“Water” hopefully gave Stargate fans what they wanted this week: SGU’s first stand-alone episode. - Eoghann Irving from Bookmarklet

I'm still pretty 'meh' about SGU. I find all of the characters unsympathetic and so far the story lines have been boring or predictable. The last episode "Water" was a step in the right direction but was absolutely forgettable. I'm hoping things get more interesting. - veo

I haven't watched this weeks episode (which kind of tells you I'm not blown away so far). It almost feels like it's trying too hard to be BSG and Stargate shouldn't be BSG. - Eoghann Irving

The most recent SGU was easily the best so far. I think the prospects for the show are increasing as far as I'm concerned. - veo