“Why do I have such strong feelings against Amazon's Kindle? I honestly don't know. It seems like a massive waste of DRM'ed money.”
Andrew Badera, AnotherⓃⓄⒶⒽ, CannonGod and Josh Bancroft liked this
I have always loved the idea of using a single, thin n portable device where I could get electronic versions of publications transmitted to it.. be it a magazine or newspaper subscription, or even as I walk past somewhere and get a free publication beamed to it. The kindle, and even sonys offering, just aren't there yet. I guess star trek spoiled me ;) - alphaxion
Have you actually used one for any length of time? Or explored the myriad of DRM-free options to get content onto the Kindle (FeedBooks, ManyBooks, Project Gutenberg, Archive.org, Creative Commons, etc.)? Even the clever hacks to get automatic delivery of blog feeds as "newspapers", without paying for them through Amazon? The Kindle is actually a pretty open platform. Only the books Amazon sells have DRM on them (and not all of them do - some are secretly DRM free). And the DRM is no worse than iTunes. - Josh Bancroft
Plus all the innovative features it DOES deliver - the unlimited, no-monthly-fee EVDO service, web browsing, AskNowNow, Audible audiobook and MP3 playback, not to mention the gorgeous high DPI eInk screen and tremendous battery life (weeks with the radio turned off). I think the Kindle gets a bad rap from people who haven't actually used one. But that's just me. I'm a rabid fan. :-) - Josh Bancroft
The kindle is TOTALLY there for novel and business book reading. At least 70% or more of the books I buy will be on a device like the kindle from now on. We need another form factor, though, to handle technical specs like most programming books, text books, etc... Amazon has something with that in mind coming up next. I don't like the DRM either, but I really don't like cluttering meatspace with dead tree by-products. - Tad - the Meme Maker
Ok forget the DRM. What do you think of the Tech? How can it be improved? What Do you like about it? Where could it be used? Who would use it? These are the questions we want to hear your expert geekyness answer. - Bored
The DRM is a non-issue for me. The Kindle , in its current form, is an amazing device. I bought it to read books, and I have read more in the past year than I had in the five years prior (books, mind you - I read constantly online). So, I bought it for that purpose, and it serves its purpose amazingly. Can't wait for the new one. ;) - Andru Edwards
Next time we're in the same town, Chris, I challenge you to a Kindle throwdown. It's not perfect, but it suffers from a LOT of misconceptions. I'd love a chance to set the record straight (and no, I have no stake in Amazon or anything besides being a happy Kindle owner). Do you accept my challenge? :-) - Josh Bancroft
Indeed. An iPod Touch 8GB, eReader app 'Stanza' w/ the option to upload/download your own ebooks via app beats the Kindle hands down ;-) - CannonGod
I hated the Next and Previous buttons the first day - always clicking them at the wrong time, but since then I haven't had any problems. I'm not sure I'm a raving fan, but I really, really like my kindle. It's a transformative tech. I don't want to read clunky ole meatspace books anymore. - Tad - the Meme Maker
I have a Kindle and love it mainly because it makes books I otherwise never getting around to reading completely accessible. The form factor is also outstanding and the digital ink screen reads like a real book. - Brad Bostic
The Kindle rocks. Kicks the tar out of reading on the iPhone. Honestly, that's not even a realistic comparison (I have both.) Downside? The UI for the Kindle is terribly slow. Mine will hang occasionally, needing a reboot. Otherwise, I'm reading much more now that I have one, DRM or not, and to me that's a Good Thing. Can't wait for rev2! - Jack Baty
Again guys, try reading on your iPhone or Touch for more than an hour or two - serious freaking eye strain. The screen size is all wrong too. I'm not saying it's worth the $350 - but I am saying that it will be ubiquitous when the price dips under $100 - Tad - the Meme Maker

