Brilliant people all - Ariel Waldman, Cameron Neylon, Duncan Hull, Martin Fenner, and Sirley Wu - first time to meet all of them in person. I also got to meet two SL friends in RL for the first time - Joanna Scott & Melanie Swan. It felt like a family reunion. :)
- Andrew Lang
Nice to meet you too Andrew, and all the others not mentioned. One and a half days is really short. So a little bit like the candy store 30 min before closing.
- Martin Fenner
Some interesting talks today but really it is the people that made the event. Many thanks to the organizers.
- Andrew Lang
no API as of yet - today was the first day I could actually import the data. It has been very unGoogle-like in exhibiting bugs. For the future I can see this is the tool we'll use for the solubility data but just something fun to play with right now.
- Andrew Lang
I've used numbered grids to play around a little with texturing -- nice if it could be semi-automated. Some way beyond non-trivial for me, alas.You can use SculptyPaint as well, I guess.
- Peter Miller
manual texturing might be useful to highlight specific areas involved in a reaction
- Mike Chelen
Interesting. A custom texture web service should be possible. How are these things normally colour-coded, have any example images you can point me to?
- Andrew Lang
I looked at the pdb format and there is a column for atom charge in the specification but with a random selection of pdb files, that column was always blank, so I decided to color according to nearest amino acid residue, see: http://www.flickr.com/photos...
- Andrew Lang
that looks great! amino acids are indeed of primary consideration when viewing an entire protein. what is the coloring key, is it based on charge?
- Mike Chelen
These are looking great! Is the program source code available? The only other thing that would be useful is additional texture maps for polarity and charge: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki...
- Mike Chelen
@Mike. IM me your email and I'll send you the code. asp.net
- Andrew Lang
Sending my email now, is the code under GPL or similar? Also, what do you think would be a good way to share the generated files on the web, and in world? The additional textures make these even better, think they are some of the best in-world learning tools for biology and chemistry!
- Mike Chelen
Uploading to flickr is good - we could tag them in some way - maybe 'slprotein'. I can release code - I'm thinking MIT licence right now, unless that's not good for you. I'm flexible. Didn't get your email. I'll zip up the code and put it on the website: http://slusage.com/sculpties/
- Andrew Lang
Flickr tags would be good, and could include the RCSB entry id. Would it be possible to output sculpty maps as lossless TIFF files? Maybe once there were a few collected, they could be put into a pack for SL. Any open-source license is fine by me, thanks for putting up the code! I imported it to github- http://github.com/mchelen... based on the file name, what would be the preferred title?
- Mike Chelen
Andrew: sure thing, still learning git and need the practice :) tried switching the image format from Jpeg to Tiff- http://github.com/mchelen... don't have an asp/.net platform to test it on though
- Mike Chelen
Heard one feature request to allow direct upload of PDB (in addition to linking of file URL)
- Mike Chelen
That was a great session -- just disappointed I had to leave so early and, given I was at work, only had low rez screen capture. I'm hoping this initiative could move things forward significantly, even if only by bringing some "old-timers" together on a more regular basis. :)
- Peter Miller
now the planetary guy as well as the science guy :)
- Christina Pikas
Call to action - wikipedia editor questions the reliability of data from open science - please go to his talk page and add your support for the ONSchallenge: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki...
quote from editor: "Although I am sure that this school project was fun for the kids, Wikipedia needs to have data here from verifiable sources. Reference to a university site (Oral Roberts or Harvard) is not good enough. Otherwise your work risks being deleted. NIST, CRC etc, now they are authorities. I really encourage you to consult someone before launching on what looks like a well intentioned but naively planned project."
- Andrew Lang
Please help. Go to the talk page and make a comment. Thanks!
- Andrew Lang
There is probably a value in thinking carefully about the response here. I have heard some criticisms of the methodology being used and have suggested that people make those criticisms in the project notebooks but this hasn't happened as yet. Strictly the WP guidelines do require a traditionally published (non-web) verifiable source and one could make an argument that these results have...
more...
- Cameron Neylon
...but not in the traditional way...I agree with you but it's a subtle argument and it could get lost
- Cameron Neylon
I would also say that at the end of the day there is much more back up on our data than there is for a NIST or CRC value in many cases - at least you can tell what was measured. Just not sure whether that will be enough for the traditionalists. Just worth rehearsing the arguments I guess i what I am saying.
- Cameron Neylon
Can you link the actual page that's in dispute? Major flaw in WP talk imo, there are no auto links to the pages being discussed.
- Bill Hooker
Just noticed in the urea talk page someone complaining in 2007 that all the solubility values were wrong and unreferenced :-)
- Cameron Neylon
Added my comment. It seems to me that, as a source to be quoted in WP, open notebooks are a new category (see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki...). They are not "third-party published sources with a reputation for fact-checking and accuracy", but they are "produced by an established expert on the topic" in the sense that JC runs the project and we judges are all scientists. More to the point, WP has never been asked to consider this kind of source before.
- Bill Hooker
@Cameron Good find! I can see the ppt slide now. Here's the quote from 2007 about the solubility in water - it seems to have never been resolved - "The article provides some specific information about the solubility of urea without giving a source. The values were out by at least a factor of 10 (probably g/L rather than g/100mL), which I have corrected by knocking off the last zero, but...
more...
- Andrew Lang
I added my 2 cents: http://en.wikipedia.org/w... . Still do not get why none of you guys - so much engaged in doing open science - seem to have ever shown up at Citizendium, a place where expertise is actually valued. It is currently very small compared to Wikipedia, but so is Open Science compared to the rest. See also http://en.wikiversity.org/wiki... .
- Daniel Mietchen
Thanks for adding a post to the discussion on wikipedia Daniel. I will check out Citizendium.
- Andrew Lang
I believe the reason most of us stick to Wikipedia is that we believe that it is (a) the appropriate general resource and (b) since it is the source most people, and Google, go to, information will be found there.
- Deepak Singh
Certainly nothing wrong with reading or editing Wikipedia entries. But the sort of problem discussed in this thread would be much rarer over there at Citizendium (they have others), and since it tends to affect scientists quite often, I am wondering why they do not give this alternative a try. Andrew Su has done that, and he was disappointed (a feeling I share for his case, since I...
more...
- Daniel Mietchen
Daniel - thanks for the comments and for the link to Wikiversity and Citizendium - we'll certainly check it out. A first look does not show any entries for common chemicals like methanol. Additional portals are always of interest though. The reason Wikipedia is useful is that it turns out to be a significant way people looking for specific non-aqueous solubility find our results.
- Jean-Claude Bradley
Bing - "Solubility of benzoic acid" search results roll-over gives solubility values in THF, acetone, and acetonitile from ONSchallenge data.
Just after reading about eHits on the PS3, this news comes out, and my kids want a Wii. What to do? I bet this won't be out for 18 months though.
- Andrew Lang
Yes, the more polished video is a "conceptualisation" rather than a product demo. As the SL peeps note, it's potentially a space hog too.
- Peter Miller
It probably won't live up to the promo but the concept is cool and potentially game-changing, pun intended. :)
- Andrew Lang