are there no artist names in the US? xing did something similar trying to force celebs to use their real name [which nb knows]
- Nicole Simon
Uh-oh. I think this will be a big deal. For example, a friend of mine, Bill Parnell, goes by Biznill Parnorell in Facebook. Is he doomed as well? (And I know Vicky's secret last name. We were coworkers from 2002-2005.)
- Louis Gray
Avatars deal with this fear all the time. I couldn't have my gamer name 'Spin Martin' there. Myspace, yes. Facebook, no. Of course people think my name is a stage name so I'm waiting for the day. Stupid anagram names. >:|
- Eric Rice
oh, yeah - modern digital slavery 'gimme yr name or gtfo'... feel for you, Vic
- A.T.
Facebook sucks for just this reason.
- Robert Scoble
Every case like this I've seen Facebook has re-enabled the account once they've realized the person was real. I think this is a good thing - it keeps fake people from being on the service, something unique to many other services out there. Why does it suck?
- Jesse Stay
I know "Records" is also a name that cannot be used. My friend ran into that problem.
- Daynah
I'm wondering if being preemptive would mean anything. If you real name is also a celeb name or looks fake, should you contact FB to let them know. I'm sure there are many people with an initial as their last name as well.
- Phillip Jeffrey
One thing Facebook does still need to do, but I argue this is a minor thing, is make sure a human is reviewing disabled accounts before they get disabled. This is why Robert's account was suspended and most likely why yours was suspended.
- Jesse Stay
from twhirl
Do you think they'll believe Oli Kenobi is a real name? If my account's disabled, I won't go back with my real name. Who will be the loser in the end? Not me!
- Oli Kenobi
my friend Bruce Cumcock was denied access.
- PC Easy
Jesse: Imagine Google deciding to shut down my gmail account because they do not like my last name. It has not happened and is not going to happen, period. If Facebook does not allow certain last names, they can for sure check and prevent me from opening an account. 8 months latter, I am an active user, they just can't get up one morning and shut me down because they don't like my name anymore. This is simply not done.
- Vic Podcaster
It will be a lot better for everyone that Facebook spells out the rules clearly. Today it is about names, tomorrow they may not like something else. Facebook has to play fair game.
- Vic Podcaster
Vic, I agree - Facebook needs humans monitoring this process before disabling accounts. However, on the same front, Google is full of spammers and scammers because they're not as strict. Facebook still needs these scripts to keep the "real person" environment that they have. They just need to do some filtering before they actually disable accounts.
- Jesse Stay
from twhirl
"Facebook sucks for just this reason" -- Facebook sucks period and the reasons in the hundreds I think.
- Brian Sullivan
Jesse: Do you work for or are paid for by Facebook? It is great and all that you wrote a book about using Facebook, I am just curious why you have picture with 'Mark Zuckerberg' in your Facebook profile photo? http://www.facebook.com/people...
- Vic Podcaster
Vic , no - I don't work for them - I was just having him sign my book in that picture. I'm as big a critic as I am a proponent of Facebook
- Jesse Stay
from twhirl
This is crazy, you've been using that name in REAL life forever....
- Zoli Erdos
Zoli: I am not sure how to tell this to Facebook. They simply disabled the account without any courtsey email or advance notice. There is no one to contact in the error message.
- Vic Podcaster
Vic, no e-mail whatsoever? That's different from other cases I've heard. Did you get a screenshot of what it shows you when you try to log in? Send it to me at jesse@staynalive.com, I'd like to blog about it. I'll also see if I can find someone at Facebook that can explain or help.
- Jesse Stay
from twhirl
That Louis Gray guy - he always beats me to it ;)
- Jesse Stay
from twhirl
Go figure. Well that's Facebook for you. They'll disable your account, but the 20 or so people with the name "Jesus Sonofgod" are A-ok. Check it out: http://tinyurl.com/6mz2zo
- Michael Forian
@Jesse, not only is the story interesting to me, but I know Vicky personally, so I shouldn't get much credit here for going first.
- Louis Gray
I'm just glad I didn't have to do another blog post tonight - I have 3 I need to do still
- Jesse Stay
from twhirl
but seriously, if Facebook won't allow "nicknames", part of "real life", I agree with Robert now - Facebook sucks because of this! I hope they allow you back on. I'll see if I can ask around myself
- Jesse Stay
from twhirl
Hey Jesse, while you're at it, could you find me someone at Facebook who is in charge of privacy? Wait. That's their Chief Privacy Officer. Scratch that. Can you find someone who is in charge of privacy, because their Chief Privacy Officer is "traveling" "unavailable" or "out of the country" any time I make an inquiry? Or would you lose your access that you got for writing your book?
- Andrew Feinberg
I know of someone who has at least 2-3 fake identities on FB, not even a nickname, and I'm wondering how they slipped through the cracks. I don't feel like playing cop and turning them in, but you wonder how they even managed more than one account.
- Cathryn Hrudicka
Andrew, unfortunately most of my access there is in their platform team. For my first book no one would talk to me there. I can ask Dave Morin though, although I'm not sure if he'll be able to help or not.
- Jesse Stay
from twhirl
I imagine they only do this only with english words. If you were using something like Victor Podcastero (Vic Podcaster in Spanish) probably they would never ever notice it.
- Arturo Servin
Thanks a ton Louis for writing the post.
- Vic Podcaster
Jesse: I appreciate your offer for help. I just sent you the screenhots at your emai.
- Vic Podcaster
Andrew: It is almost impossible to find anyone at Facebook. I guess only way is to drop by their office. :)
- Vic Podcaster
Arturo: I like your suggestion. Though Vic Podcaster is the real name I use in real life and been doing so for a long long time.
- Vic Podcaster
Jesse: Based on your profile picture with Mark, you should have a hotline into Mark's office. ;-)
- Vic Podcaster
An afterthought, I participated in a Facebook panel discussion this Saturday evening titled "Facebook Change-athon to migrate to new profile" http://socialsoftware.meetup.com/21... and I my advice to site developers regarding "Facebook Connect" was wait and watch before running with it. It will be childish of me to imagine that disabling my account on Sunday and speaking my mind about Facebook on Saturday are co-related - one of my friend just pointed out the coincidence.
- Vic Podcaster
Vic - lol - I wish! I do have a video of him playing rockband with his family at F8 that he doesn't want published. ;-) I would never do that to him though.
- Jesse Stay
from twhirl