it must be part of the API, since fftogo seems to include a time stamp on the comments
- Trent Olson
I'm sure they do store the timestamp, even if it isn't currently displayed.
- Mack D. Male
Yeah, it's in the api, all comments & likes are timestamped
- Glenn Slaven
I think this is a perfect plan. The only issue I might have is that the time information might take-over the conversations. It might just look more cluttered than FF already is.
- Ryne Nelson
concur, very useful to have. Make it a display option. Those who would think it's clutter can turn it off then.
- Alexander Falk
It is in the API (I use them in fftogo). I vote that the timestamp should appear as text when you hover over the "thought bubble" to the left.
- Benjamin Golub
All comments are time-stamped in AlrertThingy and feedalizr
- Stephen B
from Alert Thingy
What about a comment alert?! How do you follow conversations on ff!?
- TommaSorchiotti
Not sure if this will add to the functionality, but should be something they can try out...
- Dennis Goedegebuure
Not sure a comment alert is necessary. Comments bring the post up to the top of the timeline, which makes it available for anyone who is currently paying attention to Friendfeed. (Not sure why anyone would want their attention brought to Friendfeed if it isn't already there, that would be a huge productivity drain).
- Jason Wehmhoener
Please, please remember that the whole world doesn't run on PDT. I don't want to see timestamps in my FF in gReader and have to always try to guess whether the west coast is 17, 16, or 15 hours behind. If you must display timestamps, please put them in GMT. Setting the timestamps on my FF page/in my FF feed to be correct in my local timezone would be even nicer.
- James Polley
yeah ! and a hide fonction for each comment
- Jonathan
we know which came first... but in n argument the comments can edit. that makes time stamping very important so we know when someone made a change
- Noah David Simon
a timeline function in general would be nice, make everything more timeframe friendly
- Ruben Llibre
Show times either in GMT or in my own timezone, and just make it a tooltip for the quote balloon or something. Don't want it to look cluttered.
- Pat Hawks
just make the time relative from each comment, so I know who said what when in perspective. like 5 minutes later Noah David Simon said. <--this opens up
- Noah David Simon
Is i really important to know when every single comment is made? Only the last one would really be useful, could have 'last comment on june 1 at..." right beside the date of the post.
- John Duff
If the timestamp is a tooltip, then it isn't really "in the way." Maybe we can have all the timestamps as tooltips, except the most recent comment will have the timestamp printed out below it, like John said.
- Rishabh Mishra (p248)
I am so tired of entering an empty room and talking to myself for twenty minutes. lol
- Russellreno
A needed feature for sure I agree. I suggested this to the FF feedback room some weeks ago.
- Mike Fruchter
<--- try hover your mouse cursor on that little dialog icon
- topo
Sorry it's not more obvious, but if you hover your mouse over the comment icon you will see the time that the comment was made. Thanks for letting us know that it's hard to find! The feedback is much appreciated.
- Ross Miller
I believe they are timestamped but this data is not yet displayed.... you're right !
- David Berrebi
other than timestamp I also want to be able to like the comments individually =]
- Özgür D. Cyric
This thread shows what happens when nobody reads the comments before theirs
- Rahsheen ™, Coach Rah
Everyone complains about ATT, am I the only one who has no complaints about their coverage. Okay they have a tower down the street from our house.
- Paul Blasman
How can Palm not have any plans for a world GSM version yet?
- Thomas Søndergaard
AT&T realized they've been discovered...no more interference
- Devon Blugh
I think Android will suffer the same problem as Windows Mobile, multiple handset manufacturers and no consistency of user experience between phones.
- Callum
Should I pay for an ETF when the Pre comes to Verizon?
- Jeremy Stanley
Looks like according to the details, the full price only applied to people with the 3G iPhone...
- Jamison Judd
Thomas, I think they do, just no planned release date
- Devon Blugh
I've had positive experiences with both Windows Mobile and Android so far.
- Ross Johnson
Verizon doesn't line wifi on their phones though...
- Joel W Tscherne
But is it really worth it for Apple to create a CDMA iPhone?
- Michael
I was on verizon for 7 years. I loved verizon but i never liked any of their phones. I went to the iphone
- richie hernandez
Michael - how hard is it to make another chip?
- Paul Blasman
Verizon likes too much control on their handsets...
- Ari
verizon would love to have the iphone
- Chris Heath
My concern exactly Joel - I'll bet if the iPhone comes out on Verizon it doesn't have wifi
- Mark Moran
I don't think so Callum. The UI will be pretty consistent, and there are only so many handset styles that work well. WinMo sucks on it's own...
- Christopher A Carr
Paul - They need to write the drivers for the CDMA chipset, too. Put it through FCC testing, etc. I just don't know if it's worth it.
- Michael
Verizon turned down the iPhone. Think they would make a different decision now?
- Scott Thomas
I bought my iPhone in April so I'm stuck with the 3G for awhile. Of course I'll get the next version!
- Joel W Tscherne
You can get refurb 8Gig 3G for $79, that's a tempting upgrade
- Paul Blasman
There's a little uvular fricative in Ahmedinejad...
- Christopher A Carr
MobileMe is too expensive but it's nice when you rebuild a Windows PC and Contacts and Calendar items are synched to Outlook.
- Callum
To be fair to CNN, they're doing a much better job in Iran coverage today. They're still claiming they need us to wait until they properly package their coverage, though.
- Jim Stanger
Callum I agree, Mobileme should come with the iPhone service
- Paul Blasman
you can find mobileme greatly discounted lots of places, i think it's $69 at amazon
- James Tussey
Just use Google Sync instead of MobileMe... works great for me.
- Jason Hansen
I got it for $69 when I bought my new MacBook Pro
- Joel W Tscherne
It's entirely too easy to create fake Twitter accounts pretending to be anywhere in the world, though. How can we verify which Twitter accounts are genuine and which are not?
- Darren Landrum
content... not context on Twitter. Though journalism might not always get context right
- Jeremy Stanley
Apple need thier own digg site to take on AP & REUTERS with user content.
- Michael Mooney
@Ken yep... i guess the point is our first (not necessarily the best or most accurate) place to get breaking news might be twitter. The trending topics are amazing.
- Bill Grant
Can't trust eyewitness accounts. We don't know the real source of the tweets!
- Joel W Tscherne
but the MSM had people reporting from hotel rooms in Bagdhad while we were attacking. They can report under tough circumstances. they have for decades
- Jim Stanger
@Joel, i have to kinda agree, look at the Digg army and the faked front page stories as an example.
- Ryan Scullen
otoh i felt i usually got better overview with a weekly magazine or hour pbs show. up to the minute news isn't exactly highly enlightening, in general
- Preternat (Ken Cadby)
You should not take everything posted on twitter as gospel
- Greg
We only see something from one individual's point of view. Many conspiracy theories are still alive because ONE person claims to have seen something that can't be easily disproved.
- Joel W Tscherne
Leo, does a Re-Tweet count as a second source?
- Gabe
The day CNN or any other "major news outlet" goes on the air to simply report on what they're reading on Twitter is the day they lose any last shred of credibility.
- Ken Sheppardson
@Greg Agreed (on twitter <> gospel) but I think people used to think of the news media as gospel and this is also incorrect. People are better off taking lots of sources and drawing their own conclusions. This was mentioned during the last or second to last twit...
- Bill Grant
The reporters had an early night as they had been up getting their Facebook URLs
- Greg Byrne
Unfortunately old fashioned TV/Radio companies have cut their budgets so much that I'm surprised they do ANY live international reports
- Joel W Tscherne
If you want random 140 character anecdotes from anonymous sources, you've go Twitter. If you want somebody to spend a few hours collecting information, verifying sources, and asking follow-up questions, you've got CNN
- Ken Sheppardson
Bll Grant true but at least you know with networks where to complain.. it twitter u have anonymous postings
- Greg
Tell us when it means, no way. But, giving us information so we can evaluate for ourselves. They have access to lots of experts...ones that don't yell and scream their points.
- Jim Stanger
The BBC picked up the riots pretty quickly. They've been covering the whole event for weeks. Even a breaking news banner for CNN would suffice, regardless of edited footage, surely they have journalists on the street.
- Daniel Rowley
It's not about rush - it's about avoiding the filter
- Chris Saad
Why do we watch car chases? Because we're idiots.
- Ken Sheppardson
If stringers can provide accurate context and journalistic style coverage they would be worth paying leo
- Gabe
There are never any car chases where I live in North Carolina.
- Michael
@Greg I suppose, but I think people just assume journalists are by definition balanced when in reality everyone has a bias.
- Bill Grant
CNN is willing to go hours and hours with talking heads speculating on the newest detail of a missing girl story, but they won't do the same for major world events
- Jim Stanger
Haha Michael only once every 5 years
- kenneth glenn
When people are streaming video, is that mis-information?
- Colin
The newsrooms have been victim of cost cutting for years now. Cheaper to have shows with talking heads. Now, we can't get real news because they don't have people positioned in the hot spots of the world.
- Eric @ CSTechcast.com
cave man instinct. hard to overcome. like tribal prejudice. hmm, going of on tangent now :)
- Preternat (Ken Cadby)
People want to always be the first to tell a story. It's why they can often be wrong!
- Joel W Tscherne
Kenneth - I'm just down the road from you in Chapel Hill, but within spitting distance of the Durham line.
- Michael
@Colin Interesting.... but we all know that even video can be misleading if taken out of context.
- Bill Grant
On the other hand, CNN will spend 6 hours on a fixed shot of some plane sitting on a tarmac speculating about what's going on inside with no real information whatsoever, so... there's a bit of a double standard.
- Ken Sheppardson
Conversation is such a lame buzzword~~~
- Ross Johnson
CNN INternational had great coverage on Twitter and on their network this weekend. The people who decided NOT to switch to the International feed should be fired.
- joebrooks
24/7/365 live as it happens off a ticker kills the story for most viewers
- Michael Mooney
That's the definition of news isn't it, up to the date information.
- Daniel Rowley
I wonder if BBC was covering the events in Iran faster than the US new stations? Is the US new stations only caring about in-the-country-news?
- Ryan Scullen
why does the "twit live desktop 2.0" only do audio now? it used do video a few weeks ago. ....ah it worked as soon as I opened a twit live tab in my browser. Odd
- Ian Murphy
I was in Egypt recently and I was amazed about how different the CNN International stories were from the ones on CNN in the U.S.
- Bill Grant
Daniel: No. Live 24x7 streams of everything happening everywhere all the time isn't "news". "News" is somebody with some experience and judgement filtering out stuff that matters and flagging it for others.
- Ken Sheppardson
News isn't news if it isn't accurate. That just makes it rumor.
- Joel W Tscherne
They could certainly provide a background or base to help evaluate events when they happen. They have access to all sorts of historians and experts that can provide useful info without the speculation of the breaking news moment.
- Jim Stanger
jim stanger bugs me too... angers me. chichen and egg tho... also have to blame the consumer who's buying it.
- Preternat (Ken Cadby)
Ryan: the BBC were covering events way before CNN.
- Daniel Rowley
I also thought @BreakingNews on twitter was doing SUPERB coverage of the events in Iran.
- joebrooks
The other problem with TV news is the need to be commenting on every story. I don't care about pundit Joe Blow's opinion on a topic.
- Joel W Tscherne
Why isn't what I had for lunch "news"? Because it's irrelevant to everyone except me. We know that because "journalists" watch the live feeds and call our attention to what's important.
- Ken Sheppardson
@Richsanchezcnn was doing a better job than CNN recommending ppl to follow
- kenneth glenn
this show has more scoops than ben&jerry's
- vondutch
The role of journalism is to watch the live feeds and tell us what's important, what matters, and what's going to affect our lives.
- Ken Sheppardson
@donlemoncnn kinda angered me. It was along the lines of "hey I gave Iran 10min tonight. What more do you want?"
- Jim Stanger
...and verify. Check sources, make sure not so spread rumor, put things in context...
- Ken Sheppardson
however, he's on right now stepping it up tremendously.
- Jim Stanger
Joel - agreed. i see more straight to the actual events news here in canada. US has too many "news celebrities" that skew information WAY too much with their commentaries.
- Ryan Scullen
Good point Dwight. I love reading the same story in multiple ways in my rss reader.
- Joel W Tscherne
you can do a nearly 24/7/365 live as it happens off a ticker but you have to have content to help viewers understand the ticker news
- Michael Mooney
but Ken, those feeds offer a narrow view of a situation, with very little context. A remote aggregatior can't provide that reliably
- Gabe
What do you mean "but" Gabe? What did I say that you disagree with?
- Ken Sheppardson
I don't mean "feed" as in sit there watching Twitter, I mean everything that's happening everywhere. I was speaking figuratively. Sorry...
- Ken Sheppardson
@micheal that's why i don't understand why ccn cut ccn-text, that was very informative
- vondutch
Ken: I don't think news should just be information that affects our lives. We can understand and have reported information streamed to us without it necessarily having any direct impact upon us.
- Daniel Rowley
Whose picture is that on the video feed for TWIT? That bearded guy does not look like the chief cranky geek.
- Bill Grant
What about Libel or Slander. How can you trust what is being "reported"
- William
@Chris LOL thanks, must be as accurate as a SecondLife/WoW avatar
- Bill Grant
I'm saying that traditional journalism has the advantage of trained professionals on the ground rather than armatures that might not know what questions to ask, video to shoot, and could get themselves hurt if they are not careful
- Gabe
Daniel: I disagree. If it doesn't affect other people, it's not news. It's the journalists job to *explain* HOW it affects our lives.
- Ken Sheppardson
Classifieds (which is what Craigslist is destroying) was the crack cocaine of newspapers. Classifieds aren't related to the news or delivering the audience of news. Classifieds could appear anywhere that enough eyeballs collect. The audience for NEWS is differerent from the audience for classifieds. That so many newspapers depended upon the easy money of classifieds was a convenient drug. Now newspapers are going cold turkey and need to find how to live with the smaller NEWS audience.
- JR Holmes
bill, he used to have a rainbow clown hair avatar
- Chris Heath
@Ken - I disagree. What happens in Iran does not affect my life. That statement is only true the more local the story MIGHT be.
- Ryan Scullen
@Chris Now that sounds more accurate :-)
- Bill Grant
Ryan: I didn't say what's going on in Iran doesn't affect us. It does. The news outlets need to explain why. Tweets in isolation don't do that. Twitter is raw material.
- Ken Sheppardson
Hi. We probably chatted on irc. I like to continue conversation in a less crazy way and not that fast:) - Please 'friend' me or let's follow each other at Twitter @buckybit - Like to connect. Thanks, Twit Army:)
- Alex 'BuckyBit' Covic
it would be nice if the major news programs at least had a ticker at the bottom. Wish they spent more on their research, correspondents and less on their gee wiz gimmicks.
- Kim Landwehr
Ken: how does it affect your day to day life unless you have family or travel plans to the area? My point is your statement is true for local stories, but not necessarily for international stories.
- Ryan Scullen
Journalism and news aren't just a matter of narrating what you're watching. You need to have context and explanation.
- Ken Sheppardson
@Ryan This Earth is getting smaller, 100 years ago I bet someone could say something happening a state over doesn't affect him/her.
- Bill Grant
Ryan, I don't agree at all. That's like saying what happened in Afghanistan in 2000 didn't effect us. This is Iran, a country our leaders love trying to make the next bad guy. What happens there will effect all of us.
- Jim Stanger
Nigel Planer did an episode of Carpool which was a good watch
- Iain
Does Friendfeed have other "conversations"? Like for the Iran Election?
- Randy Willard
Libel/Slander: If you mess up as a journalist, like make stuff up, then you don't work again in the business. You'll then have to become a blogger or find another industry.
- William
Ryan: Great question. I'm sure if you watch The News Hour on PBS on Monday they'll have 10-15 minutes with experts who'll put it all in context for us. Or, we can just watch random tweets from people allegedly in Iran.
- Ken Sheppardson
@Bill Grant The compressed world is what makes it important to me. As Jim illustrated, it is important because the US will need to respond in some manner and that will cost you money.
- JR Holmes
Randy, this is a 'room' or 'group' created by leo for the specific purpose of discussing the live stream shows ... there's nothing stopping someone from starting an 'iran-election' group - but getting people to coalesce around the group is the hard part... that doesn't happen easily/quickly
- Chris Heath
@JR 100% agree... Things that happen in other countries matter to me in a way that might not have affected my great grandparents in their time.
- Bill Grant
yeah ken, a search is a good way to find stuff
- Chris Heath
Jim - I agree that stories can impact us later, but international stories tend to have less of a direct impact compared to national stories.
- Ryan Scullen
I really like the new friend feed, they've done a good job improving it to make it useful.
- Bill Grant
OK, I'm not familiar with FF yet, and wondered if it was possible. thanks
- Randy Willard
@Ryan Well true that the things that affect you most are the closest (at least usually).
- Bill Grant
in a bigger context, i see vetting (eg journalistic) sources as an essential act that everyone should learn... as demonstrated even here, in ff. i need to be able to assess, then depend on a hierarchy of reliable sources above me. it takes time to do that
- Preternat (Ken Cadby)
Ken - news organizations can get access to more 'official' sources of news (aka government representatives) but we all know that PR does not tell the real story. tweets as raw info, at least to me, is more valuable. RTs don't count. twitpics = more legitimacy.
- Ryan Scullen
@Ryan True. I just cringe when we as a nation don't pay attention to something that happens beyond our borders until it's about to bite us in the keester. Forewarned/Forearmed doesn't seem to apply to our society.
- Jim Stanger
The web's going to take over the console business
- Stephen Pickering
low cost, small sized games like Tetris are the way to make money
- Michael Mooney
my first real use of ff... i wish i could see avatars to help me remember what comments belong to who
- Preternat (Ken Cadby)
My current favorite game is the NY Times Crossword app on my iPhone!
- Joel W Tscherne
Jim - once news organizations have a crystal ball to tell us the future with 100% accuracy, I'm ditching web news and watching tv news again lol.
- Ryan Scullen
That's the plot for Deep Impact. 14 year old spots the comet first
- Joel W Tscherne
"Sepulveda [Pivotal Labs], whose group builds applications for companies wanting mobile offerings, said he’s advising his clients — Twitter, BestBuy and Salesforce among them — to start on the Pre. The phone’s operating system, called WebOS, offers the most compelling place to build and test a prototype, for both cost and technology reasons, he said." -- http://venturebeat.com/2009...
- Ken Sheppardson
give palm pre some time for people to develope before you write it off
- Omar Atin
Did I just hear that right, one side of the USB ports on a Mac are better than the other?
- Bill Grant
Something wrong with the mac? This bit will be edited out
- Greg Byrne
I would like to start dev for the Pre, but I don't think its got the base OS to pull off a casual games platform. I read on Gizmodo i think that the Pre's REAL target competition will be the blackberry.
- Ryan Scullen
"Got a Pre? Like Nintendo? If you fit in the overlapping intersection of that particular Venn diagram, then have I got some good news for you. Some enterprising individuals over at the Pre Dev Wiki have gotten a NES emulator up and running on the Palm Pre." -- http://www.crunchgear.com/2009...
- Ken Sheppardson
I moved off of this conversation and I have no idea how to get back.... Now I need to keep hitting the comment link at the top every time. This could be a little more intuitive.
- Bill Grant
Facebook is not using OAuth or OpenID (OpenID is promsied)
- Chris Saad
Stephen: _Was_ a walled garden? How is it not now? I still get links where I need to log in to see things. Can't think of a time it's not been this way.
- Gold
Chris: Well, considering we've ranged from the Iran elections to video games to social networking, I think we maybe just have to nod and take this all with a grain of salt. ;-)
- Ken Sheppardson
Ken - the competition is not even close. MySpace is the like AOL, Facebook is like Google.
- Ryan Scullen
Gold - I agree that is why I've stayed away from FB.
- Paul Blasman
Classmates must make money from organizing reunions. Who would pay to contactsomeone you do not remember.
- Judith Gerdin
Ryan: Fine. I'll concede the point. The only people who should fear Facebook is Classmates :-D
- Ken Sheppardson
And Leo just explained why Facebook will never "take over"
- Ken Sheppardson
Paul Blasman: I've stayed away due to the T&C. I have no problem with the walled garden but the T&C are draconian.
- Gold
Ken - lol I never liked the idea of classmates from the beginning - too much spam linking
- Ryan Scullen
Gold - I didn't even want to go there!
- Paul Blasman
Leo - you should be checking out your daughter account
- Paul Blasman
3 million usernames have been claimed since Friday night ... in the first 14 hours, that is
- Ken Sheppardson
Paul Blasman - Heh. :) I've had one friend from Auckland, NZ appear on those damned "This guys I.Q. is x. What's yours?" ads. He followed it up and they said they purchased it from Facebook.
- Gold
facebook landgrab was soooo over hyped. Just another excuse for bloggers to have something to write about and for people to have another thing added to their business cards
- Ross Johnson
I'm still going to keep my 9" black and white for my Apple ][+ monitor
- Ken Sheppardson
I feel bad for the senior citizens but for anyone under the age of 65, if you didn't follow the hundreds of mentions of this conversion to digital, you might not deserve digital tv.
- Bill Grant
I have Comcast and try using them with a cable card, they are hopeless.
- Kim Landwehr
If not for wanting live sports, I'd just go to Hulu and streaming exclusively.
- Ken Sheppardson
No, Leo is giving them away under a new promo called PreCrunch :)
- jcunwired
cable is coax. can be ran straight to TV, or a cable box. straight to TV still broadcasts in analogue over coax. so comcast is illegally shutting off analogue over coax, cause if they can get 60% or more subscribers (i think, might be 80%) onto cable boxes, they can force everyone to switch.
- Ryan Scullen
sorry my bad, those are rules for canada... not US... rules are probably different.
- Ryan Scullen
What happened to this FCC ruling - "FCC Takes Action To Prevent Cable Companies From Dropping Digital Broadcast Networks From Analog Cable" - http://consumerist.com/299517...
- Ken Sheppardson
"DVR" will just turn into a local cache
- rob friedman
Bandwidth caps are the cable industry's attempt to preserve their business model. As DSL and the long-hoped-for wireless broadband get bigger, they run the risk of losing customers to competitors who don't do that limit.
- JR Holmes
Got to have the Mashable team on more often. ;)
- Ben Parr
You should have talked about my video coverage from Computex http://techvideoblog.com/categor... , the ARM laptops cost only 100 dollars and will replace Apple, Microsoft and Intel
- Charbax
You have such a great eye for composition. Lovely shots. What did you do in post (if anything)?
- Aaron D'Souza
The spiral staircase is my favorite photo.
- Chiu-Ki Chan
Thanks :) Aaron: I imported using Adobe Camera Raw and then sometimes selectively adjusted curves and rotated and cropped. http://si.smugmug.com/gallery... is HDR, all the others are from a single exposure.
- Simon
Nice. I've got to start carrying a tripod. And my camera. And a wide angle lens. :)
- Seth
If Photography was only about equipment, there'd be gobs of great photographers. Fortunately, it's also about having a good eye, skill, and fanatical devotion to technique.
- Piaw Na
Good point. I've got to start carrying Simon.
- Seth
"Popular user-edited online encyclopedia Wikipedia has finally released a mobile-friendly version of the web site at mobile.wikipedia.org."
- Anthony Farrior
from Bookmarklet
Very good advice, Thomas. A comment on no. 6 ("Groups"): I remember Flickr staff mentioning that not only photos that are in too many groups (more than 10-15, as a rule of thumb) get penalties for their Explore rating. Allegedly, this is also true for photos that are in the *wrong* groups, specifically the ubiquitous "post 1, comment x" groups. So not all photo critique groups might be good when you want to get your pictures into Explore.
- Ole Begemann
Ole, I hadn't heard that certain groups penalized photos but have seen Flickr staff in the past mention that posting your photo to too many groups will reduce it's visibility with their algorithm.
- Thomas Hawk
Re: no. 5 ("Explore"): more criteria that seem to influence whether a photo makes it to Explore: the presence of EXIF data, geotags, title, description has a positive influence; faves and comments from people who are not among your contacts seem to count more than from contacts; faves and comments from popular photographers count more than those from nobodys; a photo that gets 2 or 3 faves within minutes after uploading is more likely to make Explore than one that gets faved 15 times within 24 hours.
- Ole Begemann
Thomas, I'll try to find a reference for this.
- Ole Begemann
Good point on EXIF data Ole, yes, photos in Explore are required to have EXIF data. My own guess as to why this is is that if a photo has EXIF data it is more likely to be your own photo vs. something you simply ripped from the web. Not foolproof of course but I'd guess that this policy is in part due to a desire to increase the authenticity of the photos promoted on Explore.
- Thomas Hawk
If you look at the photos in Explore, the only "Leave a comment" groups that I see with any regularity are TWTME and 1-2-3 groups... what makes them special I'm not sure, other than they're amongst the largest groups in general. But you see very few of those award groups or "leave x comments" groups in the photos in Explore, so I suspect that Flickr must be penalizing them.
- Eric P
Thomas, that's a great refresher on the original article. Some great tips.
- Tom Quinn
And Thomas, throwing reciprocation in as a "bonus"? It should have been #1 or #2. The vast, vast, vast majority of comments and faves that I receive are from people whose stream I previously visited. The only real exception to that is when a photo is high in Explore, which results in a torrent of views/comments/faves from strangers.
- Eric P
Yep Eric. Reciprocation is very high. Bonus tip might not be the best place for it. It's very important. Faving back when people fave your work, commenting back. Adding people back as mutual contacts, etc. All encourage activity on your photostream.
- Thomas Hawk
Eric, participation groups don't penalize your photo from Explore best I can tell. This photo http://www.flickr.com/photos... from a few weeks ago was in the Deleteme Uncensored critique group and was #3 on Explore as well.
- Thomas Hawk
In fact just searching flickr for the save10 tag from the DMU critique group along with "explore" brings up a number of photos: http://www.flickr.com/search...
- Thomas Hawk
Good post, *IF* getting attention is important to you, as opposed to using it as a vehicle to just share photos with people
- Eric Rice
After I read your original article on Flickr popularity a while back, I began reciprocating every comment received. That worked very well.
- Tom Harrison
Eric, true. Some people have no interest in their photos receiving attention. I do think that the majority of people posting on Flickr though do appreciate when their photos receive some attention. Lots of people do not though. I have friends that only publish private photos that their friends can see and opt out of every public aspect of Flickr. I think these people though are the exception rather than the norm and think that Caterina's quote is pretty typical of the most active users on the site.
- Thomas Hawk
Alright, I found something. Flickr staff member acknowledged almost 2 years ago that "groups that force people to comment/fave on certain photos with no choice" do in fact hurt your Explore chances. Also, "weight of comments and favorites from contacts is quite low in interestingness calculation." (http://www.flickr.com/groups...). A very old post and the algorithm has changed since then but we can probably say that the gist of it is still true.
- Ole Begemann
interesting Ole. I hadn't seen that. I think it would be difficult for Flickr to manually track every group that encourages tags and comments as participation. Per the links above though, photos in DMU have definitely made it into Explore anyways.
- Thomas Hawk
Yeah, I have no idea how they maintain a list of the "bad" groups. Further below, SilentObserver mentions his business is writing algorithms to filter them out automatically, though.
- Ole Begemann
Here is an example of tagging. I did not know this woman was a celebrity until after got this shot. It appears on the first page of the image search engines and it has received over 12,000 views. http://flickr.com/photos...
- Russellreno
So far I got 3 (!) photos into explore. Their common factor? They all were faved by you (TH) soon after I posted theim.
- Guillaume Lemoine
Flickr used to say "who" faves your shots was a part of the Explore algorithm. It wouldn't surprise me if the algorithm weights faves by different people from the Flickr community differently. For instance, Pro accounts where people actually have paid for the service might be weighted higher than non-Pro accounts. More active users might carry more weight with their faves then less active users. Just speculating on this part.
- Thomas Hawk
Thomas - I don't think that participation in all groups gets a penalty, just that there are some groups that are penalized as far as Explore is concerned. I simply don't see Explore photos in "Post 1, Comment X" groups - so either there's no explore-worthy photos in those groups (not likely IMHO), or Flickr is penalizing the photos in those groups.
- Eric P
As a note to certain groups penalizing your photos...I had a photo (http://www.flickr.com/photos...) that went to explore spot 150 or so. After, I added it to a few groups to see if I could bump it higher. It had the opposite affect and immediately dropped off. I can't say which group exactly did it or if it was the number of groups I submitted to, but adding to groups definitely does come with some sort of penalty.
- Justin Korn
If you use FeedBurner, you can splice your Flickr photos into your blog feed. I have it splice my last two photos and I find those have at least 5x the number of views as the ones that aren't in my spliced feed.
- Mike Hussein Cohen
Awesome post Thomas. I signed up for Flickr a couple of years ago, but only started using it more regularly after the purchase of a digital SLR camera - so this post is particularly relevant to me. I am still patiently waiting for that first comment/favourite on one of my photos to truly experience the emotions as described by Caterina Fake.
- Jeff Smith
Thanks for this post, Thomas. Great tips!
- Eric Johnson
Great article Thomas... I was also wondering about what my friend calls 'Shooting for the 75'. That is, a great majority of people only ever see a 75 x 75px thumbnail of your photo. When he processes, he always does a square crop to test how it looks in the frame. Would you like to see proportional thumbnails as an option?
- Johnny Worthington
I actually really like the square thumbnails. Heck I really like the square crop period. I think I'm cropping more and more of my photos 4x4 these days. Maybe it's just that I've always loved medium format photography so much, not sure why I'm so drawn to the square crop right now though. I much prefer Flickr's square thumbnails actually. Still would love to see larger sizes on FF like SmugMug's thumbnails.
- Thomas Hawk
you're right though. Frequently it's the thumbnail that draws people into a photo. A good looking thumbnail is more likely to be selected by viewers for clicking through to full size viewing, commenting, faving, etc.
- Thomas Hawk
One of my very first Flickr experiences was someone in a critique group cutting me down for a square crop. It was a rose in a perfect spiral petal pattern, could only be cropped square as far as I was concerned. LOL...I didn't change it either.
- Karoli
Haha, that's funny Karoli. so much of the criticism in critique groups on Flickr is so lame. You should have seen the deleteme critique group ravage a Henry Cartier Bresson photograph who is probably considered by most photo historians as the greatest photographer who ever lived. Read some of these comments on this photo for a laugh: http://www.flickr.com/photos...
- Thomas Hawk
I used to work to get photos into explore. I think I probably take better pictures now, but I don't have the time at the moment to put in the work. Lots of community building and commenting went into the mix. I confess, there's a real rush to hitting the front page. I had three in the top 10, and it was a lot of fun.
- Karoli
I have been doing a lot of panoramic shots over the past year and I have started to play around with vertical cropping. Taking a portrait photo and cropping a really tight vertical crop: http://www.flickr.com/photos... It's all about how the picture looks to you in the end. Square, circle or hexagon, it's about the sensory reaction :) (and now I'm going to square crop for this week just to try it out, thanks guys)
- Johnny Worthington
Thomas, those comments are a hoot! I met some nice people in some of the critique groups, but it didn't take me long to know the critiques weren't helping. I do love Flickr's community...even if I haven't spent a lot of time in it lately.
- Karoli
yeah, the attention from Explore can be fun. But I'm pretty unimpressed with a lot of the photos there. I think Flickr could do a much better job with that algorithm. I do find filtering explore just by my contacts though produces more consistently interesting photographs for me. I use this script to do just that: http://www.drewmyersphoto.net/flickr_...
- Thomas Hawk
Agree on the photo quality on Explore. Seems like a lot of the same sort of gimmicky stuff lands there. Looking forward to trying the script.
- Karoli
Thanks for the article, that opened my eyes up a lot
- Alex Carpenter
Hey Karoli, here's you and your daughter by the way. I uploaded this to Zooomr a while back when I was taking a break from Flickr but uploaded it tonight on Flickr. Great fun on that photowalk. http://www.flickr.com/photos...
- Thomas Hawk
Hey, cool! Thanks for the pointer. It was a great photowalk, would love to do another sometime soon!
- Karoli
Here is one more way to get attention: Comment on this post with a link to one of your photos. I received a hit today from the comment about. http://www.flickr.com/photos...
- Russellreno
This is so weird.. I was just thinking about this today, when I was arguing with my wife about why I post so much stuff. I'm thinking that personal branding is important.
- Joe Mac Stevens
Really good stuff, Chris. Thanks for sharing.
- Bruce Turner
Thank You! Excellent topic that I will delve into right away.
- Wendy J. Roan
from twhirl
except that you do a US only list it is a nice list. would it really be asked too much to at least recognize that for example linkedin does not rule the world and write "join the leading biz network, like for example linkedin"?
- Nicole Simon
Holy crap, Chris! This is great stuff! Would you say personal branding is for anyone, or more for people who have something to sell through their online persona (a product, service, or opinion)?
- Zach Landes
thanks Chris - what a great resource - wil be sending this to all my staff - if only they will DO IT! :)
- Brad
from twhirl
Wow, this list is awesome Chris. Thanks for sharing it.
- Jason Runyan
100 Personal Branding Tactics Using Social Media. Your title is awfully modest considering you covered every marketing aspect in the online world.
- Collin
One of the great things about blogging is it gives businesses the opportunity to listen. Your point about listening is well taken.
- John P. Kreiss
I was gonna say, Mitchell, that looks like the same thing that Zee posted earlier today. It's a little creepy, don't ya think?
- Pete Delucchi
Pete: Sorry I was a little slow in my credits... :-) ;-) I thought it was an awesome shot, but Zee's link is to a blogger photo which was smaller, so I went looking for a bigger photo for my collection (I have these on my computer as desktops in a whole folder of awesome pics...)
- Mitchell Tsai
hey, I'm just happy you're posting things here again, Mitchell, either I've had awful timing for the last week or so and missed your posts, or you've been posting less? Either way, I'm glad to see ya!
- Pete Delucchi
Pete: I was off-line for 22 days, so I just started catching up 2 days ago. Good to see you again.
- Mitchell Tsai
22 days?! No wonder it felt like there was a lot less Mitchell around here. Glad to see ya back, we missed ya, brother!
- Pete Delucchi
From io9: "When Kevin "Wired" Kelly worked with the Whole Earth Catalog, he happened to receive a piece of mail from renowned scifi author Robert Heinlein. Apparently Kelly had mailed Heinlein, and in response he got this bizarre form letter that Heinlein sent to all his correspondents. The author would simply check the appropriate box in answer and mail it off. What's great about the letter is that some of the boxes refer to extremely granular things, like references to obscure articles about science in long-gone publications."
- Mark Trapp
from Bookmarklet
I love the last option: even though the letter was outstanding and he was so pleased to respond, he *still* sends the automated form letter. :-P
- Mark Trapp
"One of the great things that I find about Buddhism is how the common thread of peace, truth and liberation of mind are present in all forms of Buddhism. Vajrayana(Tibetan being one example), Theravada, Mahayana(Zen being one example) are the 3 major schools, though there are many others. The basic principles are the most important thing, that the core teachings to do not change. It does not matter what coat of tradition you flavor it with, in fact, over the centuries, Buddhism has worked its way into the lifestyle of the culture where it sits and does not become the culture."
- William Harryman
I'll soon run out of Like's if Mitchell keeps this pace of sharing nice pics :)
- Jemm
Joni: FriendFeed allows ~200 likes/day. :-)) Even at my pace, I only have 2 days worth of internal posts (< 400 posts for the past 5 months). P.S. Thomas Hawk has 14,000+ favorites in his Flickr collection, try http://flickr.com/photos... For every Flickr photographer, You can slideshow (a) their pics (b) their favorites. Good reason to have lots of computer screens for showing pics & YouTube videos.
- Mitchell Tsai
yep. It's a great collection. I liked 80-90% of the pictures, which almost never happens. Some beautiful work. Now I just have to hunt down the originals & figure out where they were taken.
- Mitchell Tsai