“I don’t know if all the women in the photographs are beautiful, but I do know that the women are beautiful in the photographs.” – Garry Winogrand Garry Winogrand’s one of my biggest personal heroes. The ultimate street photographer, Garry was a non-stop photographic machine. His were the pre-digital days. He devoured film with an appetite previously unmatched. He shot film like many photographers shoot digital today. Frenetic, non-stop, with only an occasional break to reload. He shot almost every day and while he crisscrossed the country shooting the best of America, he always remained a quintessential New Yorker at heart. When Garry died at an early age of 56 he left John Szarkowski, then director of the NY MOMA, with the task of editing what he left behind, 6,500 rolls of unprinted and 2,500 rolls of undeveloped 35mm negatives (about 300,000 frames).
- Thomas Hawk
Thomas, a very interesting and thought provoking article. I do not have nearly as many hours on the street as you do, but as Brad stated on his comment on your Blog, I believe the direct approach is usually the best. If you act like you are trying to hide something, people often get suspicious. It also depends on where you shoot. SF is probably more hostile than Santa Cruz and the San...
more...
- Jeff P. Henderson
I think as long as you grab one of the corners or sides it will maintain the original image constraints? It's when you use the free-crop (IE: clicking somewhere in the middle and drawing a crop) that it breaks the ratio.
- cmiper
It defaults to the last setting... try pushing the padlock
- Johnny Worthington
@gbenedict, that shift while dragging trick is nice. Thanks. For some unknown reason it just shifted back to locked by default, crazy.
Yahoo Answers. Resolved: The reason people use the USPS stickers is because they are free from the Post Office, so the people who draw on them don't have to pay for sticker paper or printing costs for real stickers. - http://www.flickr.com/photos...
Over at the Getty Images Contributor Group on Flickr (it’s private and you have to be an accepted Flickr/Getty photographer in order to see it) there have been a number of threads started over the past few months where Getty/Flickr contributors have posted and shared basic information about how their sales are going through the Flickr/Getty partnership thus far. While it is probably far too early to accurately ascertain a lot of the statistics on how things are truly going, I thought I’d compile some of this information as anecdotal.
- Thomas Hawk
Flickr maps needs serious work. My geotags are coded as the weirdest neighborhoods. Where the hell in SF is Inset, San Francisco?
Canon Rebel and Kit Lens Survives 3,000 Foot Skydiving Fall and Still Works, Then Why Are Their L Series Lenses So Crappy? - http://thomashawk.com/2009...
"It's time to face facts: San Francisco is spectacularly mismanaged and arguably the worst-run big city in America. This year's city budget is an astonishing $6.6 billion — more than twice the budget for the entire state of Idaho — for roughly 800,000 residents. Yet despite that stratospheric amount, San Francisco can't point to progress on many of the social issues it spends liberally to tackle — and no one is made to answer when the city comes up short."
- Thomas Hawk
from Bookmarklet
Over the past couple of days Flickr has quietly begun censoring content viewed by people using Yahoo IDs coming from India. Flickr user crazydude2006 found this out the hard way when he noticed that he could no longer see photographs by many of his contacts or groups that he previously had been able to view. Flickr staffer Criz responded to his question with the following: “As you are coming in from a Yahoo! ID in India, and we just localized our site to India, you won’t be able to view moderate or restricted content.” This now adds India to the list of countries that are unable to view content rated moderate or restricted on Flickr in addition to Singapore, Hong Kong and Korea. Additionally users in Germany cannot view content rated restricted.
- Thomas Hawk
"I just recently overheard a self-described "purist" photographer ranting on about how we're all cheaters and that the photographic masters before us lacked our current luxury--even desire--to "customize" (read: manipulate/photoshop) images. It was "...all about the the composition, a beautiful subject, and a properly exposed picture". I call horse-pucky. Above: Avedon's instructions to his printer."
- Thomas Hawk
from Bookmarklet
Larry Sultan, a highly influential California photographer whose 1977 collaboration, “Evidence” — a book made up solely of pictures culled from vast industrial and government archives — became a watershed in the history of art photography, died on Sunday at his home in Greenbrae, Calif. He was 63.
- Thomas Hawk
from Bookmarklet
I've got this - I like it. I bought it to replace the the 3021BPRO. The center-column's easy vertical-to-horizontal movement without taking the column out is a nice feature. recommended - though the column is a tad be short for me at times, but otherwise I do like it.
- See-ming Lee 李思明 SML
I have the carbon fiber version of this tripod (190CXPRO3). Good tripod; tabbr approves.
- tabbr
how much lighter is the carbon fiber version, and other than being lighter are there any major differences?
- Thomas Hawk
I have this tripod too, fantastic tripod which is a bit heavier than the carbon fibre version but gives it a very sturdy feel. With the Manfrotto 322RC2 Joystick Head it's easy to use.
- Russell G
Generally speaking when Manfroto market the product in the same naming convention, their specs are close-to-no-differerent. The materials determine how much weight you want to carry. For this particular case, 190XPROB is 1.8 kg, ~$150, whereas 190CXPRO3 is 1.32 kg, ~$300. I personally buy all my photo equipment from B&H - as I find it easier to compare equipment over there: http://www.bhphotovideo.com/c...
- See-ming Lee 李思明 SML
I believe the 190CXPRO3 is about 1.1 pounds lighter than this one. An advantage of carbon fiber besides it being lighter is that it's also more rigid than aluminum and transfers less vibration.
- tabbr
"Rhode Island Democratic Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse is ready to take on that annoying blast of sound when TV commercials are just too loud and wants to compel the Federal Communications Commission to fix it and require the ads to be at the same decibel level as the programming. Whitehouse has introduced legislation called the Commercial Advertisement Loudness Mitigation Act of 2009, or CALM. New York Sen. Chuck Schumer (D) is a co-sponsor. Democrats say the FCC has received consumer complaints about commercials being louder than television shows since the 1960s. In the 25 quarterly reports on consumer complaints released by the FCC since 2002, 21 have listed as a top complaint the loudness of television commercials. Earlier this year, the Consumers Union, the nonprofit organization that publishes Consumer Reports, stated in testimony before the House of Representatives that "the CALM Act provides an elegant and common sense solution to finally ending a 45-year consumer complaint in the United States.""
- Thomas Hawk
from Bookmarklet
"According to deputy city controller Monique Zmuda, the Department of Public Works currently spends $3.7 million per year on its antigraffiti program. That sum dwarfs the $1.9 million spent annually in San Jose, which, with its population of 1 million, is 25 percent larger than San Francisco. It's also more than twice as much per capita as Los Angeles, a city of 3.8 million people that spends $7 million per year fighting graffiti. This is big money, particularly at a time when the city is facing an intractable budget crisis. Last month, the Board of Supervisors was desperately trying to scrounge up $8 million to prevent layoffs among public health workers. The Public Works graffiti-abatement program burns through that much in less than three years. Is it worth it?"
- Thomas Hawk
from Bookmarklet
"A community of ‘candid’ photographers of men in public situations (all of whom have paid for their accounts in good faith) has been displaced and silenced on photo-sharing site Flickr in less than a fortnight. Four prominent photostreams as well as countless photos vanished from July 6th 2009 to July 13th 2009 without warning or right to appeal. At least one site had over a million hits in less than a year. Flickr has stubbornly refused to give a reason for its recent axe-grinding mission against these sites, but one user was given the reason ‘voyeur content’ after more than 8 days of asking for a reason yet that particular site contained pictures of men in public which is legal. Flickr has refused to expand on the reason it gave, but cited its ambiguous and open-ended ‘Don’t be creepy’ clause in its Terms of Service asjustification for terminating at least one photostream. Flickr has also silenced debate about the issue on its Help Forum. When confronted with whether or nor the...
more...
- Thomas Hawk
Good! Flickr is out of control. They should not be allowed to delete a paying customer's photo or photostream without notifying the customer of the "problem" and giving them a chance to correct/explain the situation. It's just bad business. Flickr is a great site, but the negatives are slowly chipping away at the positives.
- Rob LaRosa
Yeah, Flickr is pretty out of control. I think I'll be letting my membership expire and using only Pbase from now on.
- Todd Walker
Wow. How do I move all of my photos from flickr? I suppose I'll have to find somewhere new to put them.
- joey
I think it sort of sucks that I post a link to blog specifically about account deletions to a Flickr Help forum thread specifically account deletions and get banned from the public forum. The Flickr is Fascist blog is not mine, I was merely reporting on it.
- Thomas Hawk
Looks like it's time to abandon Flickr to Mussolini. And then kick it in the head.
- James (!?)
Uh oh. You've been put on the naughty step.
- Simon Wicks
Seems like the more we rely on web services the more of our rights we inadvertently give up. With web services being bought, sold, discontinued, or the arbitrary rules that they invoke, we are more and more at the mercy of whim of the site owner. It seems like it is time for some sort of universal user bill of rights that defines a minimum level of service we should expect and defines guidelines for disputes between users and service providers.
- Jeff P. Henderson
Well Thomas, as the CEO of a competitor to Flickr, it was only a matter of time before they tired of your "crusades" and troublemaking. (regardless of how worthwhile they are, and they are)
- Robert Kenney
I have kept my photos on Flickr, because that is where my family goes to, but I also have them on Zooomr, really not happy with Flickr
- Kim Landwehr
This is clearly a signal that Flickr is on the move. To be spun-off, sold, etc. As part of preparations for this, they have been given a mandate to clean-up the site of "less desirable" content to make it more marketable to a buyer.
- Robert Kenney
What are the best alternatives to Flickr?
- Johnny
Johnny, that depends on what you want from the site. If you want a community, then Flickr is probably the best. If you just want a place to host your photos or sell your work. there are plenty of other options. Here are several that come to mind. Zooomr, Smugmug, Picassa, Snapfish.
- Jeff P. Henderson
Robert Kenney: Thomas has been a critic of flickr, but he's also an advocate and user of flickr, in addition to being a competitor. The photo sharing biz is funny that way.
- Bruce Lewis
from fftogo
i also don't like the fact that Flickr staff refers to me as "abusive" before kicking me out of the forum. My criticism has always been respectful. Simply because someone criticizes you does not make them "abusive" that's such a loaded almost libelous term. I resent that Flickr would call me abusive and then lock me out of the forum where I can't defend myself against that accusation.
- Thomas Hawk
Flickr is not a democracy, as they remind all of us again and again.
- Robert Kenney
Robert, but users should be able to expect a certain level of civility and recourse that you expect, (and is often required by law) when doing business with a brick and mortar establishment.
- Jeff P. Henderson
the anti flickr blog by the way has moved and I honestly have absolutely zero to do with this new anti flickr blog. I was simply reporting on it after the authors of the blog (who I do not know who they are) pointed it out to me. http://saynotoflickr.blogspot.com
- Thomas Hawk
I've been arguing against arbitrary account deletions and censorship there pretty passionately for a while. Especially lately as the account deletions seem to have escalated (and especially anything associated with or male gay related). I suppose they don't like being criticized for their deletion decisions, but personally I think labeling me as "abusive" for it and censoring me is yet another bad tact for them to take.
- Thomas Hawk
don't like flickr's problems? put your pix somewhere else. It's a website, not a national government; it's not fascist.
- Chieze Okoye
Most of the time those being deleted have no platform to object and so they turn to the only public avenue that they know the help forum. I like sticking up for the little guy, especially when he/she's in the right. It is frustrating though feeling like you are banging your head against the wall with Flickr who just seem frankly not to care one bit about the criticism or even ever address their censorship choosing to simply lock any thread objecting to it.
- Thomas Hawk
no, Chieze, it's not just a "website," any more than FriendFeed is just a "website." It's a community. That's always been what's made it special. It's just too bad that those overseeing the community don't feel that they need to have respect for it.
- Thomas Hawk
My contention is that Friendfeed *is* just a website, though. It's kinda nice when they get stuff right, and kinda bad when they get stuff wrong, but at the end of the day, it's just a tool. Is your tool breaking or acting up? Try to fix it within your capacity (writing blogs sometimes works when you're not part of the development itself, but bandying about hyperbole like calling a website fascist usually doesn't) or just move to the next tool that will work reliably the way you want.
- Chieze Okoye
There's a huge audience that you only reach through Flickr. There's no "next tool" to reach that many.
- Bruce Lewis
Chieze, I didn't call Flickr fascist. I simply reported on the fact that *somebody else* started a blog called that. I pretty much report on everything that's related to flickr that I come across. I'm not sure why I should have been banned simply for reporting on it. We'll have to disagree on both Flickr and FriendFeed merely being "websites." I hold to my contention that they are far, far, more than just "websites," that they are very significant hubs for communities, both of them in fact.
- Thomas Hawk
The thing that bugs me most about the way Flickr deals with things is that they delete and/or block, giving the accused no avenue for recourse. If they want to accuse me of having photos on the site that aren't mine, that's fine, but don't take down the evidence. They should have to leave the pics up there and prove to me that they are right. How could I do that after my pictures have...
more...
- Kenton
Oh, Thomas, I realize that you weren't calling it fascist, I didn't mean to make it seem like I was conflating you with this blog's behavior. Sorry about that. We will have to agree to disagree about the tool/website thing, I guess. I'm not an avid Flickr user, so I don't have that passion (but I am an avid Friendfeeder, at least by my personal standards, and I still think the way I do...
more...
- Chieze Okoye
Also, @Bruce, at this point, no one should be surprised with Flickr's behavior. Yes there's great audience, but it's not like there NO OTHER photo sharing site that has a community of people you can connect with. Continuing my tool metaphor, it would be like if you had the world's best hammer, but that hammer had poisonous spikes on the handle. For some people who need it or really want...
more...
- Chieze Okoye
Chieze, I'm well aware there are other photo sharing sites. I run one. But for photographers with a professional interest in getting noticed, Flickr is not optional.
- Bruce Lewis
Saying there are options to Flickr is like saying there are options to Windows. Sure, technically there are but not may people use them.
- ChiliMac
Yeah, Flickr isn't optional if you want to build a brand/reputation or just get noticed. Which sucks, because I'd have dumped my account there in protest a while ago if that wasn't the case. What's idiotic is that I can't even fathom a reason for these absurd censorship policies. How difficult can it be to implement an holding pen for violating accounts and a review process before they pull that delete trigger?
- Eric P
posted your blog post separately See-ming. http://friendfeed.com/thomash... Ironicly, posting about this "Flickr is Fascist" blog is what got me indefinitely banned from the Flickr Help forum. I think that they are pretty pissed off about it. At least pissed off enough to ban me over merely mentioning it publicly.
- Thomas Hawk
@TH Thanks! I was not going to post it until I realize recently that it is happening to a lot of my gay friends - including some who cannot post to my groups anymore because they are having the same problem, which is very sad.
- See-ming Lee 李思明 SML
As someone who has, quite unfairly, had their name featured several times in the Flickr is Fascist Blog, and who knows who the perpetrator is I can understand why Flickr would want to protect it’s users in this way. The person behind it not only has a malicious personal vendetta against certain people on the site but also promotes the censorship, deletion and suspension of other peoples...
more...
- david Martyn
"Yahoo isn’t happy that a detailed menu of the spying services it provides law enforcement agencies has leaked onto the web. Shortly after Threat Level reported this week that Yahoo had blocked the FOIA release of its law enforcement and intelligence price list, someone provided a copy of the company’s spying guide to the whistleblower site Cryptome. The 17-page guide describes Yahoo’s data retention policies and the surveillance capabilities it can provide law enforcement, with a pricing list for these services. Cryptome also published lawful data-interception guides for Cox Communications, SBC, Cingular, Nextel, GTE and other telecoms and service providers. But of all those companies, it appears to be Yahoo’s lawyers alone who have issued a DMCA takedown notice to Cryptome demanding the document be removed. Yahoo claims that publication of the document is a copyright violation, and gave Cryptome owner John Young a Thursday deadline for removing the document. So far, Young has refused."
- Thomas Hawk
from Bookmarklet
I wonder how much of this personal data Yahoo uses internally. I wonder if, for instance, someone from the Flickr team, for instance, can use your IP address to look at other ways that you use other Yahoo services.
- Thomas Hawk
I can't answer that specific question, but Yahoo! is always trying to find better ways to engage users. Typically, however, the IP address really isn't useful, since the vast majority of people are behind a NAT device. Yahoo! uses its ID system to track users and, in some cases, provide a more personalized experience. For example, in News, we had a project recently where we would track...
more...
- Mistletoe Glen
No one honestly cares about a *specific* user (i.e., we don't need to know if it's Joe from Santa Clara or Sue from Fremont), but simply using the behavior as a guide. For example, if you visit http://news.yahoo.com, there will be a "local news" panel that will do its best to determine your location and show you news from there. In this case, the best information comes from the user ("I'm in Los Gatos") and only secondarily from things like the IP address.
- Mistletoe Glen
Glen, but lets say someone was trolling flickr and Yahoo had their IP address. Could Yahoo staff also run that IP address for Yahoo mail or Yahoo messenger? Are there internal controls put into place at Yahoo that prevent staff from using this data internally. Certain areas like community management come to mind where IP address tracking could be considered useful internally.
- Thomas Hawk
Someone *could* run it but it's unlikely to yield anything useful. It's certainly not anything I've heard mentioned at the individual product level. I'm sure that there are data analysts higher up in the company who will track a single user as they move from product to product to see what paths are the most common and for optimizing navigation. When I was on Yahoo! Tech, we did some...
more...
- Mistletoe Glen
There are internal restrictions on accessing individual user information (for example, to prevent stalking or identity theft) along with all of the usual Sarbanes-Oxley audit controls that are required for everything. You have to be granted permission to access most of this data anyway, and most of it is not available as raw data, but as aggregate. Honestly, no one really cares about an...
more...
- Mistletoe Glen
You have to understand what a vast quantity of data is out there. An engineer, for example, can log into a single server (for example, to diagnose a site problem) and see the raw log data. But there are usually dozens (if not hundreds) of servers per property; even if a user hits machine #1 on one request, his/her second request might go to machine #47 or #485 or even onto another property. So data is really only useful in aggregate (except, of course, for legal subpoenas and the like).
- Mistletoe Glen
But could a Yahoo staffer cross reference things like Flickr groups/mail, Yahoo mail, and Yahoo chat based on IP address? I understand that in general someone there would not be interested in the actions of an individual. But if a staffer was interested in the actions of an individual could they pull up this sort of information on a single user and at what level/authorizations. I'm...
more...
- Thomas Hawk
yup I'm not using LR3 until it ships - I simply don't have the time to be a guinea pig
- Phill Price
I tried it on one batch, then deleted it.
- Russellreno
I DL'd it but haven't installed it. Getting tired of LR in general though.
- Adrian
it's frustrating. sometimes it works, other times I can only get two or three photos processed without rebooting. I wish I knew why. Adobe should give you the option to kill a process if you want to if it takes more than say 60 seconds.
- Thomas Hawk
killall -9 [name of process] ... terminal is your friend... assuming you are on mac...
- Terence Kearns
Adobe made it clear that this is a rough Beta. I would have to assume that all the bugs will be worked out by the time it is released.
- Jeff P. Henderson
Still, I'm glad Thomas let us know that it will be a time-consuming bitch to test for the techno-whores amongst us. I have been testing Bibble 5 beta with only slightly better results, but I think I will give LR3 beta a miss based on this thread. I use LR 2.x for my main workhorse (too lazy to photoshop).
- Terence Kearns
if you're looking for fast and solid, go Bibble Pro v4 ... Mac/PC/Linux ...
- Terence Kearns
Canon 5200mm F14 SLR DSLR Lens - eBay (item 180438980987 end time Dec-09-09 01:57:17 PST) - http://cgi.ebay.com/ws...
"This is a very rare Canon 5200mm photographic lens. THE largest & most powerful prime lens ever created for dedicated SLR photographic use. Made in Japan. It is my understanding that a customized SLR/DSLR/EF mount can be created/included by the team of optical engineers who presently look after the lens. Due to its large size, it may be better suited to astronomy applications & others... It takes two strong people to lift the lens. It could also be mounted on a customized truck or SUV. A large geared or motorized support head would be needed to get the most out it. The magnification of this lens is truly staggering. If mounted to a Canon HD XL series video camera for example, a reach of 1000x optical (at least) would be possible (approx 37,500mm). The lens could also be mounted to HD & cine cameras. Manual focus & drop-in filters can be used. With so few ever built Canon spent a tonne on the R&D, not to mention the manufacturer of this lens. The Canon factory picture shows the lens...
more...
- Thomas Hawk
from Bookmarklet
Used condition? Pfft, I'm looking for new. ;-p
- ronin
Thomas, you should buy it and then update your avatar with that lens. :)
- imabonehead
I'm thinking I really, really, really need this for the beach.
- Thomas Hawk
Think it would accept a 2x extender? You know... to get a bit more out of it.
- Andrew Smith
Maybe stack a couple of extension tubes on there while you're at it.
- ronin
*snort* Use it for macro? Reminds me of an old college prof who had an 11x13 view camera with an 18' (yes, feet) bellows—he could take a picture of a penny that was 9 inches wide, but it required 2000 watts of lights to get a decent exposure…
- Mistletoe Glen
What! No IS! I'd like to see the tripod that you need to hold that sucker up!
- Jeff P. Henderson
Cristo, there are widely reported problems with Mac Pros having sporadic connectivity issues as well as flat-out just losing it from time to time. This is because the Bluetooth antenna is mounted on the bottom of the Mac Pro. I ran into this problem myself and quit using the Magic Mouse entirely.
- Akiva Moskovitz
Ah, okay. Yeah, I wish they put a USB connector on the back of this. Most of the time it would be invisible unless you chose to use it as a USB mouse.
- Cristo
Best mouse I ever owned, and I haven't had any trouble with it on my Mac Pro. But I definitely like Cristo's idea... a wired option would be better.
- LogEx
they felt uncomfortable in my hand when I messed about with one in the store. That, and I don't like bluetooth use for mice or keyboards - many a bad experience. Happy to stick with my logitech RF mice, that and my gyro MXAir is yet to be beaten for use as a remote control :)
- alphaxion
I use this mouse all the time now, and it doesn't have any of the problems with connectivity and scroll ball that the mighty mouse did. It does feel less comfortable at first because of the edges, but after a while you get used to it. I think they should have made it slightly more rounded on the edges though.
- Cristo
Yeah, the problems reported have been intermittent. It worked flawlessly for the first couple of days and then began to have connectivity issues. Sometimes it wouldn't scroll properly, sometimes the mouse was erratic, and then sometimes it'd just lose it all together. I was also disappointed that there weren't more gestures available.
- Akiva Moskovitz
"Ms Jorgensen reckons that between her and her rivals the total number of limos in Copenhagen next week has already broken the 1,200 barrier. The French alone rang up on Thursday and ordered another 42. "We haven't got enough limos in the country to fulfil the demand," she says. "We're having to drive them in hundreds of miles from Germany and Sweden." And the total number of electric cars or hybrids among that number? "Five," says Ms Jorgensen. "The government has some alternative fuel cars but the rest will be petrol or diesel. We don't have any hybrids in Denmark, unfortunately, due to the extreme taxes on those cars. It makes no sense at all, but it's very Danish." The airport says it is expecting up to 140 extra private jets during the peak period alone, so far over its capacity that the planes will have to fly off to regional airports – or to Sweden – to park, returning to Copenhagen to pick up their VIP passengers."
- Thomas Hawk
from Bookmarklet
I wonder if Al Gore will be there traveling by private jet again. You'd think that those that are environmentally conscious would be calling for a boycott of private jets. I guess that might crimp their style though having to fly commercial.
- Thomas Hawk
I grew up in Big Tujunga Canyon in the Angeles National Forest down in Los Angeles. When I was a kid I remember a massive wild fire came through the canyon in 1975. It scorched our property, but my dad saved the house by staying behind to fight the fire with my grandfather who was a Los Angeles County firefighter. It had been 34 years since that fire when the Station Fire swept through Big Tujunga Canyon earlier this Fall. Once again my dad chose to ignore the evacuation orders and stayed behind to defend the property. The fire scorched most of the property that my parents still live on today. They lost a few vehicles, a trailer and an old storage shed, but my dad fought the fire all by himself with a garden hose and saved the house itself as well as other structures on the property.
- Thomas Hawk