Poll: Which Kevin Smith movie do you prefer?... - Alex Scoble

Chasing Amy - Alex Scoble

Dogma! - Johnny Worthington

Chasing Amy - Dan Monzelowsky

First one to say Jersey Girl gets a squirreled ball sack - Johnny Worthington

Dogma - Soup

dogma - chaz2b

Dogma - Anika

Boo on Anika - Alex Scoble

Boo on me? :( - Anika

Indeed! - Alex Scoble

But I liked Dogma. Even despite the existence of George Carlin. Chasing Amy...I'm still trying to forget I watched it. - Anika

Boooo!!! You broke the tie! Boooooo! - Alex Scoble

depends on my mood. right now, Dogma wins - jbrotherlove

When I replied, there was only 3 responses! - Anika

Hehe, you replied when there were 6 responses...hence the boos. :) - Alex Scoble

Chasing Amy by far... I /love/ Catholic humour given my upbringing, but that movie falls flat in overall tone. Chris Rock is the only one doesn't seem to sleepwalk through it. Chasing Amy (and I liked Jersey Girl, for what it was). - Michael W. May

No, when I replied, Dan's comment was the last one. The other people must have replied at the same time. - Anika

we're fast/slow like that, sorry - chaz2b

Chasing Amy. It's not on television enough, and even though I own it, I can't bring myself to watch it even though I love it. - Andy Bakun

Chasing Amy - Ubqtous

Ubqtous only said that to be contrary to me. He really meant Dogma. :) - Anika from fftogo

Chasing Amy - Haggis (Sean Loyless)

Not everything I say revolves around you Anika ;) Chasing Amy isn't my favorite Smith movie (that'd be either Mallrats or Zack and Miri Make a Porno), but it is a better piece of story telling than Dogma. - Ubqtous

Dogma for the frenetic energy of it. Chasing Amy for a more polished work. Dogma wins 9 times out of ten for me. - Pete Delucchi from iPhone

Definitely Dogma, that film had me so engrossed from beginning to end. Chasing Amy just didn't arouse my interest - Slippy "Threadsbane" Lane

TMI: I saw Chasing Amy only a few months after being dumped by The Girl From Maine after a year and half because she "needed to explore her sexuality." My ego was slightly bandaged when she later settled on labelling herself bi-sexual rather than lesbian. No longer was I the sex she turned gay because of... So the film hits many chords ;) Including the ending where some self-examination was in order. - Michael W. May

Dogma, though biased as I have not yet viewed Chasing Amy ;) - Janet

Chasing Amy.. - CW™

Chasing Amy - Bill Kinney

chasing dogmatic jersey girls in the mall. - Gunny Just Gunny

Dogma by far - Michael Hocter

neither - Josh Haley from iPhone

Dogma - J. Abdul-Qahhar

Dogma, for so many reasons. - Jack (a.k.a. Jeber)

Dogma. - CAJ, somewhere else from iPhone

Dogma - Lindsey is Fierce!

Dogma - Andrizzle Gizzle

Dogma - Aaman (Clone of FF)

Dogma. How many comedies hinge entirely on a theological paradox? - Victor Ganata

And I have to admit, I did enjoy watching Ben Affleck and Matt Damon get totally obliterated by God Herself. - Victor Ganata

Chasing Amy EDIT: Although I don't love it. Come to think of it, all of his movies seem kinda meh to me. Like him though. What's that one dvd he did where he's lecturing at a college? - Derrick

Chasing Amy - holly from iPhone

Real Genius - Geoff Schultz

Real Genius rules! :) - Ubqtous

"I wouldn't know, Dave. I haven't had a working weapon since Korea." /hijack - Michael W. May

Chasing Amy. - cecily

Chasing Amy - Tim Hoeck

Hard one, but I have to say Dogma. - Rene Wirtz

I loved Dogma, never did see Chasing Amy - Jorge Escobar

Chasing Amy but I did like Dogma too. I'd still vote Clerks higher than both. - Stephen Mack

dogma - pea ♥..!..♥..!..♥

Chasing Amy - Chris Rivait

Chasing Amy. - Ton Zijp

Dogma - Dario Gomez

I can't pick. *sob* - Alix Whitmire

Dogma. - Jason Huebel

Chasing Amy. But this is really like choosing which one of your kids you like best. Only more difficult - Joe Pierce

If anything says we need some kind of integrated polling ability on FF, it's things like this. It would be awesome if a tally was kept automatically, so we could see the stats, and the comments were commentary rather than a huge jumble of poll contributions and, er, comments. I mean, it's hard to keep track of which movie is more popular here. Although, I guess Real Genius wouldn't have been able to make a showing, and we'd need to provide an implicit CowboyNeal option also. - Andy Bakun

Dogma. - Tyler Hurst

Chasing Amy - Adrian

So. Is anyone keeping score? - Victor Ganata

Dogma - FFing Enigma (aka Tina)

Dogma - Amber, Random Time Lord

No, but if I was keeping score, I'd be using Iranian voting methods so of course Chasing Amy would win regardless. - Alex Scoble

1,000,000 to 25 for Chasing Amy?!?! Wait a minute. - Victor Ganata

Dogma - Shannon Jiménez

Dogma - Wes Hoogenboom from iPhone

Dogma. - Derek Coward

Chasing Amy. Definitely - jmcampbell

Chasing Amy - manielse (Mark Nielsen)

Dogma. - Steven Perez

Jersey Girl FTW! JUST KIDDING, Dogma. - Aaron Hood

Dogma - Peter Ghosh

Chasing Amy. - Shawn Whitmire

tie between Dogma and Mallrats - Ⓐ ☠ slayerboy ☠ Ⓐ

Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back FTW - B. Hatin