Just saw a Bravo commercial for a PR clone for...makeup design! First clothing design, then food, hair and interior design and now competitive makeup? They should really move on to some other artistic areas. Maybe competitive bookbinding? Computer hacking? Dog grooming? Hedge trimming? Mixtapes?
So, what did you think of X winning Project Runway? I won't post any spoilers but I will say that I thought Kenley's collection was hit or miss, Korto's was colorful & vibrant but had a lot of short dresses and Leanne's was the most cohesive as a collection but her theme became predictable.
And I thought the judges were very kind and more flattering than usual. They either liked these collections more than in past seasons or they are mellowing.
- Liz
Hiding eyes, it's only 7:15 in LA, no details please....
- Victor Ryden
I agree with everything you said, Liz. I was happy that Leanne won, though. In the end I liked hers the best and she has been the most consistent throughout the season.
- Shannon Jiménez
I have to say, Korto's full collection seems really great the more I look at it. Leanne's was pretty, but just really repetitive. I'm surprised she won. Kenley getting judged by Tim was such awesome payback.
- rachel
i cannot believe i watched the last episode and totally stopped paying attention before the end.
- Krista K
How can you judge a fashion collection wearing sunglasses, no wonder he picked those boring clothes with no color, that all looked alike!
- Victor Ryden
Except for Chloe's collection, I think we should be able to predict future winners from now on...whoever has the most consistent, original collection with a variety of kinds of pieces. It doesn't matter whether it is wearable or whether anyone would actually buy it. Creative over commercial.
A singular vision with all of the pieces in the collection fitting together, that seems to be more important than having a collection full of highs & lows. What seems repetitive in design to us seems cohesive to the judges.
- Liz
"NYPost.com's Jarett Wieselman got the low-down on the tension between "Project Runway" winner Leanne and her nemesis Kenley. (NYPost.com) "
- Steve Isaacs
from Bookmarklet
I'm thinking Lee Ann as well, but this season it is not as obvious as previous seasons who will win.
- Shannon Jiménez
I'd like Lee Ann to win but am afraid that it might be Kenley. My fiance was showing me their collections (I guess it's online somewhere) and Kenley's did look nice.
- Benjamin Golub
It should have only come down to Lee Ann and Kenley.
- Victor Ryden
soooo.... kenley still hasn't been sent home? theyre "intrigued" by what her show might be like?? she makes ill-fitting garments, uses the same old lady shower curtain fabrics, and has become master of one thing: ironic hipster "quirky" 50's dresses. i have no desire to see her show. bad season
She's stupid for always jumping at the judges with an attitude--the important people in the competition who decide her fate . . . Oh my life was hard...i can't help being defensive because i always had to fight... this isn't easy. really? and totally loved that fabric from last episode!! mmm purple scales
- Krista K
She's got a bad attitude. I can't stand listening to her. "It's not supposed to be elegant Heidi". And she never takes Tim's advice.
- Benjamin Golub
She mellowed out this week and was even nice to everyone, and had good designs.
- Victor Ryden
I can't believe that Kenley is in the Final 3 and Jerrell was cut (even though the final 6 all showed at Bryant Park). I wasn't a Jerrell fan & I like Korto but her dress was the worst. It sucked though giving them that extra, last minute bridesmaid's dress challenge when they all had work to do on their collections. Like they needed the extra...
I knew this would happen last week when they kept Kenley even after she was such a bitch. But her dresses WERE better than Korto's and Jerrell's. I think they kept Korto because they liked her previous stuff more than Jerrell.
- Trish R
Plus, this way I got two out of three of my first-episode finalist predictions right :) I had Kenley, Korto, and Suede... not too bad, though last season I got all three right!
- Shannon Jiménez
Also, I agree with you, Trish. I think they kept Korto on the based on the strength of her previous designs.
- Shannon Jiménez
Korto's dress was shockingly bad. I couldn't wrap my head around what was going on up top - no shape, at all. That said, everything but the middle of Jerrell's dress was a mess. While I agree that Korto's past work influenced their decision, you also saw nothing new or different from Jerrell on the runway. It was another sparkly, overworked outfit. If I was a judge, I wouldn't be compelled to see any more either. I think there's more of a surprise factor with Korto.
- Heather Cee
Kenley is such a one note designer. yawnfest
- Theda
I was surprised she stayed, too, especially after she acted so bitchy to Tim, but I guess they wanted another week of drama. From the previews, looks like she's going to do the same thing to Heidi. It's obvious now who the final 3 will be. They start running away from the others towards the end.
- Trish R
She scraped by by the skin of her sarcastic teeth. I think Suede's continued suckage cumulatively got him in the end, not just for last night.
- Steve Isaacs
Kenley should have gone home. Suede's might have been boring, but at least it fit the genre better than hers. And seriously, Tim Gunn needs to bitch slap her.
- rachel
@Victor I had him pegged to win it from episode one, like Kotto this season.
- John Frenette
from twhirl
I can pick Project Runway and Top Chef winners like there's no tomorrow, but I can't pick The Ultimage Fighter finalists to save my life. Oh, and I (obviously) have schizophrenic taste in TV shows...
- John Frenette
from twhirl
Haha, so can I, John...and it sounds like we have the same crazy taste in shows. :)
- Corie
I KNOW it's a drag competition, but really? This dude looks like a big, fat, gay florescent pig. Blayne should have been the one to go. Daniel's dress was at least pretty.
- Steve Isaacs
from Bookmarklet
No arguments from me. I thought Terri's kabuki get-up should have won.
- Heather Cee
I like it because it suits the Southern Belle drag queen and isn't at all Joe's taste. It took on the challenge, which was in a completely different area that he is used to working in (unlike Terri), and gave the client exactly what she wanted. I agree though that Terri's was the most interesting but Joe's client could go right into a drag show.
- Liz
I liked it. Great "package" hiding.
- Fancy Fembot
Kenley was one of my favorites but she is beginning to really annoy me. She's acting out her insecurities by ridiculing others and that just makes her seem so young & childish. Laughing while they were critiquing Joe was just rude even if his outfit was horrible.
Agreed. In the first few weeks she was my fave but now I kinda want to smack her. Also, am I the only one who didn't think Suede's outfit was that bad? The way they were talking about it, I felt like I must be looking at the wrong person or something.
- Shannon Jiménez
Seriously when did she become such a brat? Next week it looks like she's going to go too far. No one messes with the GUNN.
- rachel
I think they are also editing Kinley bad.
- Fancy Fembot
I aree that her outfit wasn't really that bad (don't know why the judges hated it so much), but personality-wise she has always grated on my nerves, so I'm glad she's gone.
- Shannon Jiménez
"Von Furstenberg said she was inspired by the legendary Vogue editor, Diana Vreeland, who once opined that ‘blue jeans are the most beautiful things since the gondola" And she was on Project Runway last week. Great product placement continues!
- Victor Ryden
from Bookmarklet
It's too bad they didn't kick Daniel off last week because I think Kelli could've stayed on the show longer. I mean, she won a challenge & was never in the bottom 2 before. Last week reminded me of last year's prom challenge where they knocked off Kevin too soon.
The judging is so inherently subjective that the designers have to at least understand the general basis for sending someone home. Without that, it seems capricious, unfair & random. This year it seems like everyone going home thinks they didn't deserve it, more so than in other seasons.
- Liz
I agree. Though it was worth him hanging around an extra week just to watch him sulk as the judges kicked his puppy (which was wearing a cocktail dress). I feel like unicorns could vomit glitter and diamonds on that guy and he'd still behave as if Smiths records had been injected into his bloodstream. At least Kelli seemed to have passion.
- Heather Cee
This week's "out": lame-a-licious. In your opinion, what's the bigger crime: blatantly ignoring the parameters of the challenge or poor execution? (Maybe I just find Blaine unbearable.)
Hard to say. He failed massively on both counts. Depends on the situation methinks. He's very very lucky that the other garment was complete fug-a-liciousness.
- Steve Isaacs
So, are people bored with season or what? No comments on this week's episode. Maybe you're going to the Bravo boards which can be a surreal experience at times. The regulars have their own sense of community but a number of them know a lot about fashion.
I was disappointed in the challenge last night. Is this entire season just going to be a rehash of past challenges? Boring. The winning dress was fab though.
Well, I think it is becoming more and more of a challenge for the producers to think of new challenges....there have probably been over 70 different challenges, think of all of the themes they've used (plants, food, candy, prom, trash, denim, jet-setter, haute couture, men's suits, etc.). I think they are bound to repeat versions of old themes. I'd rather they pick a good theme than something so odd-ball that it results in ridiculous clothing (wrestling, anyone?).
- Liz
Yeah, I just want to see some really nice, well-made clothes. OK great, you can make something out of food. How nice for you. Now what about something wearable?
- Corie
I think there's definitely a way to make the challenges more interesting while still making them about real clothes with real fabric. But this week the entire idea seemed like an afterthought-- ok, use this camera for inspiration and since it's night time, create a 'night out on the town' look.
- rachel