It sits on the Dems 100%. From this day forward, people who don't make enough to pay taxes, will not be getting home loans.
- Morgan Warstler
I am afraid that Robert is correct. A depression will only further the divide between the have's and have-not's. I think that we will soon see the disappearance of the "middle class" entirely.
- Mathew A. Koeneker
I would have to disagree that it sits only with the Democrats. I feel that quite a few profited on all of this. There ought to be some repercussions for those that gave the loans and made money from them. Golden parachutes be damned.
- Mathew A. Koeneker
I guarantee that most of the people who got rich off of the system are not Democrats.
- Alex Scoble
*sigh* It is depressing to see such if/then logic presented for no bailout/depression. If this bailout keeps fiscally irresponsible people in homes it will have a negative effect as well. It's interesting that left leaning folks often say they'd pay a bit more in taxes if they knew it helped a majority of Americans. Yet, a 25-35% drop in 401k accounts (for a short span of time) to benefit the majority of Americans seems to be rejected outright. [ducking]
- AJ Kohn
i am starting to think this is a bad idea. This is a short term solution.
- PC Easy
from twhirl
the debtor prisons in England during the industrial revolution were excused on the nonsensense that those inside were the guilty parties
- David HC Soul
The bailout may not prevent a depression. But it will shatter the illusion we live in a free-market economy.
- J.D. Deutschendorf
@alex, this has nothing to do with who made money - the rules were changed on purpose by the Dems to get themselves some votes, they insisted the bad loans be made to low income, bad credit risks - they (and apparently you) own it 110%. You are required to admit the source of the problem. You can't blame bankers for playing by the rules set by the Dems.
- Morgan Warstler
I can't blame bankers for making poor business decisions just because it was legal? Like hell I can't. Just because something is legal doesn't make it a good idea. There's plenty of blame to go around and most of it does not sit squarely with us Democrats.
- Alex Scoble
@alex, Nope it sits on you, in you, all around you. Repeat after me: this would not have happened, could not have happened, if Dems didn't mandate with laws that banks take risks (guaranteeing them!) to help the poor gets homes. If not but for your agenda, we'd not be dealing with this. Hope all those unfortunate people in foreclosure was worth it!! Denial ain't just a river buddy.
- Morgan Warstler
Me thinks Morgan is a being a bit revisionist considering it was Phil Gramm, a McCain advisor and former campaign member, who pushed through the legislation.
- John Frost
So, what we have here, folks, is a true dichotomy. There, unfortunately, is no good solution. Alex is right that just because something was legal, it wasn't "right." Robert is right in that a true market depression hurts almost everyone. AJ and Lucretia are right that rewarding stupidity is foolish. And David is right that a "debtors prison" is not the answer. Solution? I don't have a good one either...
- MVB (Grinch of FF)
Then you don't believe in personal responsibility? Don't believe that companies should behave ethically, responsibly and intelligently regardless of law? So much for the cornerstone of civilization.
- Alex Scoble
@frosty - again, nope. This isn't about regulation/no regulation oversight / no oversight - this is about relaxing credit requirements themselves for bad risks to get homes. More oversight wouldn't have stopped this... the market was bastardized by the Dems to buy votes from lower income people. That's the fact. Fan/fred were instructed by law to do the Dems bidding, and buy up bad loans made to low income people (read Dem voters).
- Morgan Warstler
@Morgan: First, subprime lending started to surge in the mid-1990s and comprised 8.6 percent of all mortgages in 2001. Second, deregulation and greed are the culprits. Finally, you're wrong. Demographics on subprime lending do not support the low income theory. Here is but one link, many others can be found readily: http://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2007...
- AJ Kohn
Personal responsiblity = People who don't have 10-20% down get no mortgage. Anything else is BS. Banks were leaned on by the Dems to do this, Fannie went looking for this stuff to buy! You pwnd this Alex, eat up.
- Morgan Warstler
I didn't create this problem...and also by your rules, just about no one (NO ONE!) in the bay area would be able to buy a home. And you have completely gone off the tracks on your argument. Have a nice day sir. Fact: Businesses that got into the business of making bad loans to people that couldn't pay did so, not because they were forced to by the government, but because they thought they could make a quick buck. The responsibility lies squarely with the banking industry that acted unethically. Period.
- Alex Scoble
@AJ, you are missing mah point - The actual changes to the laws that enabled this were Dems. They altered the fundamentals of mortgage business for their own ends. What happens after that is of no matter... that policy is over, and we'd not be facing this if they didn't start it. Deal. Stop obfuscating.
- Morgan Warstler
@Alex - guess what? no one in the bay area is going to be able to afford a home loan. It has gone back to 10-20% and is staying there. Forever. "Never again." Your people thinking your way created it. Redeem yourself, change your mind.
- Morgan Warstler
Your assertion is patently false and completely ignores how our government works. Please stop arguing around the facts and actually play the hand you've been given, which is crap against 4 aces.
- Alex Scoble
Alex is right. @Morgan: Start making sense. Throw a link in there to the laws. Or talk about the secondary market for these loans which was the further culprit which, by the way, had everything to do with deregulation.
- AJ Kohn
Americans bet that the economic dip from 200-2007 would be short, and that they would be able to borrow from the future to finance the present. The future arrived, and they found that they're standard of living must go down. But no one wanted it to go down. So now country is in denial.
- Paul Denlinger
@Morgan: You *should* Google that, and read Wiki and other viewpoints. The statistics don't really support the theory. Contributing factor, maybe, *the* reason. No.
- AJ Kohn
Morgan is right. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac have always been slush funds for Dems who use it to get rich after leaving office and to provide campaign dollars to all to keep from getting regulated, but mostly to themselves. It was Dems interfering in the free market that caused this.
- Dawn
Bullshit AJ, this is on you and yours. Makes me sick and satisified. No one can outrun the market. The prime number at the root of this holocaust is "securitize risk for Dem votes" - pure class warfare - you are responsible. You are personally responsible. AJ is responsible. You blaming the bankers who did as instructed, and were paid to do so, is a laugh riot. Note this: you linked to...
more...
- Morgan Warstler
Have been a little slow getting going with this... tweaked lower back + travel = not much gym time as of late. Hit the gym yesterday for about 45 min. of cardio and am feeling good today. Getting back on track feels good!
In a very similar boat - travel and vacation messed up early momentum and now I'm +1 to my start weight. Got back into workout last night and healthy eating this wk, now let's see if I can stick to it! That's what's always hard for me.
- Aprille
Good luck Aprille! For me, the upcoming holiday weekend will be a mixed bag... lots of outdoor activities(+), as well as BBQ, Beer, etc.(-)
- steve albers
Wow - I inspired someone!! Good luck Holly! I had a good run [of workouts] last week and lots of golf course walking and gardening this weekend. Here's to two weeks in a row - the next hurdle.
- Aprille
thx lloyd, tho it may have come across funny - the pineapple is separate from the tea. The mint/lemonbalm is from my yard - abundant and good stuff
- Aprille
Aprille, if you like green tea, we have had really good luck w/ "Teasource.com"
- lloyd
Well, I WATCHED the tennis today, but didn't do a damn thing myself. I may have burned a calorie or two cheering!
- kbourke