Who is hotter? Anne Hathaway or Scarlett... - Who Would Win in a Fight?

I vote for Scarlett. - AJ Batac :)

Scarlett. - Que Sarah Sarah

Scarlett - Shey from iPhone

Anne. - Spidra Webster

That is NOT fair. Scarlett but not by much - Mo Kargas

ANNE ANNE ANNE ANNE - embee

Whoever the brunette is (I am celebrity challenged) - Nathalie

I'm on Team Anne. - Joe "Looptid" Pierce

tough choice, but I think I'd have to go with Anne mostly because i'm partial to brunettes - Imabug

scarlett = http://www.youtube.com/watch... - Logan Lindquist

Hathaway - Mitch

I like brunettes, so Hathaway. - Steven Perez

Scarlett - DJ Stevie Steve

I do love Scarlett, but I have to say that the last few times I've seen Anne on television (SNL, Letterman, etc.) I've been blown away by her beauty... and those long long legs! - Mark J

Anne's beauty is otherworldly. It's hard to believe she's real, actually. - Spidra Webster

Ouch, really tough one but I'll have to go with Hathaway too. - ronin

Hathaway - Marissa

Plus, I've never forgiven Scarlett for being in that awful SPIRIT movie. - Steven Perez

Scarlett Johansson. Anne always looks like a corpse to me. - Alex Scrivener

Hotter: The brunette, prettier: The blonde - فی‌ دل

I'm a brunette guy so...Anne - David Cook

I'm a boob guy so...Scarlett - Mo Kargas

I'm voting Anne. - Christian (Simply X)

Anne! Scarlett sux big time - Freon

both, plz. kthxbai! - Joe The Sausage

Winner of the catfight between the two is the hotter woman. End of discussion. - فی‌ دل

I vote for wrestle off in a large pool filled with jello... - WarLord

better fill it with chocolate and milk so I can lick off the chocolate later. - فی‌ دل

Considering the background, I go for Scarlett. - Amir

Scarlett for ever. :P - Anarchi.Co

it's like asking which I like best, breathing in or breathing out! - Toby Graham

Yes. - Bren

please dont make me choose - sean percival

mmm gonna have to go with Scarlett. though both are too pretty to make this kind of a choice... - Sascha Wasek

Scarllet ! - Milad.p from fftogo

Scarlet ;) - ★ Soner Gönül

Scarlet FTW! ;-) - Carlton Hackett

anne! by far - Demetrios the Traveller

Anne hathaway. - Roshni

@Mo Actually, you're just a boob. :P - Shey

anne tabi ki :P - KURTAY

Actually, neither do it for me the way a Kristin Chenoweth or Carla Gugino do, but both girls photograph well. Anne has doe eyes whereas Scarlet has that bombshell figure - RAPatton from iPhone

Scarlett - david la tache

Oh no, men prefer blondes again :) - Citronella

Yes. (aw, sorry didn't see you there Bren!) - Lo the Baker

Anne looks more natural in that pic (which is the hotness), Scarlett looks uncomfortable in that pose. - yurei

Definitely Anne from those pics - Ian Rudy

Anne Hattaway - imath

Anne Hattaway, because she's kind of crazy so I have a shot at her. Scarlett is married to a guy with a six-pack, so there's too much for me to compete with. Translation: Hotter = the one more likely to fuck me. - Ciaoenrico

anne hathaway - she never looks like a cliché - pure style - Barbara R. S.

Scarlett! - Loc from iPhone

On the other hand, Scarlett was pretty good in THE GIRL WITH THE PEARL EARRING ... - Steven Perez

Scarlett - Majento

Scarlett looks like fake. I vote for Anne Hathaway. - deerstep

Anne Hathaway - Hutch Carpenter

I would say both are hotter in their own style. As a personal preference I am always leaning towards Scarlet - Jayavasanthan J

Anne is pretty, but Johansson is Hot. - Friendfeed's Francisco

If boobs were noticeable in these photos, we would all say Scarlett. - deerstep

Onur: Yeah, I agree that Scarlett's boobs just might be the only things going for her. :P - April Buchheit

Anne - David Monroe

Bumped... just cuz. - Mark J

Scarlett FTW - BRҰANSAҰS