Final paper for http://www.okfn.org/okcon/ submitted yesterday: "Collaborative Structuring of Knowledge
by Experts and the Public", focusing in on Citizendium. Tried to upload to arxiv but require endorsement, as per http://friendfeed.com/science... .
Printed off the PDF - Thanks for uploading it, Daniel.
- Graham Steel
You need endorsement to upload to arXiv? That's disappointing. Other places to upload pdfs - Slideshare and Scribd
- Jean-Claude Bradley
Who do you need for an endorsement? Someone who already has an account? Someone who has published there?
- Cameron Neylon
The rules are explained here: http://arxiv.org/help... Unfortunately, it is not completely transparent and is dependent on the subject-category, so there is no simple answer. arXiv is not an open-science utopia. It has always had some form of moderation to filter out cranks. The present system is at least a little more transparent than the previous one, which relied on arbitrary internal moderation procedures. I am an endorser, but only for quant-ph. You need to find someone who publishes in your chosen subject-category to endorse you.
- Matt Leifer
I understand these new rules (wasn't aware of older versions, though) and find them reasonable in general albeit impractical for my purposes, and even interesting as a dataset in the context of developing a karma system for science. I have never posted to arxiv before (basically because none of my coworkers have), and the most appropriate category for most of my papers would be q-bio. This one, however, does not even deal with physics - it is about general aspects of knowledge structuring but since physics is included in that, I find it appropriate for soc-ph. Didn't yet try to search for people who are entitled to endorse, and the point for me is not that I need a place for storing the file online (this ff thread does it fine) but to get some familiarity with the inner workings of the arxiv system, since it is a standard example in many discussions about open repositories and related topics, and so far, I only know it as a reader.
- Daniel Mietchen