Do any of you know anything about science outreach/science educator type positions? I'm a high school science teacher (degree in chemistry, picked the teaching cert. up after college) who thinks she'd be more useful as a science outreach educator. I have no idea how to make this happen, however, so I'm asking anyone I can come across.
I am sure you could make it happen but am not sure how you would get paid to do so. Start perhaps by talking with your local science museum, or a local college or university, who could have you coordinate a community outreach day to start? you'd have to build up some credibility in that role, so starting small is likely to be a good idea.
- Heather
Retrovirology | Full text | Impact factor, H index, peer comparisons, and Retrovirology: is it time to individualize citation metrics? - http://www.retrovirology.com/content...
" The QP-SURF program at UT Southwestern is an intensive summer research training experience which leads to an understanding of the planning, discipline, and teamwork involved in the pursuit of basic answers to current questions at the interface of quantitative science and basic biomedical research. Fellows spend ten weeks (beginning June 7, 2010 through August 13, 2010) pursuing individual research projects in the laboratories of UT Southwestern Graduate School faculty members. Fellows gain experience in modern research techniques, and have a chance to plan and execute an experimental strategy to answer a scientific question. The program introduces students to the sorts of projects encountered during postgraduate research training and leads to an understanding of the planning, discipline, and teamwork involved in the pursuit of basic answers to current questions in the biological sciences. At the end of the summer, fellows present their research in a poster session. In addition to...
more...
- Mickey Schafer
Hi, Mickey. Thanks so much for heads-up. I quickly listed it on ScanGrants: http://www.scangrants.com/grant... I am always looking for neat things like that--thanks!
- Hope Leman
Hi Hope! Then you might also be interested in the SMDEP (Summer Medical and Dental Education Program) -- http://www.smdep.org/ -- this is only for undergrads though, so I don't know how that works for ScanGrants. Also, it targets under-represented minorities. Mickey
- Mickey Schafer
from email
Hi, Mickey--thank you so much. Oh, we definitely include items for undergraduates. I really try to list as many scholarships and academic prizes in the health sciences at all levels as possible. Got to get kids interested in science and medicine! And I have a diversity.underrepresented category, too. Therefore, your suggestion was perfect and much appreciated. I have listed it here--http://www.scangrants.com/grant...
- Hope Leman
Some day all science journals will contain scientific knowledge which is as verifiable and as immediately reusable as this.
- Dan Hagon
from Bookmarklet
No mention of friendfeed, so what about writing a correspondence piece on this? It could be based on http://ff4s-paper.wikidot.com/start and perhaps also put the recent NIH grant for a "Facebook for Scientists" ( http://ff.im/beKk7 ) in perspective by providing an overview over existing tools along these lines and why they are not widely used.
- Daniel Mietchen
http://www.cell.com/authors... / Correspondence: "The Correspondence format provides our readers with the opportunity to respond to an article in Cell—either a research article or Leading Edge article—that has been published within the last 2 months. Correspondence should be no more than 900 words in length with up to five references and should be of interest to the broad...
more...
- Daniel Mietchen
Now that sounds like a good idea! I'm all for it - especially mention the gazillion "facbook for scientists" already out there.
- Björn Brembs
333 words so far, and once the generic FF description and some highlights from the spreadsheet are in, we will be near the limit. So probably no time to dwell on fb4sci, though I would still like to mention the NIH grant in the hope that those people will build on the ideas we lay out.
- Daniel Mietchen
Maybe steer away from a "but we want to talk about friendfeed" towards more "there is a much richer set of tools out there...and here is a good example..."? Might mean the Fb4Sci stuff can get squeezed in?
- Cameron Neylon
I would actually prefer the Fb4Sci stuff in there, and the article would be more balanced if we were to name a few more services that offer microblogging (I listed some in the Organization part of the document). FF can then be described in two sentences as a particularly useful example because it provides hierarchies of threaded conversations in which the most current and the most popular entries compete for the top of attention.
- Daniel Mietchen
Biomed Central's policy on publishing open science defined: "Articles may be submitted to BioMed Central’s journals when data have been previously discussed or posted in such venues as blogs, wikis, social networking websites or lab electronic online notebooks. However, given the rapidly evolving nature of these resources, where discussion of data or manuscripts posted to these venues has subsequently been incorporated into the manuscript, the BioMed Central journal Editors may make their own assessment as to whether there may be duplication in the submitted manuscript." It's excellent that we are gaining some clarity here. To my mind the idea of open science is precisely to have "discussion of data or manuscripts posted to these venues" being subsequently "incorporated into the manuscript". In these cases the Biomed Central manuscript editor decides. We really need some test cases, and we need explicit policies from other publishers.
- Matthew Todd
from Bookmarklet
If I can just find some bloody time to sort out the paper I should be able to give you a test case pretty soon...submission to go to Biology Direct along with a snapshot of the online lab notebook.
- Cameron Neylon
Great, Cameron (wouldn't it be great to be able to buy time?) Submission of grant applications of open science projects will require us to be 100% clear to our referees that open science can be published in good journals. The more publishers agree to accept this kind of paper, the stronger the case that open science can result in high quality, high-impact publications. It's an important message to make clear to those unfamiliar with, or healthily sceptical of, the concept.
- Matthew Todd
My suspicion is that if I could buy time I wouldn't be able to afford it :-)
- Cameron Neylon
I think the writing is explicitly covered by the policy. I guess its the grey area around "discussion of results that later is incorporated" that we need to flesh out a bit more? Actually I think they're just giving themselves wiggle room for silly cases to be honest but being able to point to examples is helpful.
- Cameron Neylon
Good example Daniel - if we are looking more broadly than BMC I think most fully OA publications would accept pre-prints. I also suspect hybrids would not - for example AuthorChoice at ACS - but I don't know for sure.
- Jean-Claude Bradley
"...Congress [should] add five amendments to existing statutes that would improve the processing of patents, reduce lawsuits and speed up the arrival of innovations on the market."
- Bill Hooker
from Bookmarklet
"It is widely known that the brain perceives information before it reaches a person’s awareness. But until now, there was little way to determine what specific mental tasks were taking place prior to the point of conscious awareness."
- Bill Romanos
from Bookmarklet
"This wiki collects information about tools and resources that can help scholars (particularly in the humanities and social sciences) conduct research more efficiently or creatively. Whether you need software to help you manage citations, author a multimedia work, or analyze texts, Digital Research Tools will help you find what you're looking for. We provide a directory of tools organized by research activity, as well as reviews of select tools in which we not only describe the tool's features, but also explore how it might be employed most effectively by researchers."
- Mickey Schafer
"The Association of Internet Researchers is an academic association dedicated to the advancement of the cross-disciplinary field of Internet studies. It is a member-based support network promoting critical and scholarly Internet research independent from traditional disciplines and existing across academic borders. The association is international in scope."
- Mickey Schafer
got this from Holly! "NEW YORK - A new study confirms what your 130 Facebook friends and scores of Twitter followers may have already told you: The Internet and mobile phones are not linked to social isolation. Online activities such as e-mail, blogging and frequenting Internet hangouts can even lead to larger, more diverse social networks, according to the study released Wednesday by the Pew Internet and American Life Project. The study refutes research earlier in the decade suggesting that people's growing embrace of technology has come at the expense of close human connections."
- Mickey Schafer
"Pity Ola Bratteli who, when checking out how cited he is, has to take into account the “common misspellings Bratelli, Brattelli and the less common Brateli and Blatteli” of his last name. For someone who has given his name to the rather important Bratteli diagram, this is unfortunate."
- Dan Hagon
from Bookmarklet
Personally, am not convinced of some of the assumptions, e.g. "...Both are unfortunate, but are parts of the current culture [reference to sharing early lab results]. Any network that hopes to succeed must adapt to the culture of the community, rather than trying to rewrite it." First, though likely rare, I think there are instances where culture gets "re-written" -- another perspective is that this form of communication provides an alternative to established routes. That is, does not replace them but adds to the diversity of communication means.
- Mickey Schafer
The only thing I really disagree with here is that I think there will be a shift towards more open approaches as more examples of success show up. Then everyone will go over the edge like lemmings and there will be a backlash again but by then the funders will be piling in with conditions to push things forward.
- Cameron Neylon
<cynical>It doesn't matter what the scientists think. What matters is what the funders demand of them.</cynical> Open science doesn't really depend on "[online] social networks" and never has. It's true that most open-science sorts are active social networkers, but when the rubber hits the road, I don't care who's on FriendFeed -- I care who's sharing data. If the funders demand the latter and not the former, good on 'em. Behavior will shift accordingly.
- D0r0th34
But the funders are the scientists in most cases - so a mixture of pushing from within the community - as well as top down mandates will get us there. The question is how to get the funders into a position where they feel bound to impose mandates _and_ provide the infrastructure that makes it possible to observe them...?
- Cameron Neylon
Mmm, I'm not sure I agree. Funding infrastructure relies on a fair amount of scientist labor, yes -- but it's not career scientists who have been calling the funder shots; it's been top-level administrators (some of whom are ex-scientists, admittedly) looking at bottom lines. The Wellcome Trust mandate didn't come from scientists. Neither did the NIH policy. <cynical>One can't rely on scientists for effective science policy.</cynical>
- D0r0th34
Fair enough. UK Research Councils case is more nuanced. Even Wellcome Trust policy was driven to a certain extent by the fundees or at least not in the face of belligerent opposition from them. But comparing the independent funders like Wellcome to the Research Councils (run more by councils of academics) is instructive.
- Cameron Neylon
I thought the spin on your lovely shout out for Medeley on ch 4 news was interesting, Cameron (nice monitors btw!). 'government backing for innovators to meet and share' was the message. Have you had any responses to that yet? Maybe systems like Mendeley will be the things that start to crack the nut of social networking for scientists? I'm not sure it's a killer app, more the thin end of the wedge...
- Jo Badge
Shorter DC: I don't like social networks or spend any time on them, so they must be useless.
- Bill Hooker
I'm afraid they're not my monitors but those for the control room for one of the instruments (not incidentally the one that got filmed in the piece - but at least there was no blue liquid!) But they are in fact necessary to keep the instrument running and processing data efficiently.
- Cameron Neylon
I can imagine a report from 1670, a full five years after the creation of academic journals, concluding that virtually no scientists were using academic journals as a matter of course, and thus they are useless. (Technological progress has sped up a lot since 1670, of course. But social change isn't all that much faster, in my opinion. And this is fundamentally a social change.)
- Michael Nielsen
I think we also tend to forget the granddaddy social software: email. In some fields there are tremendously active listservs that have been around for over a decade especially at research universities where faculty got email before it really caught on in the wider world. What evidence would convince a scientist that Facebook, LinkedIn or Twitter offer better communication opportunities than an archived listserv?
- Jenny Reiswig
Well, aren't most scientists using email as "communication opportunities" and nothing else? (social network, listserv etc)?
- Maxine
were observations limited to sites specifically designed for scientists? perhaps to the exclusion of other significant mainstream platforms like facebook or twitter
- Mike Chelen
Jenny: it might be better to gauge usage based either on features such as address book management or by traffic metrics such as size of audience
- Mike Chelen
"Google has bought Gizmo5, an online phone company that is akin to Skype but based on open protocols and with a lot fewer users. TechCrunch, which broke the news on Monday, reported that Google spent $30 million on the company."
- Mickey Schafer
glad to hear, since my customer satisfaction with google is generally way above that with my phone carrier ;)
- Mike Chelen
On Becoming a Scientist -- E-in-C of Science, Bruce Alberts, advises on how to make good choices in one's career path - http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi...
Tim Gowers has some very interesting ideas for an open science project to come up with a simple theoretical model where self-replication organisms are likely to spontaneously arise. In this post he tries to formulate a question or questions such a project could feasibly attack, and discusses what would count as a success.
- Michael Nielsen
I can't do justice to this post here in this short space - the whole post and the discussion thread that follows are both full of interesting ideas - but I think it'd be very interesting to get input from other people. The spirit of the proposed project has something of the flavour of the Urey-Miller experiment
- Michael Nielsen
"So what are we proposing? We will phase out project and programme grants and instead, extend the model of fellowship support to researchers who are salaried by their university or research institute. "
- Daniel Mietchen
"We look to the scientific community to bring us their best ideas." - looks like an invite for another round of Fantasy Science Funding (this time from the perspective of the Wellcome Trust).
- Daniel Mietchen
Having been a Wellcome Trust International Travelling Fellow I've appreciated Wellcome's visionary approach to funding, and applaud their initiative here. This isn't a fantasy, this is Wellcome, and it will happen...
- Richard Badge
I agree, I don't think this is fantasy. They will do what they say. Few, the light is finally dawning.
- Jo Badge
For background on Fantasy Science Funding, see http://ways.org/en... . This piece shall also serve as a basis for an upcoming post on "What would research funding look like if it were invented today?" ( http://ff.im/9SvED ) which is intended to contain a general analysis of the funding situation, combined with some specific examples....
more...
- Daniel Mietchen
this looks bit but I don't really understand what it means in practice. You apply for a fellowship but does that not mean that you still are asking for the resources for a defined programme of work? If slightly less tightly defined? Will be interested to see what this means in detailed terms.
- Cameron Neylon
Critique: An inward-looking scheme which must eventually collapse due to failure to recruit new talent (and lack of a proper career structure will speed that up). Bye bye UK science.
- AJCann
I would suggest to them to do a significant part of the review process in the open, and to abandon it for some control group that meets basic eligibility criteria.
- Daniel Mietchen
@ajcann cynic ;-) what do you propose instead then? At least they are trying to acknowledge that science is done by good people with good ideas, giving them the freedom to follow those ideas to their logical conclusions and not to a pre-determined end point that you can only guess at.
- Jo Badge
But this strategy cannot be successful in the long term as it is anti-innovative and will inevitably degenerate into an old boys club.
- AJCann
@ AJCann: It has already gone much of that way, and I interpret Walport's piece as a sign of consciousness of the matter and an invitation for constructive criticism, albeit he seems to be very concerned about the opinions of other funders.
- Daniel Mietchen
The Wellcome trust is certainly one of the organizations that are most upfront (and sometimes brutal) in saying what they want and being forceful in maximizing their return on investment. I would certainly give them the benefit of the doubt to some extent on this one. But there is also something of a perception that it is something of a closed club. Partly this is down to a conscious...
more...
- Cameron Neylon
Yes, but not a viable strategy for UK science overall. It works for Wellcome as long as they can cannibalize the fresh talent funded by someone else. It won't work over the longer term is all (or most) agencies go down this route.
- AJCann
@ajcann you'd rather have two strikes and you're out ala epsrc?
- Jo Badge
from iPod
Well at least junior researchers can apply for an EPSRC grant.
- AJCann
Alan, let me ask the tough question - _is_ there a viable strategy for UK science overall? As in a strategy that views UK science in isolation? Having just got back from China I've got to say it certainly feels like we're toast unless we build our personnel and physical infrastructure in a bigger framework.
- Cameron Neylon
Probably not at the present/proposed levels of funding and considering what is being asked. Developing economies regard fundamental research as a route to prosperity. Decaying economies seems to regard science funding as a drain. It would be possible to fund selected areas, e.g. sustainable technologies, healthcare, and focus limited funding, but in this proposal inadequate funding is...
more...
- AJCann
It's interesting how explicit that is in the China case. The spending of money to speed development as well as to bring people back to support this. Building a new campus expected to house 20,000 scientists in a five year timeframe just doesn't seem to bother them. At the same time the heirachical and top down nature of the society and organization of their science doesn't seem to support radical developments. Will be very interesting to watch though.
- Cameron Neylon
This would probably work better with a Bold and the clickable screen. I do miss the feel and thunk of pressing the keys on that thing.
- Carey Lumeng
Older?...yes. Less intuitive? You've obviously never used the HP-12c. It has the best interface around for time value of money (TVM) calculations. Also, if you can't wrap your head around RPN logic, you could always turn that feature off. Best of all, with an app like this I can leave my HP-12c at home.
- Edwin Webster
I am inclined to submit a proposal for a session on Open Science. If any of you plan to go there or wish to contribute to the session, let me know.
- Daniel Mietchen
from Bookmarklet
Update (a few months later): The main deadline for session proposals is gone, but Eurodoc ( http://www.eurodoc.net/ ) are planning to submit a session for the "young scientists" part, for which the deadline is Sep 30 (next Wednesday). Preliminary title (possibly familiar to some of you): "What would science look like if it were invented today?" Would any of you be available to join the...
more...
- Daniel Mietchen
People from the Oxford Internet Institute put in something on Science and the internet - can't remember the exact details but could put you in touch.
- Cameron Neylon
from twhirl
Yes, Cameron, please do. But participation in our session would not be limited to pre-selected themes or people - we plan to do it as open as possible.
- Daniel Mietchen
Absolutely. Just a case of demonstrating that the thinking is connected up :-)
- Cameron Neylon
Seems to me that a session on Open Science could fit well within theme #10 ("Policy - what follows?") of the http://www.esof2010.org/themes... : "European science, research and innovation policies; the role of EU and national institutions; European science policy in a global context; international S&T cooperation policies; the changing landscape of European...
more...
- François Dongier
The deadline for the Scientific Programme (and also the "Policy what follows" theme) has already passed, it will be submitted in the Career Programme. So as Daniel wrote, it should be for young scientists to inform them about developements and also to involve them in a debate on new developments. For now, it is most urgent find people for the list of speakers which will be connected online to talk about Science 2.0.
- weppens
"We describe the system architecture and template design of "Scratchpads", a data-publishing framework for groups of people to create their own social networks supporting natural history science. Scratchpads cater to the particular needs of individual research communities through a common database and system architecture. This is flexible and scalable enough to support multiple networks, each with its own choice of features, visual design, and constituent data. Our data model supports web services on standardised data elements that might be used by related initiatives such as GBIF and the Encyclopedia of Life. A Scratchpad allows users to organise data around user-defined or imported ontologies, including biological classifications. Automated semantic annotation and indexing is applied to all content, allowing users to navigate intuitively and curate diverse biological data, including content drawn from third party resources. A system of archiving citable pages allows stable referencing with unique identifiers and provides credit to contributors through normal citation processes."
- Mike Chelen
from Bookmarklet
RegExp missing some chars, e.g., % if URL-encoded. We tend to use 10\.(?:\d{4})/(?:[^ "'<&]+) but that can break too - it's annoying that the DOI spec doesn't limit the chars allowed! This is for searching the whole text (incl. within href), not element-wise so might not suit your code exactly.
- Fergus Gallagher
Fergus: going to take a look and give that a try, probably only will try to work with displayed text, but it might be cool to add compatibility with any kind of field attribute or xhtml. thanks!
- Mike Chelen
One special case worth looking for is "COiNS" OpenURL. Our (jQuery) code is var z = jQuery(".Z3988:eq(0)"); if (z.length) { var r = z.attr("title").split("&"); for (var i=0; i<r.length; i++) { var x = decodeURIComponent(r[i]); if (/^rft_id=info:doi\/.*?(10\.\d\d\d\d\/.*)/.exec(x)) { var doi = RegExp.$1; doSomething(doi); return; } } }
- Fergus Gallagher