"That, to me, is Slumdog Millionaire: contrived, pretentious, absurd, hollow, inauthentic, a pseudo-statement about social justice. And yet today the film stands on the precipice of Hollywood's highest honour, the Academy Award for Best Picture." - Matthew Schneeberger
- Vinay | विनय
via Bookmarklet
"He concluded by saying: "We're going to have to apply some flinty Chicago toughness to this town. I'm saying that when it comes to the weather, folks in Washington don't seem to be able to handle things.""
- Vinay | विनय
via Bookmarklet
"A tractor-trailer overturned on the inner loop of the Capital Beltway near Pennsylvania Avenue in Prince George's County just before 2 a.m., Maryland State Police said, but it was not immediately clear whether the accident was weather-related. The truck was carrying a full load of horse manure, which was scattered across the four-lane highway, no doubt aiding the melting of any ice and snow."
- Vinay | विनय
via Bookmarklet
"The return of winter weather immediately resurrected venerable snow-day traditions, from raiding grocery stores for milk and bread to complaining about the habit of canceling school at the first sign of a flake."
- Vinay | विनय
Is Slumdog Millionaire a portrait of the real India or a stylishly shot collection of clichés? - By Dennis Lim - Slate Magazine - http://www.slate.com/id...
"I would contend that the movie's real sin is not its surfeit of style but the fact that its style is in service of so very little. The flimsiness of Beaufoy's scenario, a jumble of one-note characterizations and rank implausibility, makes Boyle's exertions seem ornamental, even decadent. Beaufoy has suggested that Mumbai itself inspired this narrative sloppiness"
- Vinay | विनय
via Bookmarklet
"Everybody loves a good underdog. That is why Slumdog strikes a chord with audiences in these depressing times. But a clever telling of the story cannot hide the banality of it. Slumdog proves - like many films - that globalisation has largely failed to make cultures understand each other better. Because Indian cinema is synonymous with feckless Bollywood fare to many in the West, a vast body of critically acclaimed and often, popular, work which has consistently exposed India's underbelly with more ferocity and vigour than any foreign film is routinely ignored."
- Vinay | विनय
via Bookmarklet
To call slumdog's genre as "bollywoodian" is absurd even more absurd than calling Bollywood as most prolific movie industry
- Paresh Jain
This is the stupidest statement of the article: "The soundtrack is a noisy pastiche of rap, hip hop and funk Bollywood. AR Rahman fully deserves his Globe - if the film can deserve so many"
- harith
Harith: the points he is making is that 1) it is not the best of Rahman and 2) that Rahman's music is probably the best thing about the movie.
- Vinay | विनय
Paresh: no matter what you name it, it's hard to deny that Boyle was trying to make a "Bollywood" film for the Hollywood audience. That he fails is another matter.
- Vinay | विनय
The only thing I didn't like about the movie was the music. The rest was very good. It was just a very well made movie, right from the screenplay to the direction. Disclaimer, I can't watch the vast majority of Bollywood movies (I do like the "alternative" fare)
- Deepak Singh
Deepak: To each his own. In my opinion, it was a mediocre movie. The fact that there were so many cultural and factual gaffes in it, made it worse.
- Vinay | विनय
The music was one of the things I liked most :-) I tire of these opinion articles written, it seems to me, with the sole purpose of being "controversial" or going against the popular vote just for the sake of it. I don't think these "critics" even believe their own words half the time.
- Neil Saunders
Vinay, of course. Movies and music are a subjective thing anyway :).
- Deepak Singh
there are much better bollywood and indian regional movies... this movie caught attention only because it was in English.
- Vishy
I agree Vishy. It is getting a handicap from western viewers (and critics) that it does not deserve.
- Vinay | विनय
i agree. it was a cool film, but not all that and not worthy of the attention it's gotten imo. all things equal, would a movie like this attain the same level of success if it didn't have danny boyle or hollywood backing it up?
- Cee Bee
Vinay, I have not seen this movie (nor will I, but that's a different story)...but would you mind listing some of the gaffes? I'm very curious...
- Far
Far: the complete movie is full of implausibilities and if I start listing the problems here, I will run out of space. Besides it will spoil the movie for people who are planning to watch. I am pointing you to a review which mentions some of them. http://www.rediff.com/movies... (Spoiler warning). IMDB goofs section for the movie also has some: http://www.imdb.com/title... (the 1st one there is a kills-the-plot kind of factual error.)
- Vinay | विनय
"Last Thursday, Lasantha Wickramatunga, who was fifty-two years old and the editor of a Sri Lankan newspaper called the Sunday Leader, was assassinated on his way to work by two gunmen riding motorcycles. The Leader’s investigative reporting had been fiercely critical of the government and of the conduct of its war against Tamil separatists; Wickramatunga had been attacked before. He knew that he was likely to be murdered and so he wrote an essay with instructions that it be published only after his own death. Some mutual friends in the region sent a copy to me today. Read it in full below. It is like nothing else you will read today, that I promise."
- Vinay | विनय
via Bookmarklet
"The potential for foreign donors to the Clinton foundation to create the appearance of conflicts of interest for Mrs. Clinton as she handles foreign policy matters was illustrated by Amar Singh, listed as giving between $1 million and $5 million. Mr. Singh is apparently a prominent Indian politician of that same name."
- Vinay | विनय
via Bookmarklet
Several other donors have connections to India — a potential foreign policy flashpoint becvause of tensions with Pakistan. Among them was Lakshmi Mittal, an Indian businessman — the fourth richest person in the world, according to Forbes — who made billions in the steel industry. Although he has long lived in London, Mr. Mittal, who donated from $1 million to $5 million, is also a board...
more...
- Vinay | विनय