Way to take the quote out of context. Full quote "Very simple. Invest in people. A happy, healthy worker is a good worker. Good for competition too."
- Jeremy Franklin
That's an even more bigoted response Jeremy. If you're hiring only those that don't have pre-existing conditions you're excluding a very valid workforce. It's not simple.
- Jesse Stay
Jeremy I don't know what you're saying
- Jesse Stay
I never said only hire certain people. You are assuming I did.
- Jeremy Franklin
So you're saying you won't discriminate against workers during hiring, but once you have hired them, if they aren't healthy, they aren't good? Makes a whole lot of sense.
- Jimminy IS Everybody
I am saying invest in your workers. Look at the original quote above.
- Jeremy Franklin
What if happy, healthy workers are good workers... as are happy, cared for workers? I also don't see healthy as excluding all disabilities. I think you can be healthy, happy, disabled, and a good worker.
- Heather
I still don't understand what Jeremy is saying, and how is this a solution to people with pre-existing conditions starting their own businesses?
- Jesse Stay
I'm not sure where the "solution to people with pre-existing conditions starting their own businesses" comes in, but Jeremy's full quote sounds valid to me. If your company invests in it's workers, both in furthering their career skills, training, and also offering benefits such as a good health-care plan and medical leave programs then you're going to end up with happy workers who are...
more...
- Lindsay
I was typing something but Lindsay said it way better.
- Heather
I thought Jeremy's quote was in response to my Tweet about people with pre-existing conditions starting their own businesses. I don't know what this conversation is about any more.
- Jesse Stay
I still don't get what this has to do with that.
- Jesse Stay
So how is that good for entrepreneurs?
- Jesse Stay
Ken, is it really? That seems to be the suggested frame of thought, but that is questionable, without seeing it in action. There simply isn't any empirical data to support that sentiment.
- Jimminy IS Everybody
Sick people don't work as well as cared for people? I really don't see how it wouldn't be good to care for people's health.
- Heather
Heather, define "sick" - my father-in-law doesn't have joints in his knees. Does that make him sick? My mother-in-law has Diabetes - does that make her sick? The new healthcare reform makes starting a business more expensive for them, not less.
- Jesse Stay
I still have no clue what this conversation is about though
- Jesse Stay
My dad has had knee surgery (both his knees) and spinal surgery. He would be a lot less capable if we didn't have insurance to help pay for those things. My mom takes high blood pressure medication and she would be less healthy without it. I have chronic heartburn, asthma and allergies. I would be much more sick without medication. Health care is how we are more capable, happier, and healthier to be more productive people.
- Heather
Heather ask him if he could ever afford to start his own business under this new bill though. If he thought it was expensive to run his own business before this bill, just wait until after it passes.
- Jesse Stay
Moot point, he was self employed and never interested in making it a bigger business. Also, how do you know what will happen? There's 4 years from now until anything goes into effect and republicans love to yell about small businesses. I doubt small business owners will be completely ignored. As my situation is, I couldn't afford to work for a small business that doesn't provide...
more...
- Heather
Heather, never play the "how do you know if" game - once a bill has been passed it's even harder to get it unpassed. Obama sure is hinging his next election on this, though, as are many of the Democrats voting for it. I think it's political suicide, personally.
- Jesse Stay
All I'm saying is that it's difficult if not impossible to know how the bill will function if it passes in it's current state or if any legislation will go through after to modify it's effects on small businesses. And all that is based on the assumption you know the details of the bill. I don't and I think few people do.
- Heather
Jesse, due respect, the bill does absolutely nothing that would impede someone from starting a business. The employer-related provisions (that they have to offer employees coverage or pay a fee of $2000 for each employee who relies on gov't sponsored coverage) don't apply to businesses with fewer than 50 employees. So, unless you know people who start a business with 50 employees on day 1, that's just a red herring.
- Kevin (aka ThreadKilla)
Kevin, do you have a link to where it says that? If that's the case, you're probably right. I haven't had anyone able to show me where the benefits to small business are, though.
- Jesse Stay
Don't swaet the details kids - this bill will never be repeales but like Social Security and Medicare and hundreds of ungoing federal programs it will be amended changed revised endlessly at least annually
- WarLord
http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin... Paragraph 2 of the "Nearly $1 Trillion Cost" section explains the effect on businesses and explicitly states the part about not requiring business under 50 people to insure their employees.
- Chieze Okoye
Pretty much every story that covers the provisions mentions the under 50 employee exemption. As someone who has worked for and helped manage small businesses for the past 23 years, I can tell you how it helps small business. In my current company (~25 people) our 2nd largest cost, behind salaries, is health insurance. We've had years where our rates have gone up 20-30 percent because 1...
more...
- Kevin (aka ThreadKilla)
One final comment, Jesse. I think it's interesting that you were OK suggesting the bill was bad for small business without even understanding one of its most basic provisions. That's kind of emblematic of the entire discussion around health care reform. Opponents have repeated the made-up criticisms that it's "bad for business" or "socialism" or "takes away choice" so often that even smart people like you buy them, when the evidence to the contrary is right there in black and white.
- Kevin (aka ThreadKilla)
I still don't quite get the whole idea of getting "insurance" for a "pre-existing condition". The very notion of it seems to negate the idea of "insurance" in the first place. I mean, what, is it supposed to become a monthly payment plan at that point or something? How can you insure something that is already broken? It'd be like me wrecking my car then buying insurance after the fact.
- Otto
Sam, I think you're letting a semantic distinction distract you from the larger issue. Insurance companies use the "preexisting condition" excuse to deny coverage to *healthy* people and not pay claims for things that should legitimately be covered. For example, people have had claims denied for major illnesses because they "failed" to disclose preexisting conditions like acne. I am not making this up.
- Kevin (aka ThreadKilla)
Agreed, and that's an abusive practice that should certainly be stopped. But that still doesn't answer the question of why the law is written the way it is.... because the law doesn't stop the abusive practice, it goes further than that. If the goal of the law was to stop the abuse, then it should be written to do exactly that.
- Otto
Hey, it just occurred to me. If the penalty for no-health-insurance is only $750, and they can't turn you away for pre-existing conditions, then it makes a hell of a lot more sense for me to not get health insurance at all, and just wait until I get sick before paying for the insurance. Great way to scam the system, I'd say. Insurance will always cost more than the fine does.
- Otto
There's a percentage tacked onto that, so it's $750 or x%, whichever is greater. It's not that easy.
- Jesse Stay
Otto, the reform goes further than just outlawing the abuse because in a system like that, policing for the abuse then becomes costly, there are always edge cases, and a *lot* of lobbying effort would be expended on shifting the boundary in favor of the insurance companies (which, in effect, is how we got the current situation). Simpler, and cheaper, to just do away with the issue entirely.
- Michael R. Bernstein
Jesse: 2.5% of my income is still less than I would reasonably pay for health insurance. Especially when this plan drives the premiums up. Also, if you look real close (page 336 of the bill), you'll notice that there's no penalties for not paying the no-insurance "fine". It's basically unenforceable.
- Otto
Michael: It's not cheaper or simpler. Eliminating denials for pre-existing conditions makes zero sense in the context of insurance. That's simply not how insurance works. Again, I point to the example of me wrecking my car then paying one payment to an insurance company in order to get them to buy me a brand new one. You can't get insurance to protect against events which have already occurred.
- Otto
No, I only skimmed the major points that I didn't understand from the summaries. Damn thing is 2400 pages long. Here's the file: http://docs.house.gov/rules... But I tend to find that quick summaries I read online tend to be wrong when I don't understand them, so I hit those points of the bill directly to see what it really said.
- Otto
Sam, that's not how insurance works *in a for-profit insurance model.* The key issue here is that the profit motive has always come before the imperative to ensure that people have the chance to be healthy. And that's why our system doesn't work for so many people.
- Kevin (aka ThreadKilla)
1. It's "Otto". Come on... 2. There's nothing inherently wrong with a for-profit model or motive. Where it goes wrong is when it becomes over-regulated and the amount of profit margins made so thin by this that the tactics used to create that profit become immoral and unethical. This sort of incorrect behavior by insurance companies is a direct result of over-regulation of the industry in a failing economic period. This sort of continued over-regulation won't solve the problem, it'll only exacerbate it.
- Otto
As a Sonos user, I can assure him that Blackberry comes after iPhone. What other choice is there?
- Michael Krigsman
They should hit Windows Mobile, in all honesty. Just from a penetration standpoint. Of course, I have no idea how feasible that is. But they should definitely go with Android over WebOS so they don't tie themselves to ONE device on the market.
- Andru Edwards
@Robert Yeah, it shouldn't matter which phone. Just target the platform....
- Travis B. Hartwell
Michael: blackberry users don't do much other than email.
- Robert Scoble
from iPhone
Andru: Palm will have more devices out with webOS by the end of the year, I predict by the middle of 2010 every carrier will have webOS devices.
- Luke Kilpatrick
No other platform offers the freedom that android does IMHO
- Robert Burgin
However, more important than platform, they should allow the desktop application to play synched music with the Sonos system. Sure, there are technical reasons militating against this, but they should figure it out.
- Michael Krigsman
Yes, Robert. An application written for the HTC Dream/T-Mobile G1 should work on the HTC Magic/T-Mobile myTouch 3G. As for the HTC Hero and other non-Google Android forks, applications *should* be able to work, I think. Not completely sure, though; so correct me if I'm wrong.
- Rishabh Mishra (p248)
That is not true at all, Robert. I know many, many people who buy BlackBerry as a consumer device nowadays. The iPhone has changed that perception of smartphones.
- Andru Edwards
Robert: hmmm....and Blackberry users do not use Sonos systems?
- Michael Krigsman
And in case I didn't make it clear enough, I totally want Android support.
- Rishabh Mishra (p248)
Anyway, glad we are having the same debate they are having internally.
- Robert Scoble
from iPhone
Luke, I know. But right now, there is just one device, with nothing else announced. It makes more sense to go where the users are.
- Andru Edwards
Sonos has a cool controller coming out tonight, by the way.
- Robert Scoble
from iPhone
I had the Curve and my G1 blows it away just my experience though
- Robert Burgin
Android. Given enough time, I think the number of andoid handsets is going to radically outnumber all the others. Jus a hunch.
- mikepk
from iPhone
We Sonos users do not need whiz bang coolness -- we need solid functionality that works.
- Michael Krigsman
How about their own? I'd really like smaller, less expensive remote. Also, *any* level of control with a Logitech Harmony remote would be fantastic.
- Kevin Fox
I am putting together all of our assets on the new controller right now. Check out Gear Live in 90 minutes for all the news ;)
- Andru Edwards
The iPhone controller is excellent: well-designed and makes use of existing hardware so no additional cost. That's superb.
- Michael Krigsman
Palm Pre. New apps are hugely popular now.
- Jon Winters
I took the plunge and finally joined FF just to tell you to support Android. You know in your heart its the least evil of the platforms.
- Neeraj Kumar Agrawal
Get him to cut his hardware costs in half so that his stuff is affordable...
- Buzz Bruggeman
I second the Public API. It not only would benefit all the phone platforms, but soooo much more.
- Ward Mundy
Robert: If you are still with the Sonos team - Please ask when the new controller will be available in other Markets? Australia? Thanks.
- Clifford Kennedy
I third the vote for an API. There are some hacky UPNP Apis but a formal API would open up many new apps-
- Tom Wentworth
from iPhone
Why only one more platform? Seriously, they should do a few. Android and WebOS to start with.
- Cyrus Lendvay
I love my Sonos, but can you please ask him why I should get a new smaller controller for $350 when I could get an iPod Touch that does the same thing and more for less money?
- Kevin Fox
Kevin - the new controller is something you can leave in a common, shared area, has much better screen resolution, replaceable battery, etc.
- Andru Edwards
Andru: Do I need a resolution better than the iPod Touch in order to control a Sonos? If my iPod Touch only has the Sonos app on it, what's the concern of leaving it in a common area? It's a home, not a dorm after all. Lastly, when would it possibly be better for me to replace a battery than to put the controller back in a charging cradle?
- Kevin Fox
Blackberry would reach more users. Android 3rd
- LANjackal
Kevin, it's not for eveyone, but it gives you the option. I have an iPod touch, and an iPhone, both with the Sonos controller on them. But what if I don't want you, or any other guest, using my iPhone and possibly seeing my text messages or other alerts that come through on those devices? Obviously, those devices can be rich with personal info, that I don't want shared. If I hand you my...
more...
- Andru Edwards
I concede some of your points. It's also nice to have an integrated bundle with a single-purpose remote. For my own needs (and I may not be the target demographic) I already have a Sonos system and am considering an additional remote. My point is that buying an iPod Touch to be used exclusively for controlling the Sonos makes more sense for me. It's highly responsive, can easily sit in...
more...
- Kevin Fox
Yeah, I don't know WHY they price is that high - but it is cheaper than the older one, with more features. Also, the older one is going to be very heavily discounted until it sells out, so there's that. One other benefit, which may or may not be attractive to some, is you pick up the controller, and it is ready immediately. No pressing of the home button, sliding the screen, finding the app, waiting for it to connect to network.
- Andru Edwards
WebOS: any professional Web developer working today can start developing for it right now, without learning anything they don't already know: HTML, CSS, Javascript.
- .LAG liked that
I've had 5 Sonos units for the last 5 years, very very pleased.....it was actually the "THING" that made my change jump from a HTC Windows Phone to an iphone, it was the deciding factor. They were nice enough to offer to replace the controller after my pup got a hold of it: http://www.flickr.com/photos...
- Jacob Shea
I would suggest Android, however choose which mobile OS has the largest market share.
- Wayne M
Android. One good open source project deserves another! Since this post originated, a pretty good, independent Android app for Sonos has appeared in the Android Market: Andronos.
- Ward Mundy
Phones with an Android operating system outsold iPhones in the first half of the year. There is other software that can take care of the different phone specifications. Andronos is quite good though.
- Jeremy Cave
CrunchPad looks pretty similar to Google's OS, very simple, very web centric. I wonder how Google shipping netbook OS will affect Arrington's plans?
- Robert Scoble
Mike is gonna bring out the first Google OS powered hardware ?
- Swaroop
Geoff: yes, but maybe CrunchPad 2.0 would shift because of it?
- Robert Scoble
I don't think the compelling feature of CrunchPad is its OS - it's the form factor. He won't lose anything by putting it on the CrunchPad as soon as it's released.
- Matt M (inactive)
hmm, thought that u have 2 plug into the USB and doesn't have much memory on its own? I may be wrong cuz I didn't get much info.
- polou/indigo_bow
I am looking forward to both launching. CrunchPad has a great form factor as well. We haven't seen anything from Google OS yet.
- Louis Gray
Swaroop: I doubt it, because CrunchPad needs touch features.
- Robert Scoble
well it will be open source, so I wouldn't be surprised if the innovations flow both ways - my understanding of the crunchpad is it is also based on Linux - so you might see features merge between both platforms...
- Shannon Clark
Shannon: yeah, I wonder if the CrunchPad OS could be ported to the Google OS? If so, that could be a big win for Mike.
- Robert Scoble
I bet it could, because CrunchPad OS is built on Linux and I bet it won't take much porting work to move it to Google OS.
- Robert Scoble
@All - May be Crunchpad emulator on Google OS :)
- Swaroop
crunchpad is silly and only gets press because its Mike Arrington's baby.
- Zac Bowling
Robert - my point is that potentially as well Google may be porting features from the Crunchpad - the beauty of OS platforms...
- Shannon Clark
Ah, I do like crunchpad much better perfect 4 my Canadian-ness eyes.
- polou/indigo_bow
Zac: I disagree. I want a CrunchPad. It looks interesting to me as a coffee table computer. A poor man's Microsoft Surface.
- Robert Scoble
In any case, I bet Michael's time spent on Crunchpad just went from 75% to 100%. Or at least it should. Getting caught slacking while an opportunity awaits is no good.
- Sam Dodge
Zak from the photos & features descriptions, I'm pretty darn interested in buying a Crunchpad - seems like a very useful formfactor and device
- Shannon Clark
my initial reaction is: "do we need another OS?" even more to the point, Chrome browser is still quite a ways from done (mostly plugin problems) and i've not seen a lot of progress in this area. my suspicion is that the OS will go the same route. big splash on the easy 80%, but slow going on the remainin (difficult) 20% i remain optimistically skeptical.
- MikeAmundsen
I'm pretty sure I'm going to pick up a freelance gig just to purchase a Crunchpad. If only to support Mike and his team as they take a huge leap from reporting on tech to making tech.
- Sam Dodge
Robert: Curious to what's on the coming monday.
- Swaroop
Swaroop: I can't tell you until Monday.
- Robert Scoble
OS define by Google isn't really an OS at all its like going 2 7-11. Anybody agree or disagree?
- polou/indigo_bow
Oh, you are a tease Robert! Do tell, we won't pass it on, promise! ;)
- Technogran
I think that Google Chrome OS lowers the barrier so that a lot of other companies can deliver their own pads. As such it is not a great news for Mike but it also validates the vision so may be a competitor might be interested in acquiring CrunchPad
- Edwin Khodabakchian
Robert: We won't let Google index what you say. nofollow
- Swaroop
Edwin: will CrunchPad ship with a "Google inside" sticker on it? :-)
- Robert Scoble
Robert: we had something like CrunchPad inside TI when I worked there a few years ago. not a resistive touchscreen but it was pretty cool. concept device to pitch the OMAP processors to the hardware vendors we designed in house. Nokia bought into it and created the 770, N800, and N810 devices from that tech.
- Zac Bowling
man i hope he uses it on the crunchpad instead!
- sean percival
With that form factor, it needs a wacom tablet and windows 7.
- Rodfather
I think that the bigger opportunity for the crunchpad is to enable other media companies (not Techcrunch) to buy the technology and create their own pads (everyone wants to replicate the Kindle model for their own content). The problem of Google OS is that it slice the Crunchpad in the middle.
- Edwin Khodabakchian
Rodfather: I disagree. There's a new opportunity to get rid of installable software and go completely with Internet platforms. That's why CrunchPad, Jolicloud, and Google's OS are so interesting.
- Robert Scoble
Google won't kill Microsoft. They don't need to. They need to open up new opportunities.
- Robert Scoble
Robert: I am still scared to put personal data out on the cloud. Is it time already ?
- Swaroop
Robert they need to use cloud, therefore still would not solve the problem of storage.
- polou/indigo_bow
I still want the option :) GoogleOS will run on anything. So it'll naturally make it there.
- Rodfather
They do not need to kill Microsoft but they need to change the terrain of the fight from search to productivity apps and OS and they are doing a good job at it.
- Edwin Khodabakchian
Edwin, I disagree, what is interesting about the Crunchpad is delivering a form factor that is better for many people than the Kindle (or at least a much better price point) I'm going to get one to use for lots of digital reading. Swaroop - pretty much all of my personal data is already in the cloud - and more secure there than on my computers in an earthquake zone
- Shannon Clark
is there the reason why there r SSL ways 2 purchase or other ways to keep data safe @Swaroop
- polou/indigo_bow
@Shannon. Form factor is cool but that is a pure hardware business, mostly outsourced to asian manufacturers and very thin margin. The software is where the barrier to entry and business models will be.
- Edwin Khodabakchian
Shannon: My confidence is shaken when a lot of personal data/docs get exposed due to flaws in software. We just need a "skynet" kind of bot to auto check for vulnerabilities.
- Swaroop
@edwin the software is open source - which means that anyone can use it. the margins, though thin are real if you do hardware right. Sure outsourced, but high design & a competitive price can equal very large sales so small margin still equals decent profits (and sustainable business)
- Shannon Clark
@shannon: so do you mean that Google Chrome OS will not reduce the barrier to entry for companies wanting to create their own XXX pad?
- Edwin Khodabakchian
no I mean the Crunchpad & the GoogleOS are both based on Open Source, so the competitive advantage of the crunchpad is hardware design, not software (as far as I know from what I've read)
- Shannon Clark
polou/indigo_bow: Yes data transfer and storage could be encrypted. We need better identity management too
- Swaroop
yup current identity identification issues r not my favorite, OpenID not all perfect even though I am a big fan of it. Its so hard to work with, grrr @swaroop i could say more but thats all 4 now.
- polou/indigo_bow
unless they have already licensed some of the patents covering the more popular touch idioms using GoogleOS would give them a broad-base multi-touch API to work with that has deeper pockets to fight the patent battles
- bear (aka Mike Taylor)
well this may sound strange - but I suspect more than a few patents could (potentially at least - I'm not a lawyer) be invalidated by prior art in the form of movies like Minority Report (and likely other earlier but less popular SF series & movies) which showed multitouch type of interfaces
- Shannon Clark
more copyrights problems cuz of the mighy $$$. that left the big boys again, isn't it?
- polou/indigo_bow
No mention on price...I wonder if google will go for the free + ads model. Imagine ads running on the desktop, along with annon. usage statistics, how much more will google know?
- Thomas Hunsaker
from Android
@thomas why assume they will run ads in/on the OS - I'd guess that like Android they offer it for free (or for a very marginal cost) to OEM's, bundled with a bunch of default links to Google properties (esp Google search as default) and profit from expanding the number of people & devices connected online. Add in revenues from selling cloud based packages such as Google Apps for Domains and they make money w/o ads on the desktop or privacy issues
- Shannon Clark
Thomas: why wouldn't Google Chrome OS be free?
- Robert Scoble
Thomas: You would have it Google Chrome OS Beta under Google Apps. And yes there will be a lite version where you can only run a single process :)
- Swaroop
Great discussion. I think Mike should not adopt Chrome OS for crunchpad to begin with. I don't even think Chrome OS would be polished by the time he plans to launch crunchpad. I think Crunchpad launch could set the bar and direction for what Google Chrome OS should/could be. In terms of usability, we still don't know how Google Chrome OS could play out. I think different initiatives such as Chrome, Crunchpad and Jolicloud will help this ecosystem,.
- Akshay Dodeja
I'll get a CrunchPad only if Chrome OS is in it
- Hendra
CrunchPad and ChromeOS are fundamentally distinct, seeing as they run completely different browsers (Firefox and Chrome, respectively). They will be able to share apps, though, as Google has stated that apps will work in any HTML 5 browser.
- Vezquex
Vezquex: why is the CrunchPad limited to Firefox? When I saw the CrunchPad I saw nothing that would limit it like that and that dependency, if it exists, is probably easily worked around.
- Robert Scoble
Robert - my guess is that as Firefox is one of the only browsers currently available for Linux that is what Vezquex is thinking - however with this announcement I suspect we can guess that Google will be announcing Chrome for Linux rather soon (which likely means for Mac OS as well)
- Shannon Clark
maybe he was in on the big secret and crunchpad is the first device running chrome os?
- Servaas Schrama
Thought I read the crunchpad has a webkit browser ... Not firefox - at least not by default.
- Jonathan Greene
from iPhone
I agree with the browser as the OS but why would I want a pad that I have to lift my knees up to see when I can have a lap top that I can tilt the screen to fit any position I fell like stretching out in? The price point is going to have to be low, low, low for this form factor to take off.
- Stephen Pickering
Scoble, Why you want to discuss this, when we have other worries. Running adobe in chrome, UI etc
- Michael_techie
Hello…? reality check. Is there a CrunchPad on the market? Is there a $249.95 CrunchPad on sale? Quit talking of it as it it were a done deal. It it anything but, and the promiseware may yet end up in TC Deadpool before it has shipped a single unit. Takes a bunch of geeks on FF to discuss implications of porting "CrunchPad OS," hell, emulating it even, on Chrome OS, before either has passed into the domain of the real.
- ianf ⌘
@Shannon Clark [suspects that] "more than a few patents could (potentially at least - I'm not a lawyer) be invalidated by prior art in the form of movies like Minority Report (and likely other earlier but less popular SF series & movies) which showed multitouch type of interfaces." - you are confusing Hollywood with Real Life, which I suggest you get a dose of, the latter.
- ianf ⌘
It's all Linux, and I suspect that crunchpad if it even has an OS uses it too. Swapping out one Linux for another is relatively easy if you've got the source and the hardware information. <3 the Linux Virus, an OS that runs on almost all known hardware, and even as a x86 BIOS for instant ON.
- rob friedman
@dodeja "I think Crunchpad launch could set the bar and direction for what Google Chrome OS should/could be." Puuhlease...get real, what have u been drinking?
- Hendra
I wish Mike luck with the pad but it's just not the right form factor for me, just a little too big from what i can tell. My ultimate would be like a 6" screen. With a device this size you have to decide if you are going to finger or thumb type. Anything in between is going to be awkward.
- Keith James Designs
actually no. If a work of fiction depicts an innovation (especially stuff like UI) that could certainly be prior art. The point of a patent is to be INNOVATION - prior art, even in fiction, is just that - earlier examples of someone else having the same idea. And in the case of Minority Report - a LOT of people contributed to build those interfaces & design ideas - see http://www.lukew.com/ff...
- Shannon Clark
Shannon, you win. Please be sure to report back here (minority- or majoritywise, either will do) on any patent application contesting case, where fantasy GUIs cooked up for film-clarity reasons –it's never an easy thing to show off on a cinema screen– are entered as exhibits of "prior art," therefore either invalidating, or denying a patent. I'll wait by the computer until next Tuesday, do we have a deal?
- ianf ⌘
How much faster is the new iPhone 3GS? It keeps up with friendfeed's realtime feed and the old one didn't. My son noted that 3G web pages are a lot faster too.
I'm getting slightly better battery life on my 3G with just the 3.0 update. I was hoping the 3GS would have substantial battery improvements though.
- Alex Knight
One of the many impressive ways it's shown off its speediness to me was on app updates. I had 12 waiting for me when I synced the 3GS first time to my Mac. I never, ever let it try to 'Update All' on the 3G because it usually took a long time just doing one at a time. Yesterday I gave it a go with the 12 updates - just over 1 minute - boom - done.
- Patrick Jordan
How are you accessing FF on the iPhone (I have a 3G)? What's your recommendation?
- Scotty Perkins
Scotty, BuddyFeed is the best app for the iPhone so far. AlertThingy is coming along nicely.
- LPH™ and his dog P™
Scotty: I am sitting on my couch talking with you on my iPhone just using the web browser (Safari) set to the standard FriendFeed site. I refresh often. :-)
- Robert Scoble
LPH: I have BuddyFeed and love but today I was typing a long comment and got a call in the middle of it and then when call was done my message I was typing was completely gone...I don't understand how the app would not save the message in that case...absurd!
- Mike Bracco
Do any of the iPhone apps do real-time updates yet?
- Jesse Stay
Mike, I've had similar things happen. I've lost pictures that way too ...
- LPH™ and his dog P™
LPH: yeah seems like a huge design flaw, I guess I'm so used to apps on iPhone just working so I was really surprised by behavior.
- Mike Bracco
Excellent, thanks. Will try those. I'm still getting my feed under me with FF.
- Scotty Perkins
Jesse - don't think so, if you mean any of the native FF apps and FF real time updates that is.
- Patrick Jordan
Try Google Earth - which was barely usable on the older models. It screams on the 3Gs - benefits from the CPU, gpu, and ram improvements - it's more responsive than my MacBook pro (though obviously I have a much larger screen on that).
- Robin Barooah
This is great news. I can justify buying one if it's substantially faster than the 3G.
- RobinDotNet
Robert: I have a 3Gs since yesterday. I did not have the old 3G but sometimes I grabbed my friends' ones. I can tell you is faster and that the 's' is a good descriptor.
- Eduardo Loyola
Did you mean OS 3.0 or OS 2.x on the 3G didn´t keep up with FF realtime feed ?
- ɯɥøq sɐɯoɥʇ
It blows that you have to go to the regular FF site to get the realtime updates. The iPhone site is much better adapted to the size of the screen but you still have to refresh. Do you think this is because of speed concerns?
- Wim Mulder
Wim: yes. Realtime was useless on old iPhone. Even on new one I keep it off most of the time.
- Robert Scoble
Is there a concern that developers might start building apps that won't work/are too slow with the older models?
- Obayoo
Obayoo: that almost is a certainty. Games, my son says, are much better on the new hardware.
- Robert Scoble
Jeff Atwood posted a link to a great video from the iPhone Blog that compared side by side the 3g with the 3gs and it was pretty well twice as fast.
- travispuk
I turned Wifi off yesterday after the first 2 hours of usage and then proceeded to use 3G the rest of the day for all data and forgot I wasn't on Wifi... Fast is an understatement, however I'd like to see some side-by-side speed tests for 3G vs 3GS. Not convinced just yet that folks need that "S", the more efficient OS could be adding to the speed... With that said, provided I un-brick...
more...
- JR
iPhone provides me tools for work and leisure that have me very excited about modern (social) media.
- Dave Blankenship
Ahhh..thought maybe we were just to enjoy the view of the countdown through your monitor. Is there such a thing as living vicariously through someone's online life? Deep thoughts for a Friday night.
- Suburban Oblivion
Plz don't take this the wrong way---this is one of the geekiest things I have ever seen. I mean this in a complimentary way. Wow.
- Rob Michael (Atmos Trio)
Pouring my glass of Pinot Noir now, Jesse - headed over to join you. Thanks for hosting. You de man. :)
- Mari Smith
I'm pretty sure the blog said you can't
- Mike Hartman
Yep. Yer right, Mike "Think carefully about the username you choose. Once it's been selected, you won't be able to change or transfer it."
- Ken Sheppardson
Which is odd - you'd think the primary id would still be the existing numerical one, so why would it be so tightly coupled you can't easily change it?
- Mike Hartman
You need to exploit the fact that you run all these "opposing" pages/groups by posting something that starts some kind of flame/holy war. People will sign up in droves.
- Mike Hartman
I can see why they wouldn't let you just create a ton of pages/apps and give them all names, but 1000 followers seems like a pretty high bar.
- Ken Sheppardson
You need a "we are atheists" just to play fair
- Mike Hartman
If I were you I'd probably shoot off an email right now to Facebook with the URLs you'd chose for apps like SocialToo, and point out that the name is available as of the time you sent the email.
- Ken Sheppardson
You'd think that for the apps they would give # of users equal weight to # of fans
- Mike Hartman
Jesse, I confess that I hadn't joined SocialToo until this evening, but now that I have, my Facebook page is available via both the http://www.facebook.com/johnebr... and http://empoprises.socialtoo.com/ URL (for my blogs). Nice! Now that I've joined, I definitely want to check out the Twitter auto-unfollow feature (Twitter auto-follow doesn't really interest me).
- John E. Bredehoft
Yep. facebook.com/friendfeed should go to the FriendFeed app... not some unrelated user.
- Ken Sheppardson
I don't understand why they have a minimum letter requirement anyway
- Mike Hartman
I heard someone joking how it would be funny if Twitter got fail whale because everyone was tweeting about facebook - while facebook stayed up..haha
- Mike Bracco
on a side note, http://www.backtype.com/ is amazing. If someone mentions my full name in FF I get an email within a couple minutes referencing the comment. Really great tool for monitoring.
- Mike Bracco
Mike, yeah - I wish I could get stay if he can have loic
- Jesse Stay
what about.... facebook.com/superduperfacebookdeveloperpimpdaddydeluxe ?
- Jeff (Team マクダジ )
Sweet do I get a prize for helping you with the name? :) It does have a nice ring to it though.
- BRҰANSAҰS
BTW - "All Pages created after May 31, 2009 or that had less than 1,000 fans on that day will be eligible to claim usernames on Sunday, June 28, 2009."
- Ken Sheppardson
What a FUN FUN FUN night!!!!! http://facebook.com/marismith = my bright shiny new FB URL for my fan page. (same as /mari.smith. Periods make no diff, eh). And got /maris for personal profile. Wonder if that 5k limit will get lifted like @Scobleizer said couple months back.
- Mari Smith
Great to see you tonight Mari! I'm hoping on it. I'm getting closer to the limit.
- Jesse Stay
Are we going to go through this again on June 28 when all the new users and <1,000 follower pages get to pick names? :-/
- Ken Sheppardson
Thanks, Jesse!! You are a social media leader my friend. :D
- Mari Smith
My personal brand has been The "Social" Geek - I own socialgeek.tv, so that could be a good one, but it could get confused with Social Geeks
- Jesse Stay
Hey Jolie! Nice to see you here. Yes, it's going to be a focus on Early Adopter technologies, Social and Real-time web, and whatever we feel like talking about essentially. :-)
- Jesse Stay
just you or you & guests? (could do something like a play on "stay with me")
- Shannon Clark
Louis Gray will be on the show with me tomorrow - it may be a regular thing with him. We're still discussing details. The local Salt Lake Fox News Tech Reporter, Kirk Yuhnke, who just got a new Palm Pre is going to guest tomorrow. We'll be bringing in more guests on future podcasts.
- Jesse Stay
I like Shannon's "Stay with Me" but unfortunately that does not reflect the purpose of the podcast
- Vinko
I'll broadcast each one live on http://ustream.tv/channel..., and we'll release a nice recording at the end of each week. Tomorrow will be an interesting first run.
- Jesse Stay
I have been kicking around the name "appdeavors" a discussion forum around applications and other technology adoption for creative problem solving. If you like it and can put the domain to use earlier you can have it.
- Rob Jensen
I'd leave the pun aspect out of it, tbh.
- Jolie O'Dell
one small suggestion - whatever you decide to name it, record a short bumper with the name, URL etc (potentially sponsors when you get them) and be sure to lead in and/or close with it so that the file itself always has that info in it - podcasts which just start up without a quick intro can be hard to refer back to if you are listening to a bunch of things in a row (or if they get crossposted somewhere)
- Shannon Clark
Rob, interesting. I'm still trying to figure out the full focus. I'd like it to be kind of a bridge between the technical and less technical audiences though, which is sort of what I do on my blog. More than anything, I mostly want to just have fun and keep it relaxed, to the extent it's still entertaining.
- Jesse Stay
Shannon, that's why I'm recording - I'll be using GarageBand to put something interesting via audio together. If it's video I'll also be recording it all in iMovie so we can make it either a video or audio podcast. I agree, intro is important.
- Jesse Stay
Jeremy, I'm shooting for around 8:30pm MST tomorrow. I'm still getting confirmation from all involved though. I'm going to post all confirmed details on StayNAlive.com shortly.
- Jesse Stay
Of course, the other idea is to brand it with the SocialToo brand and do kind of what DiggNation is doing.
- Jesse Stay
Since you previously mentioned this on Facebook, I've been thinking that Stay N' Alive may have its own issues. For people who have never heard of you, the first thing that they will think about when they see that name is the Bee Gees song.
- John E. Bredehoft
Looking forward to more information and sounds like a great project. Branding through SocialToo is an option however if you are going to have rotating seats for guests it sounds like it could be more confusing to me.
- Rob Jensen
Perhaps another route might be to create a new brand by emphasizing your first name, which would add a personal touch to the podcast, and combine it with your expertise. For example, "Jesse's Face." Or something.
- John E. Bredehoft
John, I'll be hosting, but I'd like to allow the others on feel as much a part of it as I am though. For instance, Louis Gray has an open invitation to attend each podcast he wants to join, and if it has my name I can't give him as much credit as he deserves.
- Jesse Stay
A better idea, if you can live with having one show without a branded name. Set up some type of contest (perhaps using a prize of a book as an incentive) to solicit a name. I'll grant that's what you're doing now, but perhaps the contest, rather than just soliciting name ideas, could require the participants to do something creative to submit their entry - create a Facebook page for their proposed name, for example.
- John E. Bredehoft
Bryan, I'm edging towards that - there is already a "Social Geeks" podcast though, which might become confusing. I've already got everything set up for TheSocialGeek.tv though if we go that way.
- Jesse Stay
What are some of the topics of your podcast?
- BRҰANSAҰS
The Best Geek Show EVAR! And BestGeekShow.com is totally available
- Jolie O'Dell
Bryan, tech in general, but mostly early-adopter technologies. Tomorrow we'll be talking about the Pre and WWDC
- Jesse Stay
Jolie, still not sure if I'll use it, but at least I can now :-)
- Jesse Stay
Bryan, hopefully quality of guests, focus on early adopter technologies, expertise and knowledge of the industry. For now I'm doing this for fun, so I guess it doesn't matter until we really want to compete. :-)
- Jesse Stay
It's a good domain to have. I'm out to work on more RWW posts - have a fun night! *hugs*
- Jolie O'Dell
Jolie, enjoy. I've got a post or two I've got to do as well. I'll talk to you later.
- Jesse Stay
Sid, appreciate that. I'm trying to avoid locking us into just talking about Social Media though. I own SocialMediaCast.com so we could use that if we wanted to go that route.
- Jesse Stay
Might not work for a podcast, but if you ever do a half hour sitcom about growing up in the 50s, you should call it "Leave it to Stay"
- Ken Sheppardson
Eric thanks - we'll be mostly talking about the Palm Pre and WWDC. It will be Louis Gray, myself, and a local Tech Reporter who got the Pre yesterday that's going to talk about it.
- Jesse Stay
It's magic. Frees your mind from the stupid bullet list that bores audiences to death. Every time I see a PowerPoint deck my brain turns off.
- Robert Scoble
I have used this for years, great communication tool
- Mel Buckpitt
i prefer personalbrain. not as easy to use as mind manager but powerful nonetheless.
- Daniel Langendorf
Robert, as a former highschool teacher, I can assure you that Powerpoint is the evil enemy of learning...and yet every school insisted teachers started using it because the schools thought PP "was" technology...yikes. Advice? Tell stories with passion and understanding.
- Daniel Kenney
Daniel: I totally agree. The way schools teach technology just makes me ill.
- Robert Scoble
anyone ever try prezi.com? it's a bit different-- much more visual
- Ted Curran
So instead of Powerpoint™, use a real presentation platform that allows interactive data and tactile response to both you and your audience.
- Eric Martindale
i have been working on a new keynote /powerpoint method I can
- Ted Curran
PowerPoint is only a problem in that it makes it way too easy to just make lists of bullet points. They almost force you to go down that path. If they could somehow turn that off, and just provide the functionality to create a series of slides, each of which had a line or two of text, an image, etc... I don't think it'd get such a bad rap.
- Ken Sheppardson
*call "Attention Method"-- it's a way to use PPT or Apple Keynote not in the way the program wants to be used but in the way people's minds work
- Ted Curran
similar to other software noted is my favorite.. Big Mouth
- Daniel Kenney
What makes Mind Manager the first platform to come to mind? I have never heard of it until right now.
- Amani
I don't want to get into a PowerPoint bashing thing here, but I agree it's bad. Another thing I've noticed is that the boring speakers usually have the most elaborate PP presentations. Yikes.
- Christopher Harper
I'm a big fan of MindManager as well. Once you're done conceptualizing your presentation, Powerpoint (or any other presentation tool) can obviously be used as an effective tool. Powerpoint isn't innately evil, it's just too easy to miss-use. If you want to try a different tool give sliderocket.com a try. (but I'd stick with Mindmanager)
- Jason Goldberg
Well that's two programs I had no idea existed 15 minutes ago.
- Dean Clark
Do you use iThoughts iPhone app? I use it every day and they just upgraded to allow Mind Manager export
- Dave
Prezi is too difficult to learn for anyone - it is supercool but if you want to get right down to working, forget it - I wish I could use it - for mindmaps to me nothing beats MindMeister both for presentation materials as well for organizing ideas and tools - it is much easier and immediate than any other mindmapping tool I have tried, including having a full revisions history, working...
more...
- Robin Good
In the end the vote of PowerPoint chastity should really be targeted at avoiding making the "types" of PowerPoint slideshows that are so bad. Bad choice of images, too much text, and you reading them as you show them. It is not the tool so much, but the culture we have built around it. Whether with PowerPoint, Keynote, Sliderocket, OpenOffice or GoogleDocs the power of your presentation...
more...
- Robin Good
I wholeheartedly agree with you..PP is horrible! I refuse to use it and I've made a point to reject ppt files that colleagues send me with slides re design changes. I'll have to give MindManager a try..sounds great.
- Sufian Siddiqi
from fftogo
Prezi does look cool. I definitely need to take it for a spin.
- Alexander Grundner
The issue with powerpoint (and keynote) is that the flow of the presentation is completely locked in, and the presentation environment is unchanging. Mindmanager (or Freemind) allows branching, and the ability to store extra content for questions (only use as needed). Powerpoint or equivalent is good for building a screen when you want one that can dynamically build. An alternative way...
more...
- Alistair Nicholson
I used to use Thebrain.com personal brain for the same purpose. I stopped when I moved to multiplatforms (Mac and linux as well as Windows). I just checked back at the site to find that it is now available cross-platform (haven't checked that the data files are yet tho). I might be remaking contact with an old friend! I liked the easy way one could use local files or web resources. By...
more...
- Alistair Nicholson
@alistair: It is possible to branch PowerPoint -presentations with hyperlinks that jump from slide to another. Never considered it, but interesting idea. For example, after determining audience level, it could skip slides that explain basic things for experienced audience.
- Jemm
I like Mind Manager. Wish i had a reason to use it.
- Rodfather
Definitely. That was the last time I used it. It integrated with OneNote well too.
- Rodfather
Check out the free pptplex from Office Labs which is an add in for PP that gives you a similar zooming interface as Prezi. http://www.officelabs.com/project...
- Jamie
Alistair: That is exactly how I use PersonalBrain. I have it set up in Dropbox and am able to access it with any computer. It's worth a look-see again. It's also worth using to flesh out ideas for presentations, too, no matter what tool you end up using.
- Daniel Langendorf
Use Prezi at Prezi.com! ;) or sliderocket.com
- Csaba Mad
I am adoring Prezi - just the freshness of the look gives you a 50% boost in new biz meetings, and I really haven't found it at all hard to learn to use
- Jamie
Last week i was thinking how lame PP is and actually did a presentation at college bashing it. The tool i've used for that was Prezi.com, the one mentioned by a lot of ppl in this thread. You should give them some love, definetely a great worth a look tool.
- Diego Sana
I got tired of trying to find the perfect presentation technique and ended up developing my own http://mlx.netii.net/templat... not perfect, but it works for me.
- MLx
Daniel & Jemm - thanks for that. I've just installed personalbrain on the Mac and opened some old brains done in the PC (aahh nostalgia). I really missed it as a tool. I've been using freemind, which does have some very good features, but personalbrain is still a better tool for this sort of work. Thanks.
- Alistair Nicholson
Jemm - in some cases I will just generate one or two slides using ppt or similar. By exporting them they become individual objects that I can mix and match - or call on as I need, without having to consider how to jump to them within the powerpoint package. Powerpoint (or keynote) then becomes a graphic slide authoring tool that just generates some components or objects I use in my...
more...
- Alistair Nicholson
I have presented for many years with MindManager. Its great for interactive presentations. Tomorrow I will use it present to a conference of independent financial advisers on the subject of mind mapping and mind mapping software. I humbly suggest they will remember my hour more than the 5 other hours of PowerPoint. This is web version summary. http://twurl.nl/24rzyv
- Andrew Wilcox
Powerpoint is a time sink - whenever I have had to use it I ended up using more time fixing the presentation than focusing on the message. Can't remember which company took powerpoint off the systems and said they measured a productivity increase... or if it is a digital legend... but from my experience I can believe it.
- Iphigenie
"It's a poor workman who blames his tools" -- old proverb
- Karim
Meh. Powerpoint is a tool to put stuff on screen. As long as you're not just reading off it...
- Yuvi
Just convert powerpoint slides into pdf and present pdf to the audience.Although I am not a great fan of PDF or for that matter any powerpoint like software.
- Ashish
ashish: you're not getting it. There's nothing worse to do to an audience than to present a standard powerpoint deck to them. The format is NOT what makes that boring.
- Robert Scoble
Robert: Flash is the answer but it's a pain to learn and expensive to outsource, but that's the answer I think. Besides that, Mindjet MindManager is a fantastic peice of software
- Brandon Hall
You're right, it's not the format, nor is it Powerpoint. It is not using it to in an engaging way.
- Dennis Beatty
Robert,Sorry for misinterpreting your question. This one is a really tricky question.
- Ashish
I often find slides take away from the message - people are reading the slide text instead of looking at and listening to the speaker, and the speaker is looking at the slides instead of at the audience. I wouldnt mind the speaker looking at the screen if he was demonstrating something (or writing, in the old blackboard style) but in a way slides which were supposed to support the presentation end up taking away from it. Too passive?
- Iphigenie
prezi is pretty amazing mark. i also use Free Mind but have never used it for a presentation...
- Morgan
wishing for 2nd like or something to bump this up higher amongst my likes and discussions
- metalerik
I have a talk tomorrow morning at my kids' school about technology in education. I was brainstorming it in Curio and Keynote, but I bought Prezi Pro just cuz it looks so cool. It's a little quirky, a little buggy, and not as flexible as, say Keynote, but it sure is a unique look. Mindmapping + Presentations.
- Leo Laporte
Nothing wrong with Powerpoint, it's just a tool. I do just fine with it and Keynote. Sounds like it's a presenter issue if you're bored
- Bwana ☠
I love mindmanager, but its license is toooo stupidly and insanely expensive!!
- Mohamed Salem Korayem
yeah I love using xmind for organizing talking points but I don't normally use them to present - most audiences don't grok them ime
- mike "glemak" dunn
I'm sorry, trying to learn. I have a 30 slide presentation (+-10) that i present to customers around the world usually in a room of about 10 people. What could Mind Manager do that PPT isn't doing?
- Surprisingly Monstrous
For everyone looking to learn more about using MindManager for presentations, I have written up a number of posts on the Mindjet blog that talks about how to do it, some best practices and sample maps. The most popular post in the series was from PresentationCamp SF, "Become a Presentation Superhero": http://blog.mindjet.com/2009... while other posts covered using images, colors, and fonts within your mind maps. Check'em out or contact me if you have questions!
- Michael Deutch
ah, michael good to see you here - for those who don't know him michael is mindjet’s chief evangelist & one of the hardest working community engagement folks on the net - i use xmind because i test lots of open source tools but have been a customer of mindjet for years & love mindmanager :)
- mike "glemak" dunn
Yeah thanks Michael, I've been wanting to see some examples/how-to's about using MindManager for presentations.
- Justin Hopkins
Actually I spoke too soon. I'm curious to see some video of a person "giving a talk with it" like you said Robert. Do you have any recordings of some of yours of the Buzz Bruggeman talk you mentioned?
- Justin Hopkins
I find using a Mind Map a lot easier for people to follow and sparks a lot more collaboration from the group.
- Jim Lavin
If you hate Powerpoint, Robert & friends, then you have to check out Edward Tufte's essay "The Cognitive Style of Powerpoint: Pitching Out Corrupts Within." It's brilliant. And the cover still cracks me up: http://tr.im/lXjv
- Alan Mairson
Funny thing for me is that I've always made fun of PP style presentations and have been known as someone who really gets groups interacting, etc. (check out this clip of a game I led at Seattle Mindcamp -http://tinyurl.com/qjathj) BUT, just recently, I've discovered that for my type of improvised, interactive, often scattered, creative style --powerpoint is actually a good (much needed!) balance. So I've been upping the KeyNote. MultiModal is the way :)
- Leif Hansen
Robin Good: great comment on MindMeister.com - present.io is a very interesting app to keep track of, if you are doing a lot of online presentations. I use Skype screen share (Mac) for Coaching and presenting ways and methods to use applications.
- Jan Friman
from Nambu
How about having a standard cheaper version of mindmanager. I dont use all the awesome features version 8
- Mohamed Salem Korayem
Jemm and others - I'm back having been in the most boring presentation today that I have experienced in a very long time - powerpoint slides of the most horrible structure, plus given over a video conferencing tool where the presenter didn't read any of the questions in the typing area! Thebrain has a free version. What I've found is that because I use tiddlywiki (also free) to organise...
more...
- Alistair Nicholson
just a quick reaction to the person who suggested video - what can video add if you are there in person?
- Iphigenie
@Joelle a video is a way to engage the audience and let the main messages be reminded. Your role there is to give the right introduction to the video and then open and manage the discussion after it. People will partecipate more to teh discussion. That's my personal experience by the way!
- Michela Cimnaghi /cimny
Robert, I agree & use MindManager for presentations, as well as various project information summaries, trying to stick to a "one sheet" philosophy for reports. One of my pet peeves is presenters who read the bullets on a PPT. Yikes!
- Rick Cogley
Joelle (thanks Michela) another use of video is short interviews or contributions. For example case studies with a manager from the customer explaining their problem, a business analyst explaining their technique around a specific problem, a web designer talking about how they 'imagine' the personality of a site, demonstration of an experimental technique with a patient. It creates...
more...
- Alistair Nicholson
I also meant to draw attention to Lief's comment about multi modal and how sometimes a powerpoint slide can present the underlying structure or main points of the presentation. I still believe there can be a place for dot points - so long as they are not the sole content. I believe there are few that would suggest Steve Jobs' presentations are boring, for example. Always worth a watch and they can be found on youtube. Other exemplars are the top rated talks on TED.com.It gives me something to aim for.
- Alistair Nicholson
FreeMind is very useful and Open Source. Give it a try!
- Nicola Junior Vitto
just got into Amode 4 project mgmt. same company @MindSystems. imports @MindJet.
- Courtney Engle
IMHO, my best tool is a whiteboard, and second place, a notebook with squares to plan a sort of storyboard. When I switch back to analog planning, I started to get my best results back on PowerPoint (I love 2007 version). Cheers,
- Rolando Peralta
Wow, what a great thread! I explored some best practices for presentations and wrote the following posts on the Mindjet blog. They could apply for any type of presentation but they're primarily focused on mind mapping...The first: 10 Steps to Great Presentation Maps -- http://blog.mindjet.com/2009...
- Michael Deutch
Next, How to Make a Great Presentation: Mapping Your Content -- This one applies to using mind maps to 'think through' your presentation content, regardless of what tool you select for the actual presentation: http://blog.mindjet.com/2009...
- Michael Deutch
What’s a Picture Worth? Here's a post about incorporating images into mind map presentations. http://blog.mindjet.com/2009... -- I saw an interesting tweet from Andrew Wilcox earlier today where he suggested placing large images inside 'topic notes'.
- Michael Deutch
Prezi reminds me of microsoft photosynth.
- Ashish
michael: constructive suggestion - you should setup a mindmap group here on ff so these suggestions can be feed in separately and others can participate, they're just going to get lost inside this thread...
- mike "glemak" dunn
Wow what a great discussion. I have never heard of Prezi before and I will have a very imortant presentation to one of MNO next week. I prepared with PP, but now consider to do from scratch via Prezi.com. Thanks guys!
- Jacque
Robert, do you have anything that you can share that you've used Mind manager for? Do you actually use it in presentations or do you use it as a thought organizing tool? Thanks for answering if you have the time!
- Gregg Morris
i was blown away by a preso done in prezi.com. tried it out, the UI takes some getting used to, but w/ patience the zoom in/out approach yields great presos. worth checking out some of the demos. I saw a preso done w/ it that all took place inside the dot of a question mark (that was the reveal at end of preso). cool.
- Adrian Chan
re. TiddlyWiki: should I mention, that there's also a true presentation version?... http://ow.ly/8vMH
- schilke
Or you could emulate Carrot Top and use props from a great big trunk. Problem is you need to be a) really pumped up and b) certifiably nuts.
- bob corrigan
Schilke - thanks for the link to tiddlywiki presentation version. I've bookmarked that and visited the example. With tiddlywiki each 'tiddler' has a specifically adressable URL so that pages can be individually linked from mindmapping software. That way a complete subtopic can be created as a 'deck' but not invoked in the presentation unless we choose to go there. Back to the 'horrible'...
more...
- Alistair Nicholson
A cool MindMapping alternative is XMind.
- Martin Seibert
Phillip I think they are under creative commons, im not sure though.
- ralphsaunders
They should put all the textbooks on Google Books and let people access them all on Kindle for $10 per month and sell the Kindle at $99 with a 2 year contract
- Charbax
I'msure Bezos aleady is in talks with the Text Book Industry
- Jim Lavin
Nah you would need Wacom stylus for the Kindle not multitouch
- Charbax
What abuse? I'm a student and I can tell you the vast majority of our textbooks stay at home.
- Justin Yost
What I was going to say was, it wont be treated like a textbook, its not going to be stuffed in a bag with a load of other stuff all the time.
- ralphsaunders
The content creators never look ahead, they wait until they are losing their lunch.
- Justin Luey
by far more popular than Sony reader and other competitors
- Charbax
Yes but the cost of books on the Kindle are usually a lot less, which makes up for the cost of the Kindle
- Jim Lavin
Have you bought a college textbook lately, I spend minimum $500 a semester for books.
- Justin Yost
phil, a student could easily download a pdf of the textbook over the internet. the DX is a really good opportunity in that sense.
- ralphsaunders
Sam Davyson: Agreed. I still prefer to read a real book. I don't imagine myself curling-up in bed with a Kindle
- Phil Essing
So this is the first comment thread I've seen is functioning as a real time chat room.
- MacNeurotic
The larger kindle is about 2 things: 1)more money for textbook people since this will kill used book sales and 2)killing campus bookstores -- which more and more are owned by Barnes and Noble, an Amazon competitor
- jccalhoun
I'd love to see something that is more accessible for people with disabilities like visual impairments. I liked what the Kindle was doing about the audio until the Author's Guild had to get in the middle.
- Molly Song ;)
MacNeurotic, FriendFeed is a great platform for live events.
- Louis Gray
Agree with Alex there - I do the same on my iPhone
- Roberto Bonini
Or the bookstores off campus that tend to be independent stores.
- Justin Yost
E-ink is 100 times better than LCD for reading a lot of text
- Charbax
Jim - what would you prefer be discussed?
- Louis Gray
This is a good show. Really enjoy watching and listening to smart folks.
- David Damore
Skip the Kindle DX; wait for a full-colour version (or competitor) that supports comic books/graphic novels, at about $199-299, and you have a world-beater.
- Shéa Bennett
Phil, if you go to the right places PDFs are avaliable free :)
- ralphsaunders
@Sam Davyson what major? Engineering here, we have to buy pretty much all of our textbooks which are easily some of the most expensive and fastet changing books
- Justin Yost
@Charbax: Color E-ink will never come... Really?
- David Damore
Sam, there is not. FriendFeed doesn't show a # of logins.
- Louis Gray
@Landor Therein lies the question. :) It is coming, though. Remember Tom Hanks' character in Big? He was WAY ahead of his time. ;)
- Shéa Bennett
char, didn't they say that about a TB HDD?
- ralphsaunders
I buy a book and inside of 2 years the book is out of date.
- Justin Yost
Having textbooks with audio would be good for visually impaired
- Molly Song ;)
Louis, I just get a little tired of comparing everything to Apple devices, there are a lot more devices out there...
- Jim Lavin
taking calls on TWIT is genius! that first call worked perfectly
- Justin Luey
Jim, I mentioned that myself in terms of everybody thinking they know what's coming from them, but it's been discussed for a decade. I brought up Sony's eReader.
- Louis Gray
The Kindle Voice is not that bad... It is listenable...
- Jim Lavin
I had a friend who had to scan in his textbooks to be able to read them, he was that dyslexic.
- Justin Yost
It's better than the Kerswell computer voice :P
- Molly Song ;)
the only way to know how many people are in the FF chat is if they sound off
- guruvan (Rob Nelson)
I agree, I've had 4 different EReaders and the Kindle is the best I've used to date.
- Jim Lavin
This call in for TWIT will raise TWIT to a whole new level!
- earl wallace
That would be nice, the library books tend to be too out of date here (Texas Tech University) and our professors specifically do tests that include material only from the books, same thing and a lot of other schools that I have friends at.
- Justin Yost
It's interesting that such 'old fashioned' technology like a call-in is still a popular and perhaps pivotal feature for an internet show.
- Shéa Bennett
Agree, Shéamus, could be a good feature.
- Louis Gray
I love the call in capability, I think this add a lot to the show.
- Jim Lavin
And now thy gonna start pimping audible... alex is particularly fond of it
- Roberto Bonini
However if you are a liberal arts major you tend to not buy such expesnive books, aka English majors buy books to read, not actual textbookds.
- Justin Yost
I'm in the middle of John Hodgman's Area of My Expertise and it's cool.
- Molly Song ;)
@Justin Luey Leo tried talkshow on Net@Night for awhile, and I loved it. Always thought Leo should integrate it into more shows. Today it's a TWiT/Tech Guy mashup and it's gold.
- MacNeurotic
Good thing I didn't upgrade from Kindle 1 yet. Things will change again
- Francine Hardaway
@Jeremy... seems like Amazon pissed off a lot of Kindle2 owners with the DX release... no upgrade deal, eh?
- .LAG liked that
I regret the Kindle 2 purchase as well, but like Louis said, sometime you get bit being an early adopter, I'll probably get in line for a DX and give my Kindle 2 to my daughter.
- Jim Lavin
Hope this TWiT is a success, I hope he does this more often. :)
- Molly Song ;)
Talkshow sounds much better when it is only one person at a time.,
- Jim Lavin
You dont need to have seen the tv shows to unerstand the film which is the best thing. You just wont understand a few of the jokes, like i didnt when other people were laughing.
- Simon Wicks
Trekkers go to Nepal... Trekkies love Star Trek
- Phil Essing
I couldn't believe how they ████████ when the ████████ . And then when ████████ was on the ████████ and ████████ goes over to the ████████ ?!? ███████ing amazing.
- Ken Sheppardson
Interesting that despite rave reviews, ST still grossed about $10m less than the mostly-panned Wolverine (which I enjoyed). Wolverine made $27m this weekend, too. You'd think the fanbases would be fairly equal.
- Shéa Bennett
Leo, the problem with Friendfeed is the lack of mobile apps. It would be great to use Friendfeed on the go but I can't use it besides right in front of the laptop.
- Sweyn Venderbush
colin, yes... their back end is amazing
- Chris Heath
I know of it but Lag and Roberto but they aren't native app and they don't have notifications and they are limited by the worst phone browsers. I would like a windows mobile app as there are many iphone apps already. Nambu looks very nice.
- Sweyn Venderbush
Is it Terraccota that squarespace uses? It's either that or Hadoop that's the super sexy library for java and spreading work across a ton of computers *needs to learn it*
- Patrick Sullivan
They should take this survey in Canada I bet this l% is lower
- Greg
Why isn't the comment link at the bottom of the thread instead of the top? They should switch the direction of comments if they continue to try and emulate Twitter...
- Tim Moore
@Sweyn: good points... FF is just dying for some developer to come along write an iPhone app for it...or Windows mobile, if you must. ;)
- .LAG liked that
Phone numbers will be like domain names in 3-5 years. You'll buy one, take it everywhere (cell/home/etc), and keep it for life (assuming you make renewal payments).
- Shéa Bennett
@LAG the difference is that the apps for WM are so much more expensive than iPhone apps. The IM+ app is $40 as apposed to $6 or less on the iPhone. I would pay $40 for a good FF WM app.
- Sweyn Venderbush
I just dig how I don't have a Kindle, haven't seen Star Trek and don't have Google Voice. Quite the week for me to join...
- Louis Gray
I would use Google Voice, but I moved to a different state after I got it, so the old area code # doesn't do me a lot of good now.
- Tony Miller
seeqpod seems to be down now too. Dead or not-dead?
- Doug Slater
Thanks Louis. I actually don't see much of it on FF. As long as a user writes a preamble to give the song context it has value. Just a link is meaningless as would be a TinyURL without an introduction.
- Gregg Scott
Can I play the semi-completed Duke Nukem on my Kindle DX while dressed as a Vulcan and chatting to my 'girlfriend' on Google Voice? No? I thought this was tech?
- Shéa Bennett
I would argue this value is lessened in the world of mobile computing. But I won't slam the sponsor.
- Louis Gray
Alex looking at your www.TWiPlog.com site and the headings aren't centered. Is it hard to realign those design elments?
- Gregg Scott
@louis eventually they'll launch "Go To My Cell Phone"
- Tim Moore
But you shouldn't need it if you have a laptop.
- Louis Gray
I've always suspected MS's paperclip 'helper' in Office was responsible for the boon in serial killers in the 1990s. "I see you're writing a ransom note..."
- Shéa Bennett
You don't--it's gone, baby. Cut and paste or add to bookmarks...
- Gregg Scott
bearable for now, but yeah still breathing fire. :p
- Josh Haley
@Louis Gray, you should start your own podcast
- Matthew
Louis should do a 19 minute podcast.
- Daniel Rowley
1st gen iPhones... Turn off Location services!
- Tommy Bevins
i've had days where i forgot to pause the ipod on my iphone when i unplugged the jack ... it didn't put audio out on the speaker, but kept running the songs and it ran down the battery by the early afternoon...
- Chris Heath
No Motorola had the first phone that worked with iTunes called the Rocker
- Jim Lavin
That's was hilarious, Daniel Rowley!
- Gregg Scott
3G I never use. WiFi always on. I browse internet about 20 minutes a day, I do about 15 minutes of talking a day, send about 30 sms a day. Maybe an hour of ipod a day. Lasts me 2-3 days on one charge.
- Jackson Pollock
zephyrlily i disagree... i like having an all-in-one device
- Chris Heath
@leolaporte It's really not that long it didn't really start till 3:40
- D Lets
The chat on friendfeed will eventually be filtered by "likes" when they add likes for comments and provide filters in real-time to only show liked commentors
- Charbax
Thank you for an interesting show today.
- Ed Boutros
awesome show today Leo! For being fairly last minute i think it turned out great.
- Chris Heath
Dunno if anybody's reading these after the fact, but something at least tech-related in the Star Trek discussion...slight spoiler contained...Cryptic is working on an ST MMO, set about 50 years after Voyager I believe. Anyway, they have been updating their news feed once or twice a week with a story called "The Path to 2409," (http://www.startrekonline.com/fiction) which follows the...
more...
- David E. Mullins
Just listened via podcast. Love the TalkShoe integration, Leo!
- casey wright
Rob, it disrespects the office of the President of the United States. I don't care how goofy George W. Bush was, or if any of the "rumors" were true. Stone depicts the rumors as though they actually were true and completely diminishes the respect of the office of the President of the United States. I don't care who it is - the President should never be depicted in the way Stone did George W. Bush - he made a foolery of him. (Note that I voted for Obama)
- Jesse Stay
Same here. I thought it was a horrible movie, but not sure it was disrespectful or who it would be disrespectful to.
- Jeremy Franklin
The presidency of George W. Bush was far more disrepectful to the office than anything else. Oliver Stone is only guilty of making some crappy movies.
- Rob Michael (Atmos Trio)
Jeremy it made a fool of the President, especially where it came out while that President was in office. I think that's disrespectful. Rob I don't care if you have that opinion. I think he made mistakes as well. It's another to completely make fun of him based on complete rumors that make him look like a fool. Stone had a political agenda with this and it was disrespectful to the office of any President that leads this nation. I completely lost respect for Stone with this one.
- Jesse Stay
Jesse, I do have that opinion, as such there is no reason you should care about it. But to say Oliver Stones little movie made a fool of George Bush is give Stone far to much credit. George Bush would look like a fool with or without the movie. re: Oliver Stone--I think we agree.
- Rob Michael (Atmos Trio)
I wouldn't go too far on the disrespectful suggestion, but the movie seemed cheap and boring.
- Louis Gray
Luke, I saw it - didn't see any reviews telling me not to watch it though. :-P
- Jesse Stay
definitely looks like it's going to be a great camera. I'm just disappointed for the degraded 1080 @ 20fps. Perhaps the http://chdk.wikia.com/wiki... forum guys will figure something out soon!
- Elijah Nicolas
Yeah. That 20fps is not so great. The Gizmodo video sort of demonstrated it, but it is a start. My 40D is looking really old now.
- Jeremy Franklin
Wow pretty amazing, cameras = PCs these days in terms of refresh rate on tech. Interested to see what the mid-line refresh brings as well
- Bill Pennington
from twhirl
Also I keep wondering what this signals for camcorders in general, seems like a camcorder form factor + 5D2 tech would just kick butt. Oh and give me manual control please!
- Bill Pennington
from twhirl
The Canon. I'd have so much more fun with a zippy camera than a Big Mac.
- Mike Neumann
Probably the computer. I'm happy with the first gen 5D I'm about to buy and as awesome as the camera is, the MBP doesn't need another $5K in lenses.
- Derrick
Neither, you need at least twice that for glass & equipment to get the "rig" you should want for a Canon MKII - sorry, 3K isn't enough for that toy; and spending 3K on disposable technology (Mac equipment) isn't a wise investment.
- Enrique Gutierrez
Neither, I'd use it to buy food for a year.
- Will Higgins™
Considering I can make quicker cash with my Photography work I would say the Canon 5D MKII and then I would buy the Apple 17 inch MacBook Pro with some of my earnings!
- Patrick Greer
5D Mark II. And then throw the remaining towards some new glass.
- Andy Hannon
2k into the bank, 1k for computer upgrades and other stuff.
- Grant Bierman
5D Mk II everytime ... unless I don't have a Mac at that particular time ...
- Stephen Taylor
I've already got the 15" unibody so I'd go for the 5Dmkii
- Sparky, lurking
If I didn't have a laptop, then I would get the 17" MBP. If I already had a lappy, then get the camera...
- William Sellers
Well, I recently moved from a 30D to a 5DMII because it was a huge upgrade for my "system". With a 2 year old Macbook Pro still serving me well for my needs, it's an easy decision. Additionally, I can't see using a 17" notebook over a 15 for portability sake, I'd just as well get an iMac and keep using my Macbook Pro for mobile use.
- Ryan
Aren't you in Vegas? I think there are a few other options in front of you..
- LA Snark
MacBookPro 17-inch. I am a Nikon guy. So, Canon 5D MKII if I had $7K for all the lenses, too.
- Chintan Zaveri
The camera! I already have the 15" MBpro. 17" is just too big.
- Sherry Main
My 1 yr-old MacBook doesn't thrill me; it sits on the desk unused, and I just couldn't pay more than $200 for a camera, unless I was dreadfully rich.
- MiniMage
5DMKII - sell some images on istockphoto, and then buy an MSI Wind and install OSX. It is faster than my 15" MBP!
- Darren Mak
Neither. Maybe 3 coins :). I have a Macbook Pro which I don't use often comparing to my PC. I am not into the consumer electronic stuff, only got a digital cam last year :).
- dexin
Canon. Can't believe Apple ditched the matte screen on the 17" - FCP users and photographers don't want a glossy screen - the idea of the 17" is the ability to use it out in the field for photo/video editing.
- Peter Clayton
So limiting, Robert! If I could pick whatever I wanted, I'd get one of those sweet Asus multi-touch netbooks coming out - and then use the rest to buy Yahoo! stock. :P
- Shawn Farner
MB 13'' and the external cinema display. MBP17 is huge to carry out
- Jean-Charles VERDIE
Well part of it would have to go towards fixing my car, http://preview.tinyurl.com/9dz2kz. Then the rest would go towards buying a second camera body to be my main and at least one lens if not two. Then the rest would go towards bills.
- Mathew™ aka Youngblood
Robert: Apple products plus awesome SLR cameras...response is a given :)
- Mo Kargas
the camera is nice - especially all the HD video. friend of mine in the movie post-production business reckons this sort of Camera will KILL the movie camera business in a few years time. especially at the low-budget movie (<$30 million) of the movie business. RED already making big inroads. much cheaper than an ARRI.
- Scot Mcphee
The MK II as I already have the MBP 17 inch...older but it works.
- Semipro
Canon 5D is the winner for me. Great digital photography is the gift that keeps on giving.... ;-)
- John Uppendahl
Well.... Given that I have 4 PC desktops, 2 PC laptops, and 1 iMac, all of which are operational and regularly used, AND that I suck at photography, I'm going for what's behind door #3: A whopping big HDTV -- which will get hooked up to the living room PC, of course. ;-)
- Joanmarie
I'd go the MacBook - but I'd also load it up with the full 8gb of RAM I see as an option (and not many people mentioning). Sadly, a nice 17" MBP setup it just over NZ$10k :(
- Mark Derricutt
MacBook Pro. Hands down. I'm a computer engineer, not a photographer.
- Logan Leger
well since I've already got a Canon 5D Mark II... hmmmm...
- Thomas Hawk
I'll buy neither. What I would rather do is try to buy one share of BRK-B if it gets to that price. :)
- imabonehead
The 17" Mac Book Pro, I already have a 5D MkII ;-)
- Jeff P. Henderson
I'd buy the camera, I have always loved photography and wanted to learn.
- R. Ferguson
I would take the cash and build an ultimate gaming PC !!! :D
- ralphsaunders
When you buy an inexpensive camera, you really sacrifice quality, and that lack of quality endures (you want to keep your photos forever, right?). When you buy an inexpensive computer, that's not the case (I don't need a unibody case :)
- David Andrzejewski
Ouch, this one hurts. I suppose I can't opt for a Nikon equivalent to the Canon? If this is the choice, I'd opt for the MacBook Pro. But if I had 3K, I'd buy myself the Nikon D300
- Karoli
The Canon. A 17" laptop is too big unless you plan to use it as a desktop.
- Hartley Spurlock
Mac for sure.I have a first generation Macbook and I need a new one. Kaya Singer
- Kaya
I'd pay off my credit card. For all that stuff I, like, already bought.
- Jandy
I would save it until I had between $8-15K for a CO2 laser cutting machine. I like my macs small, and while full frame sounds nice, I know I'm not nearly hungry enough to go pro in photography, so 40D suits me just fine.
- Jason Wehmhoener
That's a tough one because I have been wanting to get my first Mac (have to start somewhere, right?!) but am a hard core Canon fan/user. So if push came to shove, I would have to go with the Canon.
- Laura Zickus
That would be either a trip to another continent or a Fujitsu LifeBook P1630, but it would not be either of the options in the question. I seriously cannot understand $3k for a camera, unless you're going to make that money back in a month or two WITH said camera.
- MiniMage
Neither, I would invest in the stock market.
- DGentry
I'd prefer a D300, however no matter what brand I'd take the camera in a second over the MBP. Save up another $500 and get a Windows Notebook as well.
- Kenton
The Canon 5D MKII for sure. Cameras bring me a lot more joy than flashy computers. Though a 17-inch MacBookPro would be nice to edit those new photos on too ;-)
- Ian Holton
from twhirl
Probably the Mac. I would never carry around a DSLR. Too big.
- Rodfather
Neither. The new full frame format with HD Movies (wow! Woopee *rolls eyes*) is crap - only 3.9 FPS?! Who are they kidding?!
- Adam
Seeing my Macbook Pro is 5 months old. I would buy neither...but I would buy a MacPro with more RAM.
- Ryan
I take a cruise with Lindsay - big ass stateroom.
- iTad
Neither, I'd get a Canon Rebel XTi and build a new gaming PC, anything left over would go toward the new home NOC
- xero
If I had the $3,000, Canon 5D and a larger donation here http://tinyurl.com/daniela Pros: it's more portable, takes better pictures, and connects to my more compact 15" Macbook Pro. Of course, it doesn't work with my Nikon lenses, so...
- Lee Dale
Canon 5D MKII only cause I have a Macbook Pro. If I didnt it would be the Macbook.
- Bob Maltais
Nah. Patrick's college fund. 5D Mark 2 or the Macbook isn't all that exciting.
- Joshua Hayworth
cannon.I kill computers, so not worth spending 3 grand on one. Plus I have a (beat up) macbook pro already.
- InPerpetualMotion(Gina k)
the new MBP, without a doubt ... my current ones needs a refresh (I'm accepting donations btw) ;-)
- Jeffrey Canton
Since I'll be getting the new MBP anyway, I'll take the 5D. BTW, is anyone keeping score?
- Brad Kligerman
Blatant self-promotion, but if Robert used re-searchr.com it would keep score for us... I wrote it to suck down inline multiple choice selections so no ne would even have to leave ff
- James Ostheimer
Robert, you're asking the question that's been pondering in my mind from some time (albeit it used to be with the 15" and Cinema display v. 5D/a900/D700 -cannot make my mind-). I want to be able to make a decision before March. I think I'll be going for the Mac, since I might relocate in part of the world where carrying an expensive piece of art around my neck might be more dangerous than here, in JPN.
- Paul Papadimitriou
I'd go for a MBP, mine needs an upgrade and I just bought a 50D not long ago which is just fine for me.
- Andrew Trinh
from Nambu
More lenses. My camera is fine, and this Thinkpad is a good 'un.
- Paula W
Seems like Apple design the 17-inch MacBookPro just can use in 3years.the battery can only use in 1000 times,1time per 1day,3years.But Canon 5D can take more beatuful pics for me,and can stand by me more than 3years.if i really have 3000dollers,i real do this.kick off 17-inch MacbookPro.
- jedorstar
from twhirl
Wow, I came late to this convo. Well, for what it's worth at this point, I'd probably get the lappytop, sell my old MBP and then use THAT money to buy a cheaper camera. :D
- Jonathan Hardesty
Macbook I think. I have a 40D but REALLY want the 5D. Which do you think you could get your hands on first?
- Andrew Smith
The $2800 MBP becomes a lot more compelling when converted to 2080€.
- Brad Kligerman
I'm a Nikon guy but the 5D MKII has me seriously considering a switch
- Bryan Thatcher
from twhirl
As I don't like Macs and into my photography the choice out of the two is simple. :-) But I've rather spend the money on say the Nikon D3 and if you gave me an extra grand or 2 then I'd go for the Nikon D3X. ;-)
- Kol Tregaskes
from twhirl
Without though, the Canon 5D MKII. First up, you don't want to trust another "first gen" Apple product. And with the unimpressive lineup yesterday, maybe the 15" laptops are coming out real soon now, with similar features, and all quirks ironed out
- Colin Charles
from twhirl
17-inch macbookPro is way too big. so I would go for the camera. Problem is I would need to learn how to use it then...
- Davide D'Incau
If you have good lenses to take advantage of the MKII (extra $3000 needed here), go for the camera!
- Joao Pedro
I would buy a Apple 17-inch macbook of course.! I don't have an apple and I would really like one. I have a camera thats good enough for me.
- @LarsenTweet
nor this neither that! i will send money to help people in Gaza or at least I'll send 1000 $.
- خیزران
I would buy the Mac, get a cheaper camera with the money I have left, and edit and enhance my videos using my Mac.
- Shevonne
I'd go the Mac route. I'm looking to buy one anyway and I've already got a camera. Might not be as fancy as the Canon do-dad, but I'll manage.
- James Ferguson
Wow 202 comments! How did I miss this thread? :)
- AJ Batac
The 17" MBP as my current 12" PB is on it's last legs and needs replacing - need rather than want for me
- Sally Church
The Canon... even though I already have a 5D and actually need a new laptop
- Shawn Duffy
from twhirl
The MacBookPro, I have a Canon 30d but I do not have a MacBook
- Bob Gannon
I wouldn't want a 17'' monster of a MacBookPro and therefore would go for the Canon 5D MKII
- Donald Townsend
5D, the 17-inch MacBook Pro is very big. Harder to find bags for it and its less portable.
- seanb
bank it, put in matress, done need either of those things, we need smarter devices that tell us the likelyhood of use-longevitiy in them, "i'm a camera you bought last year, you used me 9 times, i collect dust, owner- please resist replacing me unless you really really really need to, and the data suggests you don't.."
- Dan Rockwell
from twhirl
Not enough to buy what I want with the Canon, and I wouldn't be caught dead spending $3000 on a laptop. What a waste!
- Paul Puri
Neither. A $3000 laptop is not worth it just because of its branding.
- Spencer
ohh.. I can't choose. I want both of them... But if i choose, first canon, second mac... İ have canon 40 d and 15'' mac book pro. And i don't like mac's new screen. It's like mirror...
- devletsah
Spencer: as a recent PC to Mac switcher, it's more than brand. Much more.
- Ryan
I'd buy a netbook for the other three members of my family and put the remaining $2000 toward bills or savings. :)
- Steve Lowe
Agree with Aaron, love my 13" Macbook and really want the 5D MKII
- Kyle
Is this thing still going? I can't remember if I replied to this yet, but I say it depends on what will benefit you the most. Robert, you are a photo-maniac. I know that you have a few cameras laying around the house, but I don't know how many Macs you have. You have to remember that a 17" laptop sounds great on paper, but I know that you do a lot of traveling as well, so it might now suite your means. Then again, I would never keep $3,000 dollars in my pocket ;)
- Michael Forian
of course the mac - doesn´t matter what the second option is...
- Dieter Schwarz
I would buy the Canon 5D MKII but being a Nikonian I would end up buying the MacBook Pro and feel no remorse :)
- Carlos Lorenzo
MacBook Pro. I need a laptop really bad.
- Nick Humphries
The camera. 17-inch laptops are fricking ridiculous.
- Andru Edwards
Impressive amount of comments here, this has to be the highest ever now right?
- Joe Dawson
I'm sorry, can you repeat the question: did you say a "camera", a "computer" or a "shark with laser beams"?
- Micah
save the money for tougher times. as much as I'd like the Canon, it's going to be just an expensive toy for me. and my three year old Inspiron works just fine for the most things I do on it.
- Franci Penov
from twhirl
5Dm2 because I already have the new MBP 15" 2.8Ghz. Mostly b/c the cam is more revolutionary than the 17", even though the 17" battery life is enticing.
- ɯɥøq sɐɯoɥʇ
Wow, 250 comments - OMG ...FF is really growing ...YEAH !!!
- Susan Beebe
Yeah, this week has produced several >100 comment threads in my feed.
- xero
Not the 5D, but some body+the best lenses, that actually lasts longer. Laptops are out of date in months and often die within 18, cameras and lenses last a lot longer
- Iphigenie
I would buy a Apple 17-inch MacBookPro, only cause I already have a SLR, so I dont need the Canon 5D MKII.
- Colide81 (James)
I would not spend it, id rather invest 3000 dollars with 10 shares of google
- Kyle Weller
then just buy lenses - you probably already have a computer that can do everything you need
- Iphigenie
Exxon-Mobile. Oh wait, what was the question again?
- Erik S
Neither- new hardware for the pending Win7 beta drop. :)
- Randy Holloway
from twhirl
@Ryan I am a Mac user, have been for a while. It's just my opinion, but $2800 for a piece of hardware in which you can the same or better specs on a PC, is quite a bit of branding.
- Spencer
Using the MacBook Pro 17 inch now (love it!)- and I am quite happy with my Canon Powershot G9, so I'll just take the cash and pay down some of my debt--thanks!
- Kelly W.
Canon 5D MKII then buy the 15" MacBook Pro later.
- John Wang
I would buy a new fast lens for my old 5D (around $1000) and save the rest.
- Alexander Arsky
Nikon E90 *and* a 15" Macbook. :) I bend rules.
- Daniel Miessler
Canon 5d MKII, i'm not a mac person so that was easy.
- Squid
I've been back and forth on this since the 17" was announced. I am very likely to upgrade to the 5DMKII this year. But I want a more powerful laptop to work on the huge files it creates. Chicken? Egg? Confused.
- Jeremy Brooks
Canon 5D MKII for sure. MBP 15 is still chugging along after 2 years. And the 5D is still doing great after 1 year, but I would really like the new 5D.
- Johnny Sewell
The job requires him to work unnoticed, even in plain view, so Jon Favreau settles into a wooden chair at a busy Starbucks in the center of Penn Quarter. Deadline looms, and he needs to write at least half a page by the end of the day. As the espresso machines whir, Favreau opens his laptop, calls...
- Jeremy Franklin
The job requires him to work unnoticed, even in plain view, so Jon Favreau settles into a wooden chair at a busy Starbucks in the center of Penn Quarter. Deadline looms, and he needs to write at least half a page by the end of the day. As the espresso machines whir, Favreau opens his laptop, calls...
- Jeremy Franklin
I'm with @Jesse... maybe I don't log into Facebook enough but that just seems crazy.
- Paulo Elias
from twhirl
Now, one thing that would be nice would be if I could track only certain friends via RSS, like I can on FriendFeed. I can track all via RSS on FB, but not specific friends that I'm aware of.
- Jesse Stay
from twhirl
I think there is a movement to be aware of a friend's status because people are publishing their emotions.
- Jeremy Franklin
Jeremy, I don't think it's appropriate to expect anyone to read all of your status updates. I have almost 800 friends, I know many with 1-3,000 friends or more, all people we know. There's no way you could track all of them.
- Jesse Stay
from twhirl
My addiction to iPhone and FriendFeed has definitely made me less productive and less able to appreciate what's in front of me at the moment. I lost my iPhone and found myself twitching today -- I'm not sure I'll get another one. I stopped using a Blackberry for the same reason.
Brandon: that has an even better keyboard. I think I'll stay with Nokia devices that have regular phone keyboards that are hard to text into.
- Robert Scoble
I don't do the smart phone thing for the reason you mentioned Robert, but FriendFeed really destroyed my ability to focus on anything for more than 30 seconds. I've been ignoring FriendFeed for larger and larger chunks of time and find myself not missing it at all after about a week.
- Mark Trapp
Brian - Had to rework my lists a couple of times but readily admit I spend a too much time here. On the other hand, a lot of it has been productive in a lot of ways.
- Charlie Anzman
Agree. I left FF for about two weeks, and when I returned, something felt different. I spend a lot of time here but, as Mark said, I find myself not missing it as earlier.
- Mladen Srdić
Mladen and Brian and Mark: is it because there's less and less tech news in between cute videos and pictures and funny news stories?
- Robert Scoble
"with Nokia devices that have regular phone keyboards that are hard to text into" -- thanks Robert, I will inform my colleagues that ITU keyboard has this kind of reputation :)
- A. T.
Christopher - I get concerned when I hear comments like that. It takes 'a little' time but the controls are here to see and respond to what you like. Just create your own channels. Still one of the best networking and discovery games in town.
- Charlie Anzman
Christopher: I've noticed this behavior about early adopters. It happens in every online community I've been a part of since the mid 1980s (yes, that's how long I've been doing online community stuff). I thought FriendFeed would be different because you could join rooms that have smaller groups of people in them and also make a list of only your closest friends and avoid the noise. Why aren't these working for you?
- Robert Scoble
Robert, maybe: I still make sure to go through Google reader just as regularly as I always have, and I feel informed. With FriendFeed, I'm reading things I already read in reader or saw on TV. The only things it keeps me informed on is specific people, and those updates, for most people, are few and far between. You said Google reader makes you smarter: I think that's the same thing. With GReader, I can spend an hour or less, get informed about the topics that interest me, and actually have an end point.
- Mark Trapp
It isn't the devices we use, it is us. That said, I would rather have the functionality and the negative side effects than another thing take its place and not have the functionality.
- David A. Levine
David: I don't agree with that. An iPhone is akin to living above a bar for an alcoholic. Nokia's web browsers are a LOT harder to use so I don't even attempt to use them, most of the time, where when I have an iPhone in my hands it's hard to get me to do anything else.
- Robert Scoble
I don't mean to be rude, but shouldn't we exhibit self control at some point. I love the tech news, discussions, and Twitter, but I can focus on other things when needed.
- Jeremy Franklin
I haven't really used FF and don't miss it. Twitter -- now there's another story. I got an iPhone so that I could Twitter any time/place/thing (to be fair, my PDA died 2 weeks before and I missed an important meeting as a result). I paid for Twittelator instead of using the free apps. On my desktop I have TweetDeck with one Twitter identity and Twhirl (LOVE them both) with the other. Twitter is my number 1 news source and I am finding out a lot more about my world because of the tweeters I follow.
- A.J.
Agree with Mark again. My main news sources are Google reader and rss crunchers, like Feedheads and Feedly (i don't use it anymore, but I'll give it another shot). I once started a thread for sharing via Google reader and got a fine response of about 20 people. Interesting way to get some interesting content, beside tech news.
- Mladen Srdić
There's some stupid stuff on FF that I could do with out, and then there's the issue that some people rather post tech stuff to rooms rather then their main feed.
- Colide81 (James)
It's all about self discipline. Switch it off when it's too distracting. If needed turn off wifi.
- Peter van Teeseling
from twhirl
@pvantees the problem is that addiction overrides discipline.
- ·[▪_▪]·
My girlfriend pointed out that I wasn't able to watch a movie or tv show with her without thumbing through posts on Google Reader for the iPhone at the same time. I had to lose that habit, lest I succumb to a meta-relationship to go along with all my meta-interactions online.
- Shay Frendt
Sounds like a new group of 'recognized disorders' for the Psych community ... luckily, there's now help thanks to passed legislation (that was attached to the bailout bill??!!) http://newsblogs.chicagotribune.com/triage...
- Charlie Anzman
I got my FF addiction under control but I think I've lost my grip again. I have to get it together again. It's causing a general lack of ability to concentrate, I just want to check for something new all the time.
- xero
I've started microblogging more when I bought iPhone 3G. If thats more productive or not I don't know, but its fun. I love my iPhone!
- Svartling
There is just the need to know how to control yourself... if you know how to control yourself there will be no addiction...
- Edoardo Piccolotto
But isn't the new generation of mobile devices, micro sharing services and tools opening up a whole new form of organic communications enablement that has the potential to change everything. What if the mobile device is our communications hub/router/data store, freeing us from our desks & enabling a wider group of people to engage like never before -- Cheers, Christopher :)
- Christopher
Brien - Watching the river is a pleasure. Productivity is another kind of activity. Do pleasure and productivity mix? Fun and work?
- Jimmy Walker
Being connected is a *good* thing. However, it takes discipline. If you can't control when you use it and when you don't, it's probably best not to have an iPhone. I hope I can teach my kids this - it's a valuable skill.
- Jesse Stay
I don't surf the net that much on my BB Curve since I have my laptop in front of me most of the day. If I was mobile like you are, then I'd definitely be using my phone to access http://FFtogo.com a bunch! You're in a tough situation...I'd probably cave in and buy a replacement within 3 days! ha, ha! I was highly temped to buy the iPhone just because of your love for it, as well as numerous other buddies of mine who swear by it. However, I am a cautious buyer of new technology, and opted to go with BB
- Susan Beebe
People that don't have an iPhone just don't realize how fully functional the mobile version of Safari is. Unless the site is Flash based or the detect it's a mobile phone browser (I'd rather they didn't do that for the iPhone), it looks and functions identical to the desktop web experience. Even crazy script AJAX-y stuff.
- Paul Reynolds
i am addicted to my blackberry. it never leaves my side.
- Krista K
That's because you are supposed to read them. Not look at superficial headlines. -
- Todd Hoff
I usually find out about news stories on Twitter long before I see it on the news or read it in the paper.
- Mike Hussein Cohen
Todd: I didn't know that! :-) I am reading Time who has a cover feature about Rick Warren, a guy I interviewed back in January. The thing is Time can't go interactive the way you all do.
- Robert Scoble
I think it's because with Twitter and Friendfeed there's a much smaller gap between you and the people "behind" the data. They're actually real people out there. Interactivity is a part of that. Sure, there are real journalists behind the magazine articles, and they're interesting too, but I think a lot of the time what we really want is to feel connected and in touch/
- Nathan Rein
It's just that I feel like I'm in a losing battle backing the side of reflection. When I look at Time it's full of interesting stuff (stretching, solar power, anthrax, evangelicals, etc). Immediate interaction is so powerfully rewarding (dopamine) it can shout down less immediate pleasures. I wrote about this about a billion years ago in The Internet is a Denial of Service Attack on Your Brain (http://tinyurl.com/npzo9). It has only become worse since.
- Todd Hoff
Well, don't you control what you look at in Twitter or FriendFeed? If there was a news site where you got customized news by subscribing to individual authors, it would be a seriously interesting comparison.
- Rishabh Mishra (p248)
@Bob Blunk: Print news is anything but dead. It is alive, kicking and in places such as India, Brazil (+12% in the last year) and other developing countries (http://tinyurl.com/6dr4tb). Bear in mind that these are countries where the use of mobile phones is growing far faster than in the developed world so it's not simply a lack of tech that is pushing people to print. Incidentally, I read that in a hard copy version of the Economist, while sat on the loo (still not somewhere I prefer to take electronics).
- mattpovey
What will happen to "Front porch" society and the newspaper? Or the Barber shop and the newspaper? I long for the "flying roll" fired from a speeding Western Flyer and opening the lid of the magic milk box to find a sweating glass gallon at 6am. ;)
- Melanie Reed
people want content via the distribution method that works best for them - not what works best for the content providers. newspapers and magazines are an endangered species in America as people choose newspaper and magazines less and less. This trend will continue as computer screens achieve higher-resolution and digital content distribution networks mature. Can't say it's a bad thing - more immediate, personalized delivery + wouldn't hurt to save a few trees along the way.
- Morgan
With the fresh and local movement taking off I'm guessing we'll see solar milk delivery trucks making the rounds again any month now. The news paper delivery will only happen in once yearly old town reenactments :-)
- Todd Hoff
The way things are going, let's hope there are a few newspapers and magazines left on the stand in a few years. I still enjoy them. Like so many others in media, most are wondering where to find the next revenue stream.
- Charlie Anzman
I find this is always the case. However, magazines are often more entertaining and they don't require wi-fi ;)
- Ryan
TALLAHASSEE -- Herbert Pompey had gone through rehab, stayed sober, held a job, married and started a landscaping business in the two years since he walked out of Taylor Correctional Institution. But what Pompey hadn't done -- and what he assumed a string of felony drug and DUI convictions would...
- Jeremy Franklin