Leo Laporte
I mean really. Isn't the worst pie better than the best cake? Cake is just puffed up flour but pie is a slice of heaven.
You haven't had Red Red cake, then. - XDpaul
nah ... cake beats pie - Deepak Singh
Both are heaven if my mom made it. She's the best cook/baker of all time. Seriously! - ·[▪_▪]·
The cake is a lie. - iTad
It's hard to deny a hawaiian dream cake though - Rodfather
cold cake. oh yes. - Josh Haley
You convinced me. Time for some apple pie for an afternoon snack. - Loren Heiny
No... way... cake beats any pie, easily... except perhaps Pecan Pie, or some chocolate peanut butter pie - Nathan Chase
My response to "pie vs cake" continues to be "prime rib." - R. Francis Smith
+1 Nathan for Pecan Pie. Although I'd argue *Chocolate* Pecan Pie. Yum! Got a pointer to the recipe for the chocolate peanut butter pie in question? :-) - Joanmarie
hair pie! - NoahDavidSimon
No way, I'm cake gal all the way. Frosting is my weakness...and if you factor in that chessecake is still cake, well...hands down cake wins! - Jennifer Van Grove from twhirl
finally, mr. class weighs in. shame on you! - Wilma Stoneflint
A good Red Velvet cake beats any pie! - Michael Thorp
Pie is definitely better than cake. And both are better than cookies. I despise cookies....they're just little fake cakes. - Angel Smith
now cupcakes are totally different than cake, cupcakes rock! - Jeff Woelker from twhirl
when i drove across the country, i ate pie at every available opportunity. it was like a little piece of americana at every stop! - Veronica
this statement is only valid if you don't include cheesecake. Cheesecake is, by definition, the best thing on earth - Erik Jonasson
All cake completely owns all pie. It's true. - Rishabh Mishra (p248)
IMHO: Ice Cream > Cake > Cookie > Cheesecake > Doughnut > Pie > Cupcake > Pudding > Jello - Nathan Chase
cake >>>>> pie - Morgan
chocolate cake > pecan pie > carrot cake > cherry pie > vanilla cake - FFing Enigma
Always prefer cake. But I guess that's why I need supplemental insulin. - Jeff
Definitely agree that it depends on the kind of pie/cake. A well made apple pie beats out pretty much everything & anything. - Robert DeBord
pretty sure tiramisu is considered "cake". so it's Cake FTW - tiramisu was put on this earth as an offering to women as consolation of having to endure childbirth :) - Dana Coffey
Check the Apple Caramel or Bruiseberry at http://www.doorcountypies.com. - marc britten
Depends. Do you believe cheesecake goes into the pie category, or cake? Cheesecake takes other desserts out behind the woodshed. - DGentry
I completely agree with you. Pie. Pie might even be good for you, - Francine Hardaway