust. Jews are traumatized, it's easy to understand why we can't see anything sacred in the ashes of Jews. But isn't it likely that the Holocaust was the divine birth pangs of the Promised Land? Don't religious Jews observe the resurrection that comes from the ashes of the burnt sacrifice? Or are we blinded by our anger at at God for using OUR flesh for the sacrifice, like Isaac on the altar really getting burned? How long will Jews ignore the divine plan of redemption unfolding? Someday someone will suddenly notice it was happening all along… and it will be a revelation."
- Rachel Cogent
"This is actually a corporate subsidy to raise the overall quality of the workforce. Business should pitch in since the government is culling out incompetent, mentally ill, unhealthy and desperate potential employees."
- Rachel Cogent
"Don't forget that business interests love and subsidize the cheap labor. These poverty stricken immigrants were invited here to play soldiers in the war against organized labor. Why do you think Reagan gave them amnesty? Because our economy thrives from importing cheap labor. So while wealthy republicans appreciate the ubiquitous servant class, poor republicans bemoan the invasion of employment competitors. This is why it is so often said that most republicans are poor people tricked into voting against their own interests."
- Rachel Cogent
"I sure do hate to see Jerusalem turned into just another fasttrack. The religious need to put an end to this endless striving to imitate every other worldly city."
- Rachel Cogent
"Please continue talking about this problem. Kashrut should supervise our food production chain to ensure we eat healthy and not just whatever maximizes corporate profits. There are already many modern non-Jews who look for "Kosher" because it means cleaner and more humanely prepared food. This is a huge vacuum that tthe rabbanut can fill, and thus bring "Kosher" into the mainstream."
- Rachel Cogent